The West has become so consumed by historical guilt that even its defenders feel compelled to invoke the slavery and massacres of other civilizations, particularly the Islamic caliphates, hoping to embarrass a left that conveniently excuses them. But to what end? To force a debate? To make people reconsider? Why would that ever work? The rise and fall of empires, ancient and modern, has always been marked by conquest, bloodshed, and brutality. Anyone with a passing knowledge of the past knows this. The mistake is assuming that those obsessively prosecuting Western countries care about facts or moral consistency, when they have repeatedly made clear, to anyone willing to listen, that their political project is the delegitimization of Western sovereignty itself.
I take issue with the contention that Talarico is “solidly tailored” for Texas in a normal environment. I think that’s where our disagreement lies.
It’s like saying the success of a running back behind an offensive line with (5) all-pros would be equal to his success behind an offensive line with only (1) pro-bowler.
You are representing a tail event as something that will reflect a normal outcome in the future — the same thing I was saying in 2024 to Republicans in terms of overperformance with certain minority groups.
Anyways, we’ll see who was right and who was wrong.
I think that is the thesis. Let’s see how it works out.
From what I’ve seen of the data and the focus groups — Dem brand remains as toxic as ever, and the midterm result is largely attributable to R turnout drop off + fairly right-leaning folks voting Dem to send a message that R’s were not being *aggressive enough* in delivering on the promises made in 2024.
How that translates into a generational realignment that puts Texas, Indiana, et al into perpetual play, while simultaneously alleviating Dem needs to play defense anywhere is beyond me.
Definitely. If there is someone who could make Indiana competitive, it’s probably Bayh. But the midterms were an “asteroid hit the planet just as it was being sucked into a black hole” level disaster. Those don’t occur often. We can’t look at the landscape through rose color glasses as Republicans, but Dems also need to come back to reality.
@_rotimia@elainejgodfrey “What if Democrats can have it all?” Shakes of the End of History. Alas, indications are you and your party are already sowing the seeds of your undoing.
If Democrats wanted to reduce the salience of immigration as an issue to the electorate, they could start by encouraging immigrants to talk like this, instead of making them a part of the Left’s attempt to remake America👇🏻…
"Being in the US is the blessing of a lifetime.
I'm forever indebted to the generations of Americans who built this nation and its institutions, through sacrifice and bloodshed.
My being welcomed here is indicative of America’s unique beneficence in the world.
Instead of working to tear down statues, extirpate the memory of your national heroes and founding myths, or engage in the remaking of America in my own community’s ideological or cultural image, me and my posterity relish the opportunity to imbibe your values, defend your culture, and do our part to ensure America as you have built it is the America we adopt as our nation too.”
Thomas Jefferson and John Adams met the Tripoli Ambassador in London and asked why Muslims were attacking nations who had done them no harm.
In a letter to John Jay dated March 28, 1786, they wrote:
“The Ambassador [of Tripoli] answered us that it was founded on the Laws of their Prophet, that it was written in their Koran, that all nations who should not have acknowledged their authority were sinners, that it was their right and duty to make war upon them wherever they could be found, and to make slaves of all they could take as Prisoners, and that every Musselman who should be slain in battle was sure to go to Paradise."
Jefferson would go on the wage war against the Barbary pirates (terrorists) during his presidency.
Thomas Jefferson had a Quran - just before the Barbary Wars - for the same reason I read 15 pages each of Karl Marx, Chinese media, and Cosmopolitan magazine every day.
Know your enemy.
Extremely interesting thread here by @matthewstoller. I highly suggest everyone gives it a read.
Leadership style and philosophy, as well as intellectual predilections, are curiously rarely discussed things about electeds.
In truth, they matter a lot more than “policy views.”
Dem members of Congress and base voters see Hakeem Jeffries very differently. I'll try to make the case *for* Jeffries, from the perspective of members. Ironically, they like him for the same reason voters don't, which is that he's nice and passive. He's NOT Pelosi.
Pelosi was a control freak, she tracked everything and bossed around the caucus with detail-oriented savviness. To give you a specific example, Pelosi made sure that only a few members could have staff with classified clearances, while most could not. That was a mechanism to ensure that just a few Dems would be able to make key decisions on national security.
She also was the Democrat who took over from the GOP Congress first elected in 1994. Gingrich (and his side kick Tom Delay) had taken apart a bunch of important Dem-leaning institutions to run Congress, centralizing control in the hands of leadership and corporate think tanks. That was the 'K Street Project.' It was a Strong Speaker model.
Pelosi had the chance to undo those changes, but she doubled down on the Strong Speaker approach. It wouldn't be a return to the Office of Technology Assessment and powerful caucuses, it would be the Wall Street-funded Center for American Progress and Congressional leadership in charge. She was a pro-choice Gingrich. Subsequent GOP leaders basically kept this arrangement in place, with Trump operating as the de facto latest strong speaker.
If she liked you, you could do anything. If she didn't. you got virtually nothing. She was in charge. When committees selected new members, Pelosi had a big say. When legislation needed to be finalized, that was Pelosi's call and her advisors choosing which lobbyists to listen to. She raised money, she allocated favors, handed out metaphorical parking spots. She knew everything.
The upside is that Pelosi could whip close votes, and could rule the House. She was able to save the ACA when Obama was ready to give up on it, because of her centralized control of the House. She governed. In some ways, she sort of saved the Obama administration. If you liked the direction she wanted to go, you were happy. If you didn't, you were not. But there were a few significant institutional downsides.
