Students are not inanimate objects. Their effort matters for learning. So we can’t say “If the student hasn’t learned it, the teacher hasn’t taught it.”
@natwexler Looking forward to reading it! Was your trip paid for by Alpha or are they otherwise paying you? I have to ask every time now because people are not disclosing it.
@levelsio@Hetzner_Online@digitalocean People complaining about third-party software being installed by default, like Linux isn’t third-party software 😅
@SamMacD86958750 I think that’s a good example of focusing on something we can control: how we teach reading.
But probably Steubenville does not have zero high schoolers failing classes or zero elementary students with attendance problems, for example.
We should take responsibility for what we control, like what and how we teach.
When we try to take responsibility for things we don’t control, like student attendance, behavior, and effort—and ultimately learning—we see maladaptive efforts and weird unintended consequences.
Maybe schools SHOULD take responsibility for delivering a curriculum—which they can actually ensure—rather than trying to take responsibility for student learning, as if students are inanimate objects without any agency or free will.
🧵
@elwin013@levelsio@Hetzner_Online@digitalocean I’m not sure what you think a VPS is—it’s all software. Some of that software can access hardware directly, but you can’t. There’s no universe in which you can get a VPS with nothing installed on it. Why not default to a safe configuration?
Maybe schools SHOULD take responsibility for delivering a curriculum—which they can actually ensure—rather than trying to take responsibility for student learning, as if students are inanimate objects without any agency or free will.
🧵
@AliBtait@eduleadership@ali Absolutely. Whether your kid is gifted or falling behind, parents are left fighting for appropriate support. Education seems more focused on delivering a curriculum than ensuring children actually learn. We've lost the rigour & the independent data parents need to demand better.
@teachthemx3 However, I would agree that we need more types of schools. Definitely worth experimenting with a variety of models and offering alternatives.
Parent enthusiasm is just a bad indicator of quality.
@teachthemx3 I don’t know the context here, but I would broadly agree with the comment. Parents often have terrible ideas, and are very susceptible to fads and marketing. Knowing their own child doesn’t save them from these terrible ideas.
Trying to make educators totally responsible for student learning squeezes out the most important party: the student.
There’s no learning without student effort.
When a school is doing everything right…how can you tell?
They won’t get perfect results, because every school has a mix of students.
How can you judge the quality of teaching? You have to examine the teaching.