I will say it till I’m blue in the face: especially at the top of the draft, TAKE THE BEST PLAYER REGARDLESS OF POSITION.
You can always use your surplus of talent in one area to trade and fill a deficiency. It’s harder to build a team by reaching to fill needs.
In 2018, Toronto paid John Tavares $11m x 7 years creating what became the core four (Tavares, Marner, Nylander, Matthews). Four elite forwards that were meant to lead Toronto to the promise land.
They never won it all as a group.
One of the biggest factors was how much money they had committed to forwards (especially in a covid flat cap environment) while lacking a true #1 defenseman.
What followed:
• In 2019, the late Ottawa Senators owner, Eugene Melnyk, said the Leafs "forgot about defense" during their rebuild. They proceeded to draft 4 defensemen with their next 7 first round picks. Constructing an elite defensive squad without much offensive firepower. Just 3 goals in 4 games vs Carolina Round 1 in 2026.
• In 2022, New Jersey was the best young team in hockey with Jack & Luke Hughes, Alex Holtz, Nico Hischier, and Jesper Bratt leading the charge. With their 2nd overall selection in 2022, they drafted Simon Nemec, a defenseman, instead of Logan Cooley/Shane Wright. In 2024, they drafted another defenseman. In 2026 they missed the playoffs with the 31st ranked goals/60.
• In 2024, Chicago already had Connor Bedard ahead of Oliver Moore and Frank Nazar as their future offensive weapons. With the 2nd overall pick in 2024, they grabbed Artem Levshyunov over Beckett Sennecke and, notably, Ivan Demidov. In 2026, they traded their 4th overall pick for a defenseman while Connor Bedard notoriously has 0 winger support entering year #4.
Seems like a lot of franchises find their star player and then are terrified to end up like Toronto.
This is absolutely correct and no one should be blaming Leo Carlsson for failing to live up to this contract. He basically never will. Be mad at the GM who dragged his feet and built up such bad will with the player that he had to match a poison pill offer sheet
All the talk about "how can Leo Carlsson justify the cap hit"
he basically can't. he was intentionally overpaid for tactical reasons. he's not going to be the best player in the NHL, which is what he'd have to be for 17% of the cap to be "reasonable."
Speaking to an #NHL Exec…he suggests if a player negotiates a no-trade or a no move clause in their contract but then requests to be traded prior to the expiration of their deal, the NTC should be voided and the team should be allowed to trade the player to any team in the league.
The better of two horrible options. This immediately becomes one of the worst contracts in the NHL (all due respect to Leo, who is going to develop into a very good 1C)
Frank Seravalli: Re Leo Carlsson offer sheet: Between [former coach] Greg Cronin, between the tough negotiating, there's a real growing sense...Leo Carlsson doesn't wanna be [in Anaheim] anymore - Oilers Now (7/6)
The Wingmen podcast "caused some problems" in the Senators locker room, per @FriedgeHNIC 👀
One player felt it was the final nail in the coffin after all the previous noise surrounding Tkachuk
I’m told the Anaheim Ducks have went to the NHL in search of an additional compensatory first round pick from the Philadelphia Flyers for the Leo Carlsson offer sheet
Verbeek believes the Ducks are entitled to the additional first as Carlsson will have the highest AAV in the NHL
Anaheim Ducks this offseason:
• traded Olen Zellweger for a 2nd round pick
• traded Mason McTavish for two first round picks
• lost Jacob Trouba to free agency
• lost John Carlson (traded his rights for a late pick)
• Leo Carlsson signed a $90m offer sheet
Disaster.