The Democratic Party suffered because Pelosi was a God-awful communicator. Just utter trash. She sounded entitled, she stuttered, she gave wandering obnoxious speeches, and couldn't articulate any coherent goals. To have someone that bad as the party front-person, and then to have the rest of the caucus admiring her, well, it made the party look bad.
On an 'office politics' level, the House was a miserable place where a few people made decisions, and all other elected Dems outside of leadership were merely ornamental. Talented House Democrats often jumped at other job opportunities, because the House was a waste of their talents.
On a substantive level, what it meant is that legislation could only be as good as Pelosi's people could make it. A San Francisco out of touch rich lady, and her advisors, were the ones structuring policy. Pelosi cut out much of the caucus, which means she cut out much of the country. That dramatically reduced the quality of what the House was doing.
On a party level, Pelosi's iron-fisted approach meant that no new leaders could emerge. Rather than embracing, say, the Squad, Pelosi went to war with them. That's not to say the Squad was good, just that Pelosi didn't create space for them to do their thing, whatever that might have been. The result was that there were no dynamic young Democratic leaders in the House, which should have been a talent pool for new people and ideas. Instead the House was a slightly younger nursing home than the Senate.
And Jeffries? Like Pelosi, Jeffries is a very communicator. So to outsiders, he seems similar. But he's completely different as a House leader. He doesn't track very much, he doesn't know what is happening in every corner of the caucus, and he doesn't have strong views. He won't set a direction. He'll listen, he will act if there's a consensus, but otherwise will sort of let things play out. You can talk to him about your concerns, he'll listen and be sympathetic. No one is worried about crossing Jeffries.
The downsides to Jeffries are pretty clear. He's widely disliked as a speaker, he makes the Democratic Party look bad because he clearly doesn't have a view of how to govern. He likes Israel and big money, but he'll do populist things if pushed. He proposed no agenda for the 2026 election, so there's no obvious specific mandate. Do something about 'affordability,' sure, but what? He also won't be able to manage the House. He won't be able to whip close votes, he won't set a direction, and the committee chairs or caucuses will likely run the place. When he speaks publicly, he'll lack the credibility to speak for the caucus. He won't be able to negotiate with Trump one on one, Trump will just go around him to other groups of Dems. It'll be chaos.
He's also not creative. Like Pelosi, he isn't going to reverse the Gingrich changes that ripped out the institutional capacity of the House. But he won't be strong enough to manage the centralized control that implies.
The upside is the same as the downside. Chaos. The House Democrats are going to have to set the agenda themselves, through organizing, committee hearings, and pure hustle. An entrepreneurial member or set of members working together on something will be able to get a real hearing for what they want. New leaders could emerge. There will be bitter fights between and among caucuses. Members could demand real structural changes to how Congress works and make it functional again, and Jeffries would probably eventually go along.
I don't know that members have thought through exactly why they like Jeffries or these dynamics. Certainly the newly elected class has different views, they never experienced Pelosi's management and they don't know Jeffries. Still, when I see Jeffries speak, I am not convinced he speaks *for* the Democratic caucus. I don't think anyone does. And that's good, we need all of those new members from Trump-y districts to have the space to find their voice.
New on Render Safe, the second piece in my series on an American "One Nation Conservative" agenda:
It's the Cost of Healthcare, Stupid.
Most American families are insured, but one emergency away from ruin. Republicans have trailed Democrats on healthcare for 30 years. Ceding it to the Left is a losing choice.
Read it today!
https://t.co/9uVB75zSyd
New on Render Safe, the second piece in my series on an American "One Nation Conservative" agenda:
It's the Cost of Healthcare, Stupid.
Most American families are insured, but one emergency away from ruin. Republicans have trailed Democrats on healthcare for 30 years. Ceding it to the Left is a losing choice.
Read it today!
https://t.co/9uVB75zSyd
New on Render Safe, the second piece in my series on what an American "One Nation Conservative" agenda should look like!
"Sanitas Sanitatum, Omnia Sanitas: Health of Health, All is Health - It's the Cost of Healthcare, Stupid."
In mid-nineteenth century Britain, Benjamin Disraeli's Conservative Party did something many never expected. It willingly angered its base constituencies to give Britain clean water, sewers, and a new health program. Not in one sweeping bill, but act by act. Mortality fell by more than a quarter over the following decades, and the Tories won the trust of working-class voters for generations.
America's healthcare problem today isn't mainly about quality. It's about cost and financial precarity. Most families are insured, but only one emergency away from financial ruin, and the working-class voters at the heart of the Republican coalition feel it most.
Yet Republicans have trailed Democrats on healthcare for three decades and have offered no credible agenda. Ceding the issue to the Left is a losing choice.
The fix isn't another giant bill. Reform where we can, when we can. Get busy.
https://t.co/9uVB75AqnL
Random point that's rarely made: whether the US white population is declining at all basically depends on how we end up deciding to count Hispanics.
With Hispanic Caucasians in the "W" category, USA is 76-77% white, not 60%. My off-hand guess is that this will become a norm, as it did with Italians, Irishmen, the Lebanese, etc.
"The right is very susceptible to doomer psyops, the left takes everything in stride. The confidence the left has in marching to its believed inevitable destination (a form of ‘faith’) represents a huge psychological advantage."
Spot on. The Left believes history is unfolding in consonance with how they define "progress," both philosophical and intellectually.
Too many on the Right believe they are simply fighting a rearguard action that is doomed.
‘Setback for Obama, catastrophe for Trump.’
The right is very susceptible to doomer psyops, the left takes everything in stride.
The confidence the left has in marching to its believed inevitable destination (a form of ‘faith’) represents a huge psychological advantage.