Aswath Damodaran: Nvidia marks its chips up 800 to 900%. That margin can't last
"It designs the chips. It gets TSMC to make the chips. So, it doesn't have any of the manufacturing facilities. It marks those chips up 800 to 900%."
"This model is rife with tension at both ends, right?"
"Remember the typical chip company has operating margins of 40%. Nvidia's operating margins are 70%."
"But the 70 cannot stay 70 because you're going to get tensions on both ends. Meta and Microsoft are working on their own chips because that way you don't have to pay the premium."
Aswath Damodaran On Nvidia’s Collapse & Anthropic’s $1.5T IPO
Ed Elson (@edels0n) is joined by Aswath Damodaran to unpack his take on the Nvidia scandal, how Jensen Huang’s departure could affect the company’s value, and whether he thinks Nvidia is overvalued or presents a buying opportunity.
They also discuss how he valued Anthropic, why he’s concerned about its governance structure, what has impressed him most about the stock market this year, and his outlook for the broader market heading into 2027.
🔗's 1/2:
Youtube: https://t.co/f1ntvUBC8V
–
Chamath says a buyback tells you the company doesn't know what to build
"Most of the EPS gains for many years in the stock market was because of this game."
"They took their free cash flow and what did they do? They bought as much stock as they could."
"That game is over."
"And the tell is the following. I don't know what to buy. I don't know what to build. I don't know what to invest in."
"When disruption is high, you are going to be rewarded for acquisitions because that tells the existing investor, you are trying to defend the moat that you have and build new moats."
"That is why when Nikesh does a four and a half billion dollar acquisition, the stock goes up, the market is voting."
Chamath says a buyback tells you the company doesn't know what to build
"Most of the EPS gains for many years in the stock market was because of this game."
"They took their free cash flow and what did they do? They bought as much stock as they could."
"That game is over."
"And the tell is the following. I don't know what to buy. I don't know what to build. I don't know what to invest in."
"When disruption is high, you are going to be rewarded for acquisitions because that tells the existing investor, you are trying to defend the moat that you have and build new moats."
"That is why when Nikesh does a four and a half billion dollar acquisition, the stock goes up, the market is voting."
Friedberg says AI's biggest opportunity is solving problems humans never could, not cutting costs
"I think the biggest opportunity for AI is on the frontier."
"That means crafting solutions to really difficult engineering problems, to really difficult scientific problems, to previously untractable problems."
"That is where I think that the frontier gets expanded by 100X or 1000X versus AI being some like iteration on existing business processes to save money and make things more efficient."
"Most people don't work on the frontier and they're not pushing the envelope on what's possible."
Friedberg says AI's biggest opportunity is solving problems humans never could, not cutting costs
"I think the biggest opportunity for AI is on the frontier."
"That means crafting solutions to really difficult engineering problems, to really difficult scientific problems, to previously untractable problems."
"That is where I think that the frontier gets expanded by 100X or 1000X versus AI being some like iteration on existing business processes to save money and make things more efficient."
"Most people don't work on the frontier and they're not pushing the envelope on what's possible."
Nvidia's interim CEO backed neoclouds, but. That but was the tell, says Paul Kedrosky
"She tried very hard on the call last night to say, she could have only done more, like maybe put in a heart emoji and say, 'we still love NeoClouds,' but that didn't happen."
"Instead she said, 'we're still big supporters of NeoClouds, but we're going to be much more discriminating in future.' That but was the telling but."
"That's the one that told you that it's all about to change in terms of the cost of capital for the NeoClouds because the central bank just decided the cost of capital needs to be different."
"There is the group most at risk. And they are both the marginal providers of compute as well as already having the most expensive cost of capital and it just got more expensive."
Nvidia's interim CEO backed neoclouds, but. That but was the tell, says Paul Kedrosky
"She tried very hard on the call last night to say, she could have only done more, like maybe put in a heart emoji and say, 'we still love NeoClouds,' but that didn't happen."
"Instead she said, 'we're still big supporters of NeoClouds, but we're going to be much more discriminating in future.' That but was the telling but."
"That's the one that told you that it's all about to change in terms of the cost of capital for the NeoClouds because the central bank just decided the cost of capital needs to be different."
"There is the group most at risk. And they are both the marginal providers of compute as well as already having the most expensive cost of capital and it just got more expensive."
NYU Stern's Aswath Damodaran on why he put a limit buy on Nvidia at $140, but would never go all in:
"I think this is the kind of stock where concentrating your portfolio is deadly."
"Don't have a third of your money, half your money in Nvidia, no matter how great you think the company is."
"I did put a limit buy on Nvidia at 140. I sold all my Nvidia holdings that I bought in 2018 over the last 2 years. But at 140, I'm willing to live with the uncertainties."
@AswathDamodaran
https://t.co/5gU9Z6KTCl
Chamath says Nvidia can't reinstate Jensen because it would throw governance out the window
"He was an exceptional, legendary founder and CEO. He built the most important company in the most important industry in the world. He is biblically good."
"He also made a bunch of mistakes. The extent of those are still not known."
"The problem is that you can't reinstate somebody like that into a public company with that much valuation that has been destroyed, because it just completely throws governance out the window and it puts everybody at risk, everybody, including the company."
"So that's why it's not going to happen. And that's why they have to say that."
"I think Collette is excellent. And she's put in the awkward situation of having to be the message bearer of that."
