@DaveNewman64@DAcemogluMIT This is exactly what will happen. Billionaires will flee because they can and the taxation will move on to "millionaires" and so on until capturing those who cannot flee.
@DAcemogluMIT And so you heal a distortion with another distortion. You just named the real culprit: imposing heavy taxes on labour income. This creates a strong incentive for tax avoidance. This phenomenon occurs in many countries. The simple solution: reduce labor tax taxation.
@Andrew_Akbashev You said big truths we all see but at the same time we fail to discuss openly and honestly. Nowadays, competition is widely understood as some kind of panacea. Yet, things are much more complicated.
Not able to produce “favorable results” in the lab? You are a “loser”.
Stay in the shadows of those who can bring cool data to the Big Prof.
Sounds familiar? It's not only about this case at Stanford.
It's about academic culture in general:
- Keep pushing for metrics. Quantity over quality. Look for flashy conclusions.
- Skyrocket your profile. Build your research enterprise. Outcompete everyone in your field.
Isn’t it how academia works today? 🤨
▫️
Albert Einstein remarked: “An academic career, in which a person is forced to produce scientific writings in great amounts, creates a danger of intellectual superficiality”.
Peter Higgs said he could NOT replicate his discovery in today’s academic climate: “Not enough peace and quiet in the present sort of climate to do what I did in 1964”.
▫️
Wonder about the results of this “culture”?
1. Thousands of FAKE research articles are published. 30% of all scientific articles may be fake products of paper mills. There is even a special lengthy page on Wiki called “Replication crisis”.
2. Life-draining tenure requirements that fuel the rat race. Why? To ensure the university ranking and recognition is going up.
3. Most PhDs don’t see themselves in science anymore. In many places, you are not required to be creative and knowledgable. Instead, you should demonstrate you can win a race.
Everyone knows it but few things change.
▫️
I am happy that Stanford showed courage and carried out investigation. It is an excellent example of HOW to react to manipulated papers and unhealthy lab dynamic.
It's just another reminder that:
We should STOP focusing on taking “professional selfies”.
We should STOP trading our passion for glory.
Focus on science instead
#AcademicChatter #AcademicTwitter #phdchat
@BrianNosek I think that the reviewers understand the presence of a high-status co-author as a signal of quality under the premise that a top tier scientist would not risk harming his/her reputation. Basically, it's a kind of rational behaviour in a context of uncertainty and time pressure.
Massive status bias in peer review.
534 reviewers randomized to review the same paper revealing the low status, high status, or neither author. 65% reject low status, 23% reject high status.
Amazing work by Juergen Huber and colleagues. #prc9
"Impacts are lifelong: female students taught by female teachers were more likely to move up the educational ladder by completing high school and attending college, and had higher lifetime family income and increased longevity." https://t.co/z2tBSpcRMB
The Chinese Communist Revolution was one of the most leveling events in history. The land of the better off was confiscated, and those who were wealthy were denied education. Yet, none of that mattered. Those who wealthy before, went back on top.
https://t.co/OXr9yxRyyI
The Chinese Communist Revolution was one of the most leveling events in history. The land of the better off was confiscated, and those who were wealthy were denied education. Yet, none of that mattered. Those who wealthy before, went back on top.
https://t.co/OXr9yxRyyI
Happiness plummets in mid-life
According to an analysis if seven recent data sets, covering 51 countries and 1.3 million randomly sampled people. https://t.co/kjIMnA5E8Z
The effects of the mid-life dip is comparable to major life events such as losing a spouse or employment.