@roguewealth Same, have enjoyed this. A parting thought:
If Truth is a person (Jesus “I am the way, the truth, and the life…”) then the approach to “how we can know” goes beyond Socratic methods.
The sources give weight to the claims about the Gospels’ authorship.
It was Christians who cared to make note of these things, so finding writings by people outside of the faith, 2000 years ago, is probably not happening.
The scholarship is more than enough for some and not for others.
The words themselves in the Gospels and the Bible compel me to faith. They are the words of life. I have put them to action. God has revealed himself to me through them. I am not the same person.
What drives your good questions?
The attributions of the four authors become an explicit consensus by the mid to late 2nd century.
Papias of Hierapolis (AD 95-110):
His writing "Exposition of the Sayings (Oracles) of the Lord" was lost, but was preserved by Eusebius.
Eusebius in "Ecclesiastical History" reports that Papias said of Mark:
"Mark, having become the interpreter of Peter, wrote down accurately, though not in order, whatsoever he remembered of the things said or done by Christ."
And of Matthew he said:
"Matthew composed the sayings [logia] in the Hebrew language [or dialect], and each one interpreted [or translated] them as he was able."
Irenaeus of Lyons (AD 180):
A disciple of Polycarp and Polycarp a direct disciple of the Apostle John.
Irenaeus said in "Against Heresies":
"Matthew also issued a written Gospel among the Hebrews in their own dialect, while Peter and Paul were preaching at Rome, and laying the foundations of the Church. After their departure, Mark, the disciple and interpreter of Peter, did also hand down to us in writing what had been preached by Peter. Luke also, the companion of Paul, recorded in a book the Gospel preached by him. Afterwards, John, the disciple of the Lord, who also had leaned upon His breast, did himself publish a Gospel during his residence at Ephesus in Asia."
Tertullian (AD 200):
In "Against Marcion", wrote:
"We lay it down as our first position, that the evangelical Testament has apostles for its authors… Of the apostles, therefore, John and Matthew first instil faith into us; whilst of apostolic men, Luke and Mark renew it afterwards."
Clement of Alexandria (AD 200):
His writing "Hypotyposes/Outlines" was lost, but also preserved by Eusebius in "Ecclesiastical History" wrote:
He reports a tradition of the early elders that the Gospels with genealogies (Matthew and Luke) were written first; describes Mark as writing down Peter’s public preaching in Rome at the request of hearers (with Peter neither strongly forbidding nor encouraging it); and says John, last of all, composed a “spiritual” Gospel after the external facts had been set forth in the others.
They were written decades after, but we do know who wrote them.
Guys like Polycarp trained under the apostles and confirmed who the authors were. (He’s the only one I can remember off hand).
Instead of thinking “relying on the Bible to prove its own claims,” as a single entity, consider the 5 separate writings I mentioned earlier as *testimony*. Their compilation into the Bible doesn’t negate 5 different testimonies (or 4 since Luke wrote two of them).
It’s like Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John giving their testimonies in court.
There are 4 guys here. They are making wild claims, but their stories match. Court weighs that heavily.
It’s worth mentioning that our understanding of the value of eyewitness testimony comes from the Bible. A case must be established by two or three witnesses (Deuteronomy and multiple other places).
Regarding circular reasoning, all reasoning circles back to a *standard* of truth.
For example, why do we give weight to eyewitness testimony of *multiple* witnesses? Why is this the “good”? Why is this a standard?
Why is one thing good and not another?
Because God said it was so.
Why does our reason have a taste for certain things and spit out nonsense?
Because God made us that way. He wrote the life SOPs.
I would argue that we should use the Bible.
The requirement “without using the Bible” presupposes that it lacks historical, eyewitness merit OR that there’s some platonic, clean slate neutral ground dictated by reason that all arguments must be subject to.
Neutral ground doesn’t exist. We all have presuppositions and one of mine is that reason is subject to God and his word.
If the question is around historical merit, Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, and Acts are eyewitness accounts with substantial content and corroborate each other.
The fact that they were compiled later into the Bible and that they are lauded and sacred don’t negate their historical merit.
Genre is just a starting point for how to understand the Bible.
We should establish truth claims. It is certainly not merely guidance. The truth of it is essential in the most classical sense.
For example, in one of Paul’s letters, he says that if Christ didn’t actually raise from the dead, literally, then Christians are the most pitiable and in essence, the faith is pointless, and we should just eat and drink.
My favorite way to have a bot walk me through something painfully difficult and/or tedious is to tell it:
"Walk me through this, only give me one step at a time. I will copy & paste (or screenshot) the output after each step. Then you will give me the next step."
They're usually pretty smart to tack on a few steps that are super tiny, e.g. instead of saying "Open the menu," they'll say "Open the menu and click on Settings".
@spenley No with WordPress because @Kinsta was ahead of the game.
Yes with my app @OpalRecall, but yesterday, not today, because I had to patch NodeJS.
@tomthie55en It was actually Danielle. I was recounting to her that joke we shared and her immediate response was “what about the wheels in the sky in Ezekiel?”
And I was like, “uhh, ohh, dang…”