Ophthalmologist. Built a practice with a dozen staff, sold it for 7 figures, rebuilt it with zero employees. Software runs the clinic. I just do the medicine.
In 2011 I started a private practice from scratch. By 2023 it had a dozen employees, and I sold it to private equity for seven figures.
Then I did something nobody expected: I started over. Zero employees this time. Software answers the phones, verifies the insurance, books the surgeries.
I'm documenting exactly how it works, with receipts: https://t.co/0E15ABaLWq
My post on cataract surgery going underwater reached far more people than I expected.
Thank you to everyone getting involved in the conversation. It's one we've needed to have as a community for a long, long time.
A few thoughts on the most common rebuttal:
"Premium IOLs and surgery centers make up the difference."
This pushback is grounded in truth.
Ophthalmologists have several sources of revenue outside of what Medicare, and insurers more broadly, are willing to pay. We can own surgery centers and share in that profit. We can perform LASIK and cosmetic surgery, and even the "average" cataract surgeon can offer what we call "premium IOL choices." These are intraocular lenses placed during cataract surgery that help reduce reliance on glasses and contact lenses.
All of this is true, but the reimbursement problem is important to talk about on its own terms, for two reasons.
Pragmatically, some demographic areas will not be able to afford $2K upgrades per eye. These areas and patient populations are not meant to be forgotten. I spent about a decade with two offices, one on the north side of town and one on the south. The less affluent of the two had very little "conversion" to premium IOLs, but the pathology and the severity of the cataracts there was greater by far.
If premium IOLs are the new financial engine of ophthalmology and make the cataract surgeon's bottom line, then what happens to areas like these? Are they not supposed to have eye care?
As for surgery center ownership, some surgeons will not take out the loan to become an owner, especially if they're carrying school loans or opening a first office. Should they be out of business before their practice opens the door to patient number one?
Those are the practical considerations. But in principle, I believe there is a problem with accepting a payment for a service that is lower than what would have been the cost of providing that service, even several years ago, and certainly today.
When we are doing such a case, are we working for free? Are we paying to work? It's a real disconnect, even if you find other revenue sources to "get around" it.
"Traditional private practice" is over because it was the idea that you could complete medical school and residency, be great at what you do, contract with insurance companies, do the work you were trained to do and make a good living. That is not true anymore if your main procedure is cataract and your reimbursements line up with Medicare rates.
The fact that you can make money other ways is true and important (and the reason the industry still functions), but the traditional idea is gone.
It's also interesting to me that some younger ophthalmologists don't know how disruptive premium IOLs, the first upgrades patients paid for out of pocket, were when they first came out.
I don't want to harp on our younger generation. They are our brilliant, devoted and brave successors who will carve a new path into the future for us, I know that for sure. Yet they were born into a world where this was just the way it was: you offer the patient an upgrade.
I was in practice as premium IOLs were being rolled out. Several older physicians (my mentors, my teachers) swore they would never, never be a salesman to the patient in their examination lane, and went to retirement that way.
To be clear, I implant these lenses and think they benefit many patients under the right circumstances. But it is useful to remember that many physicians felt a line in the sand was being crossed. Doctors were not meant to have any goal beyond healing the patient, and any personal financial incentive that could influence thinking was frowned upon. Those guys are retired or have passed on now, and that concern is all but forgotten, but they sensed something was wrong. How would they feel now, when for many of us the only way to be profitable is to get a few patients to "sign up," and no one even pretends a practice could function any other way?
Strange days indeed.
I like to talk solutions.
Mine is drastic downsizing with reliance on automation. It suits me. I like small business, and I like having direct oversight of all functions. I think my solution is great for people in my situation (semi-retirement, wanting less stress and continued revenue), and it may be great for those who want to start a practice without holding tremendous debt right out of the gate.
Any other fixers out there?
Let's hear your plans!
@JahangirAsgha10 Exactly right. Having another revenue source doesn't justify inadequate reimbursement, and plenty of surgeons and patients don't have access to those sources. Thanks for putting it so clearly.
Fair points, and thanks for engaging.
On overhead: agreed, 70% is the high end. But at 60%, 2018 overhead was $394 a case. Adjust for 34% inflation since then and it's about $529. Medicare pays $444 in 2027. Still underwater.