Chamath says Nvidia can't reinstate Jensen because it would throw governance out the window
"He was an exceptional, legendary founder and CEO. He built the most important company in the most important industry in the world. He is biblically good."
"He also made a bunch of mistakes. The extent of those are still not known."
"The problem is that you can't reinstate somebody like that into a public company with that much valuation that has been destroyed, because it just completely throws governance out the window and it puts everybody at risk, everybody, including the company."
"So that's why it's not going to happen. And that's why they have to say that."
"I think Collette is excellent. And she's put in the awkward situation of having to be the message bearer of that."
Nvidia's lobbying jumped from $640K to $5M, then China chip approvals came, says Ed Elson
"Between 2024 and 2025, Jensen increased Nvidia's spending on federal lobbying from $640,000 to $5 million."
"At the same time, the company made a $25 million donation to the renovation of the White House Ballroom."
"Within a few months, the results became obvious. By August, Jensen Huang had agreed to sell H20 chips to China."
"Soon, the supply of its more powerful H200 chips was also approved."
"Later, Trump additionally awarded him the National Medal of Science."
Nvidia's lobbying jumped from $640K to $5M, then China chip approvals came, says Ed Elson
"Between 2024 and 2025, Jensen increased Nvidia's spending on federal lobbying from $640,000 to $5 million."
"At the same time, the company made a $25 million donation to the renovation of the White House Ballroom."
"Within a few months, the results became obvious. By August, Jensen Huang had agreed to sell H20 chips to China."
"Soon, the supply of its more powerful H200 chips was also approved."
"Later, Trump additionally awarded him the National Medal of Science."
The more flattery CEOs receive, the higher they rate their own judgment, and their odds of getting fired rise by as much as 64%. There’s even a name for it: the Icarus Paradox.
It has now claimed Nvidia’s Jensen Huang, once known as one of the greatest CEOs of all time, who came crashing down in a giant ball of flames.
And he’s not alone. Billionaires and bad judgment go hand in hand. More in my latest piece below.
Factory's CTO says Apple could dominate consumer AI agents by lifting one Mac limit
"Apple is really the sleeping giant of personal computing, because every single one of the laptops and Mac minis they provide could theoretically run."
"Each agent needs its own VM. Apple limits it so that only two VMs can run on one Mac computer."
"If they choose to undo that limit for just themselves, they have a huge unfair advantage in scaling out this compute problem."
"I do think that there is a lot of opportunity for them to dominate in the consumer market."
"In enterprise, you're still going to want to scale on Linux, on Windows. And I do think that there's sort of an unfair advantage in consumer that may not be reciprocated in enterprise agents."
Factory's CTO says Apple could dominate consumer AI agents by lifting one Mac limit
"Apple is really the sleeping giant of personal computing, because every single one of the laptops and Mac minis they provide could theoretically run."
"Each agent needs its own VM. Apple limits it so that only two VMs can run on one Mac computer."
"If they choose to undo that limit for just themselves, they have a huge unfair advantage in scaling out this compute problem."
"I do think that there is a lot of opportunity for them to dominate in the consumer market."
"In enterprise, you're still going to want to scale on Linux, on Windows. And I do think that there's sort of an unfair advantage in consumer that may not be reciprocated in enterprise agents."
COMING UP ON DB LIVE at 1p PT/4p ET:
@DanielTNiles on the AI trade carnage
@cartainc’s Henry Ward on the disconnect between public and private markets
Factory’s @EnoReyes on token economics (AI keeps getting cheaper, but is spending keeping up?)
And a Friday kicker with F1’s Toto Wolff and Microsoft’s @judsonalthoff on their Mercedes partnership
https://t.co/UlvsA20n8W
Anthropic buys AI chips like a hotel room booked the night before, says Deirdre Bosa
"Before the IPO, Dario Amodei told Jamie Dimon that he deliberately buys less compute up front than he might need. So if demand runs hot, he buys more at the last minute."
"Think of it as booking a hotel room just the night before. You're going to pay more, but you get it."
"OpenAI has really done the opposite when it comes to compute. It locked up huge amounts of computing power early, and that allowed it to close much of the intelligence gap with Anthropic this year."
"Anthropic even admitted in its own IPO filing that it's significantly underestimated how much computing power it needed, and that actually set back its products this year."
Anthropic buys AI chips like a hotel room booked the night before, says Deirdre Bosa
"Before the IPO, Dario Amodei told Jamie Dimon that he deliberately buys less compute up front than he might need. So if demand runs hot, he buys more at the last minute."
"Think of it as booking a hotel room just the night before. You're going to pay more, but you get it."
"OpenAI has really done the opposite when it comes to compute. It locked up huge amounts of computing power early, and that allowed it to close much of the intelligence gap with Anthropic this year."
"Anthropic even admitted in its own IPO filing that it's significantly underestimated how much computing power it needed, and that actually set back its products this year."
COMING UP ON DB LIVE at 1p PT/4p ET:
@DanielTNiles on the AI trade carnage
@cartainc’s Henry Ward on the disconnect between public and private markets
Factory’s @EnoReyes on token economics (AI keeps getting cheaper, but is spending keeping up?)
And a Friday kicker with F1’s Toto Wolff and Microsoft’s @judsonalthoff on their Mercedes partnership
https://t.co/UlvsA20n8W