Today, I published a new white paper for @JoinFAI titled "Copyright, AI, and Great Power Competition." Copyright lawsuits are the greatest threat to the U.S. AI industry. If the U.S. is serious about leading the world in AI development and diffusion, we cannot ignore copyright.🧵
@brianlfrye That’s actually a really interesting issue that I wish they had dug into. I’d argue that each database update registers new authorship in the key number system.
@brianlfrye There was surprisingly little focus on what gets registered as the "Westlaw" database. It includes the updated text as well as the selection and arrangement with each headnote and the key number system. I guess it's easier to focus on the text. Missed opportunity, IMO.
@brianlfrye Judge Bibas held that the selection and arrangement was original and Ross copied it. Thomson Reuters argued on appeal that Ross copied the text and the "creative choices about wording, selection, organization and context." https://t.co/EprX2gbG8l
@brianlfrye It sure would be helpful if we could see the 2,243 headnotes at issue. Heck, just one would be nice. It's hard to argue in the abstract. I also would like to have seen more focus on the selection, coordination, and arrangement issue since it's a compilation.
@nicksummy NBC had some incredible Thursday-night lineups: Cosby/Family Ties/Cheers/Night Court. Mad About You/Wings/Seinfeld/Frasier. Community/30 Rock/The Office/Parks & Rec. It really was “Must See TV.” A genuine cultural phenomenon.
13 times the energy of a loaded semi, gone in 80 milliseconds. Truck crash math against the numbers on N722BD's final 76 seconds and explains why investigators are sifting a crater. https://t.co/f4An4EEsZN
@kristianstout@bc_butler Their point is that AI companies are necessarily copying protected expression in order to access unprotected facts and ideas. But it's confusing to invoke merger doctrine language for this, IMO.
Ukrainian President @ZelenskyyUa sat down with @john_walters_ for a conversation on how Ukraine can secure the front line, defend its civilian population, and ensure a just and lasting peace at the negotiating table.
Watch the full event: https://t.co/1SXzjqlOCf
The Global Innovation Policy Center’s Jaci McDole shared a recap of the 3rd Annual Digital Piracy Symposium, noting that digital piracy has evolved beyond a traditional #copyright issue into a much broader threat. Read Jaci's post here to learn more: https://t.co/LBO7UhgVdU
@mmblaszczyk@shanedk That's how Judge Bibas described them: https://t.co/eLXGl41XaW I'd have to dig through the docket to find it, but I recall that Thomson Reuters focused on these headnotes because ROSS's own expert said they not near-verbatim copies.
I’ll use the Supreme Court’s decision in Feist v. Rural as an example. Here’s a famous paragraph from the opinion. Tons of good stuff in there: fact/expression, originality, independent creation, minimal degree of creativity, creative spark, novelty. https://t.co/lGYO9muTCs
It’s the same underlying paragraph from the Feist v. Rural opinion. But the headnotes differ in text, selection, coordination, and arrangement. There are countless original ways to summarize and organize the law.
Those headnotes are divided into “facts” and “originality - novelty.” The fact/expression dichotomy is mentioned first. Each topic corresponds to several headnotes.