On premium IOLs: at 10-15% conversion, 85-90% of cases are the basic Medicare case. Unless you're a large practice with negotiating power, your private insurance reimbursement probably follows Medicare rates pretty closely. Premium lenses and ASC ownership keep practices afloat, but not everyone has your conversion rate or owns a surgery center, especially younger docs. What about them? And premium fees carry overhead too. At 60%, a $2,000 PanOptix fee sends about $800 home. Those fees don't exist outside your overhead structure.
On the course: the lessons are free. I sell the ready-made prompts that run my office. Disclosure: I'm a ModMed ambassador and a Keragon affiliate, and I've earned $0 from either so far. I'm pretty sure of that because it's an easy number to remember.
I teach physicians and administrators the same thing I teach my college-age kids: walk into the workforce with a working knowledge of AI, and in healthcare, know how to use it in a HIPAA-compliant way. You and your audience are welcome to join. The first lesson is tentatively Dec 2 at 11 AM CT (assuming no one calls in with new flashing lights and floaters), or watch the recording later. If you walk into 2027 able to automate several office functions, or at least understanding how it's done, I think you'll be ahead of the game.
My goal is keeping medicine independent. If you've built a practice that thrives at lower overhead as an independent physician, that's great. Mine is one answer. Yours is another. That was the point of the post.
Yup. Ophthalmology has two tricks up it's sleeve that have allowed it to survive this long. A: Surgery center partnership. B: "Premium" lenses that can be billed outside insurance. Both have helped, and are probably how practices continue to survive. The question is how to justify the "regular" case at this point.
Ophthalmology's flagship procedure, cataract surgery, goes underwater in 2027.
What does the end of private practice actually look like? This ophthalmologist is asking you to put on your glasses, because you'll see it for yourself in about a month.
Ophthalmologists perform cataract surgery. We perform other surgeries too, but that's the big one. Everything I'm about to tell you is linked to sources below, and most ophthalmologists already know it from experience.
In 2018, cataract surgery paid $656.27 (Medicare rates). Published overhead for ophthalmology practices ran as high as 70%. The practice I worked at ran at 70%. At that rate, you were paid about $197 and about $460 went to overhead. That's in 2018 dollars.
In 2026, cataract surgery pays $462.94 after this year's 11% cut. It is slated to drop to $444.34 in January 2027.
Starting in 2027, the total payment for cataract surgery is $15 less than the 2018 overhead, before adjusting for eight years of significant inflation. You are now paying $15 for the privilege of taking responsibility for a surgical procedure, performing it, seeing the patient after surgery (usually at least twice per eye) and being available night or day for ninety days. You are paying for that, not getting paid.
And that's before inflation. Consumer prices rose about 34% from 2018 to 2026. Adjust that same $460 in overhead and it becomes about $617 per case. Against a 2027 payment of $444.34, a 70% overhead practice loses about $173 on every Medicare cataract surgery. That's the conservative estimate, because staff wages and practice costs rose faster than general inflation.
So what does the end of private practice look like? Do practices spontaneously combust? Of course not. That's not how the real world works.
Until now, the answer was "more and faster." As cataract reimbursement dropped, surgeons who could do ten a day learned to do twenty, then thirty, then forty. I did that too. But what happens when stepping harder on the gas only moves you backwards? 2027 is that year. What happens when adding two more patients to the schedule solves nothing?
A lot of negative things will happen, and some positive things too. It will be a mix.
Some physicians will leave. Some practices will push patients harder into self-pay options. Some will limit access to cataract surgery unless patients buy add-ons. Patients who can't afford all of that will start waiting longer for routine surgery. All of this will come true, as sure as the day is long.
Other things will happen too. Physicians will step back and ask: what are we doing here? Some will try new things. Some will reinvent the wheel, or at least try to get it to roll forward again.
I stepped away two years ago and built a practice that runs with no full-time staff, using AI automation. It has only two rules: I leave happy every day, and the patient leaves happy every day. It's a micro-practice. Instead of forty cataracts I do four. Instead of thirty patients a day I see a handful. The overhead is minuscule, and in this setting cataract surgery has value again.
That's how I reinvented the wheel. Others will find other solutions.
