current queue of megaprojects:
- solve continual learning (my day job lol)
- solve ARC-AGI
- rewrite line rider
- build that DAW from first principles of human musical interaction
- develop a cybernetic theory of psychology informed by prior art (mostly freud)
DAWs are hostile to creativity. You open it up and the interface tells you “your mission is to create one finished song” plus everything needs to fit into tracks
Historically that was exactly the point. Record the tracks from musicians and then mix and master.
How most musicians truly work, I think, is by sketching small ideas and iteratively extending/combining/recombining them (at least mentally) and then optionally arranging into a full song. Thats how musicians improvise: learning many small ideas and then arranging live. I guess like language. Feels like a general optimal creative strategy. And it’s been the most reliable process for me for music production.
Ableton Live made a step in the right direction with clip launchers, but it still imposes the project/track paradigm.
I feel overhead when I have to deal with projects and tracks. I suppose music producers do approximations of this like having ideas in many projects or building up a library or relying on Splice. But I personally can’t tolerate having to manage and organize Things.
I want an infinite canvas as a DAW. Like being surrounded by instruments within arm’s reach, and all these instruments with their own interactions.
So I know live coding music is a thing, is that what you’re thinking of?
Live code could be a flexible backend for what I’m thinking of, but I still want to adjust parameters and have some way of actually “playing” instruments as you would for a physical instrument. But for more tedious things, yea GUI isn’t a good fit, esp if it could be done with code
I saw your project and it looks like your approach is basically having a full featured synth with a fun interface. Which is cool! But I was thinking something more directionally like a modular synth. Basically similar capabilities as a DAW but with a radically different interface
https://t.co/XnYsHF3QVW
Introducing BPMORBIT, a new way to see and make music in the browser
Designed to be a beautiful experience that gets you making music fast quickly intuitive
Open beta starts today, dm me or sign up on https://t.co/XbtspVbWEf
@kristianfreeman Didn’t think my post would get attention. Indeed that is the primary purpose of DAWs. looks like I didn’t communicate clearly. the precise critique is: DAWs are default for electronic music but not conducive to musical ideation like how non computer musicians naturally do it
@kristianfreeman Didn’t think my post would get attention. Indeed that is the primary purpose of DAWs. looks like I didn’t communicate clearly. the precise critique is: DAWs are default for electronic music but not conducive to musical ideation like how non computer musicians naturally do it
@weaselwishes I know you’re trying to roast me but telepathically creating music is another idea I have! There’s this high res EEG I wanna get and train it on my brain waves with a neurofeedback-like set up and see whatever fun stuff comes out
Ah yea I feel that’s the intrinsic disadvantage of anything digital and computer based. No matter how you organize it. Infinite canvas, or files, or tabs, we can’t have spacial anchors
I guess more precise direction I want to go to is breaking away from “this piece of paper is supposed to become the finished product”, like have an interface feel more like a sketchbook page than a…framed canvas?
@_zetier In what sense? I think you may be on to something.
If by organizing you mean composition, 100%.
If you mean having a disciplined process for organizing materials, there may be something to that too
@kristianfreeman Didn’t think my post would get attention. Indeed that is the primary purpose of DAWs. looks like I didn’t communicate clearly. the precise critique is: DAWs are default for electronic music but not conducive to musical ideation like how non computer musicians naturally do it
So I know live coding music is a thing, is that what you’re thinking of?
Live code could be a flexible backend for what I’m thinking of, but I still want to adjust parameters and have some way of actually “playing” instruments as you would for a physical instrument. But for more tedious things, yea GUI isn’t a good fit, esp if it could be done with code
@kristianfreeman Didn’t think my post would get attention. Indeed that is the primary purpose of DAWs. looks like I didn’t communicate clearly. the precise critique is: DAWs are default for electronic music but not conducive to musical ideation like how non computer musicians naturally do it