I think the scariest part is not that he tells the truth, it is that he enjoys telling it.
Most villains lie because they are scared of being caught. Snow tells the truth because he wants you to feel trapped. He will sit across from Katniss, pour her tea, and calmly explain exactly how he is going to ruin her life, and he will do it like he is giving her a weather report. No shouting. No threats. Just facts.
That is why Katniss can never beat him in a conversation. If someone lies to you, you can catch them. You can prove them wrong. You can fight back. But what do you do when someone looks you dead in the eye and says, I poisoned my own allies to stay in power, and I would do it again? There is nowhere to go with that. He has already admitted the worst thing about himself, and he is still standing there, still in control.
And he uses that honesty to make other people look like liars. He tells Katniss that Peeta was hijacked, and it is true. He tells her that Coin will be worse than him, and it is true. He tells her that the rebellion will use her until she breaks, and it is true. So by the end, Katniss does not know who to trust, because the one person who never lied to her is the monster.
That is his real power. Not the Peacekeepers. Not the Games. It is that he made the truth feel more cruel than any lie could ever be.
Forever thinking about the fact that he submitted a letter asking to play the role cause he said he wanted to play something meaningful at the end of his life to impulse young people to speak up against government oppression😭❤️