Ticci Toby is the only creepypasta that’s still an anime boy in my head after all these years. I feel like that’s just him. He’s gotta be a little pretty for some reason
TICCIJACK!!! mostly because Toby ends up unknowingly injured (since he can't feel the pain) and Jack has to deal with it (he cares too much to leave him hurt)
please take my mspaint rendition