@AZSPORTSNETWORK@MikeBasic2 SCA's had those advantages for decades & outside of some 8-man titles in the 80s they were just another squad. They're a beast now because Sheahan's the truth & when he leaves it's probably back to their historic mean. It's ok to let greatness shine as long as it's done legally.
@MikeBasic2@AZSPORTSNETWORK Incredible how people advocate for Program X to be moved to a more competitive division when there are many examples of elite programs rapidly bottoming out due to a change within that program. A program's generational greatness doesn't mean overhauls to the system are necessary.
@IamCoachDRich@theazhouseguy ...you're at one of the schools that literally has no excuse to not excel in 6A play. The format is in place for schools who do not have the resources to compete with the top Chandler schools. Take away opportunities for those schools and you end up like Bishop Gorman this year.
@theazhouseguy@IamCoachDRich Cool. My guess is seeds 13-16 enjoyed that their playoff experience was more than being immediately fed to a program stacked with players from across 2 counties, & seeds 17-20 liked getting to play their way in. "I don’t like it" is not much of an argument.
@AZSPORTSNETWORK@IamCoachDRich That's my point; you move up teams for nothing more than success & expect them to accept their scraps off the floor with no further consideration. The current format gives the 13-20 seeds a legitimate shot at playoff success & not being immediately thrown to the wolves.
@AZSPORTSNETWORK@IamCoachDRich I have no issue understanding the point; it's still a bad point. 6A has programs with 5A enrollments forced to play 6A schedules; it seems like a fair tradeoff that you're more or less guaranteed two playoff games if you're a top 12 seed. AIA has bigger issues to fix than this.
@gridironarizona All this time I thought an absolute rogue program receiving limited ramifications for sex abuse, racism, & recruiting scandals was a bug in the system when it was a feature all along. Hamilton essentially being rewarded for a soft schedule and limp performance down the stretch.
@studmuffin4cm@salonebobo29@1biglizard@azc_obert@azcentral After following high school football for over 30 years I've learned that 1) every selection system has it's flaws; 2) the complaints about said systems are often self-serving; and 3) people are more than willing to be intellectually dishonest to get their way.
@studmuffin4cm@salonebobo29@1biglizard@azc_obert@azcentral Casteel's schedule was out of their control yet they used their freedom to play the defending Oregon champs. Everyone knew strength of schedule played a factor in seeding & that Corona's schedule was bad; they made a choice to prioritize a casino weekend for parents and boosters.
@studmuffin4cm@salonebobo29@1biglizard@azc_obert@azcentral My original argument was we have plentiful evidence that a team can have a losing regular season record & still be a worthy playoff team. You decided to discredit the accomplishment itself instead of refute it and are clinging to semantics instead of refuting the original point.
@studmuffin4cm@salonebobo29@1biglizard@azc_obert@azcentral (Misleading because the "consolation" label overlooks the fact that it's easy to make an argument that the top 2-4 teams in the 6A bracket should have been in the Open field)
@studmuffin4cm@salonebobo29@1biglizard@azc_obert@azcentral In 2024 5A was in the same position as 6A (half the Open field was from 5A) so that much is not correct. Whether you want to throw a misleading label on the bracket it doesn't change the fact that the 6A bracket was an incredibly strong field and should not be quickly slighted.
@studmuffin4cm@salonebobo29@1biglizard@azc_obert@azcentral I will go out on a limb & say Corona wasn't forced to play a mid-tier Nevada team by the AIA so I don't put a lot of stock in the complaints about not being able to select their own schedule. Their schedule makes sense for a program that went 8-23 over the previous three seasons.
@studmuffin4cm@salonebobo29@1biglizard@azc_obert@azcentral You’re not focused on getting the right teams in the playoffs when you ignore that there's a big difference between a team who's opponents combined for 70 wins and another's combined for 27 wins.
@studmuffin4cm@salonebobo29@1biglizard@azc_obert@azcentral I mean the 2024 6A bracket where the 1 seed had a 9-1 regular season record, the 8-2 2 seed had a future ACC starter @ QB, the 3 seed lost to the Open champ by 3, & the 4 seed had 8 kids with retired NFL stars for dads.
@studmuffin4cm@salonebobo29@1biglizard@azc_obert@azcentral A team that entered the playoffs with a losing record won the 6A bracket two years ago; the year before that a .500 team won it. People are getting hung up on records while also complaining teams have no control who they play. The two statements are incompatible with one another.
@studmuffin4cm@salonebobo29@1biglizard@azc_obert@azcentral Five of Corona's wins came to teams with five wins between them - four of those were over the four worst teams in 6A. Boulder Creek shouldn't be in the playoffs but there's no good reason why Corona should be rewarded for a historically bad schedule.
@studmuffin4cm@salonebobo29@1biglizard@azc_obert@azcentral On the head to head front, Casteel did also beat Corona by 28. Again, there's a reason the media has singled out Salpointe & Boulder Creek as not playoff-worthy & mostly been quiet about Casteel and ALA-QC.
@studmuffin4cm@salonebobo29@1biglizard@azc_obert@azcentral Four of Casteel's losses were by one score or less so at least in their scenario I don't agree with that statement. The only reason I'd be shocked to see them win the 6A bracket is they're playing the only team that truly blew them out in round 1.