Traditional private practice is over. In truth, it has been over for a while. 2027 makes it official, at least for ophthalmology. But medicine won't end. It will change.
My colleagues are the best and the brightest, and I have complete faith in them to rise to this challenge. It may not be easy, but inevitability is the push no one wants and everyone needs. It guarantees that change is the only way forward.
Sources:
2018 ($656.27): https://t.co/Qp722RjluH
Overhead range, 50 to 70%: https://t.co/Vkut3Mq1GT
2026 ($462.94, -11.27%): https://t.co/Z8LtxvHbdX
2026 11% cut: https://t.co/VvbFDugY3i
2027 ($444.34, proposed): https://t.co/5uusDELrU7
Inflation 2018 to 2026, 34.34% (BLS CPI): https://t.co/nbGoewtD3Y
@realdocspeaks Thank you ! I am definitely enjoying the process of creating a new modality of practice. Every day is a little adventure ! I am not sure it is for everyone, but it is one pathway to succeed and be happy practicing medicine in the current environment.
@GmOrr9000 It could happen that way. Of course the younger generation has to step up anyway, but as you said, we don't want a true bump in the road. I am hopeful that we think our way out of this one.
@JahangirAsgha10 Years ago I thought the squeeze was driven by at least some level of intelligent oversight and they would be careful to hover above some semblance of a profit margin. Turns out it is oblivious. Just a giant thumbscrew they twist once a year.
@OckhamsRazor4 I agree. We are at the turning point. It's extremely hard for career physicians to acknowledge it. The rules have always been: Verify the patient is insured, proceed with surgery, then get paid. It is just not true anymore, and no one is sure how to react.
@drdanchoi 100%. Physicians who cannot make real choices with regards to treating patients are simply embodied nomograms run from on high. Let's not let that happen. We did the training, we have the knowledge and experience, we choose the course!
It is true that the traditional model of private practice is over, but new variations on the model will now become commonplace.
The ability to do basic data entry medical tasks via automation has changed drastically over just two years. I run a practice right now where the referral faxes enter themselves into the chart, the voicemail box sends scheduling links, and insurance verification is performed by HIPAA compliant AI. More physicians will begin to tailor design practices around the Doctor patient interaction alone, and I think there will be a rebirth of physician led practices in the near future.
@OckhamsRazor4@aceddeca1@chrissyfarr I was thinking of writing about this with formalized numbers from Novitas.
423 !!!
That is definitely below what was considered "overhead per case" a few years ago. Crazy times. It wouldn't surprise me if people call it quits early.
Yes, I did high volume like that myself, that and some conversions to Toric/Premium lenses are the only way to continue to run.
Now I am at 3-4 cases a day aiming for ten max. But I have a small clinic with no full time staff, so the overhead is not really comparable to the way I used to run an office.
I don't always need verification. If it is all established patients I recently verified, or if it is mostly post op patients or if the new patients are medicare with a secondary... there is very little utility to running it. My automation takes some guidance because of the different websites (availity, optum, etc..) it needs to peruse. So I keep it as needed.
I wouldn't return to work in 2027 without the admin power of 5 to 10 employees in your hands.
I run a cataract practice with no full-time staff. Check-in, scheduling, faxes, voicemail, insurance, recalls: automated. No programming.
Here is a QR app to begin habituating online scheduling from both patient and referring Doc. I'll plan a live session HIPAA compliant agents: Dec 2, 11 AM CT 👇
Because I run a solo practice, my job today was to look through the 22 denied claims. Why didn't I get paid 22 times ? Here are the reasons:
Address not exact match. Name (Bob for Robert) not exact. Denied for no reason at all. Denied for "code not appropriate" despite going through computer program match.
We perform surgery on the "chance" that we will be payed a month later. Doesn't always work out, and if you have not found the root cause of denial before ninety days, you have likely performed a charitable service.
I was just talking to another ophthalmologist about this, and I'm wondering how many people feel the same, that we just hit the breaking point with this years 11 percent cut. It used to be a cataract paid 600 and a busy office functioned at 70 percent overhead. that is about 180 for surgery, post op visits, and ninety days of care. 420 was assumed to go to overhead. Fast forward to today. Novitas pays me 480, and overhead with inflation is way higher. The question is, are you really getting paid anything at all.