@grassrootsrefJa@jtcfc_824 'Impactful' is the new buzz word now with shirt pulls. Before the Isak incident there was little mention of it. Not saying it's not in the rules but it never seemed to crop up before now. This word is going to be used a lot in the coming weeks.
@jtcfc_824@grassrootsrefJa Yep, too often we see blatant holds and pulls ignored then we're told afterwards it wasn't sustained. So what? Defenders know exactly what they're doing and can easily cheat the system to benefit from fouling.
@Telstar22995931@DaleJohnsonBBC Wouldn't impact have been made at the point in which Mateta was going his fastest? He hadn't hit the ground to reduce any momentum...he was flying through the air at the point contact was made
@Telstar22995931@DaleJohnsonBBC Preusmably this just means he went diving in after running toward VDV and it wasn't like he made the challenge having already begun to slow down
@groomyd@DaleJohnsonBBC The panel isn't there as a percentage game. It's about how many panel members thought the decision was correct.
Panel members need to consider ALL of the various factors that make up a pull-related foul. Just 1 felt there weren't enough boxes ticked to justify a foul.
@DaleJohnsonBBC They got too far caught up on the impact aspect I reckon.
Deliberate pull? Yes
Defender focused on the ball? No
Defender focused on stopping attacker? Yes
Made an attempt for the ball? No
Non-footballing action: Yes
Sustained hold? No
Impactful? Only Isak could tell you.
@grassrootsrefJa My point was that hyper focusing on impact meant placing a disproportionate amount of weight on it whenever the other factors in their sum parts were glossed over. The scales were tipped too far the wrong way on this one.
@grassrootsrefJa For shirt pulls the law has multiple factors that need looked at. If we look at all these factors combined then in totality we can see it was a clear error (4-1), instead what often seems to happen is that we lean too heavily in to that one factor that best excuses the error.
@Sargesbackheel@HowardKech@FplThor@bfcgpg Liam Delap did a deliberate running forearm smash in to Djed Spence's face - dislocating his jaw - and absolutely nothing happened to him. Then you see this with less intent and less force and he sees red. I'd love to know how they decide what's OK and what's not.
@Telstar22995931@Sargesbackheel But I think people purposely misinterpret those different factors or puposely ignore them as they've already reached a conclusion in their head & need to work backwards to justify it.
The main way they do that is to pick an unrelated incident then hang their hat on it ad nauseum
@Telstar22995931@Sargesbackheel I do agree that comparing incidents has legitimacy as the many different factors that are taken in to account when making a decision can help people understand and differentiate between those factors.. Such as: level of force, point of contact, where the arms are positioned etc.
@Telstar22995931@Sargesbackheel We've seen a lot of 'no two tackles are alike' comments meaning it's pointless comparing one to another. Not least because there's always enough subjectivity to justify a number of outcomes.
@Sargesbackheel@Telstar22995931 Dale said a yellow was fine but on another day could be upgraded to a red. Subjective enough that you could argue either colour card is correct.
@Sargesbackheel@Telstar22995931@DaleJohnsonBBC In real time and from that far angle it looks like a good tackle where y he's hooked his right foot around and got the ball - but you absolutely do not see the straight leg impact after the ball is gone which over rides getting a touch on it. It looks bad in the replays
@Telstar22995931@Sargesbackheel Kovacic was fully off the ground just nanoseconds before contact. We're always told that when that happens the player has lost control and strengthens the case for a red.
This was another straight leg, studs up tackle. Should be a red for me.
@Sargesbackheel@Telstar22995931 Would like to see the video in real time and to start secs earlier it's hard to judge force using slo-mo. Seems a red from the vid alone given:
The height of the contact
The full sole (studs) of McAllister on show - like Mateta last week
McAllister had a fully straightned leg