I am actually disgusted by the timing of this drop. And this will get a bit more technical.
Let’s do a real technical teardown of this "1,385-sigma Blackwell weight fingerprint" report that OpenAI and Anthropic are breathlessly promoting today, because banking on nobody reading past the headline is how DC narratives get manufactured.
First, look at the actual CUDA maths: when PyTorch initialises model weights (torch.nn.init) with a fixed PRNG seed, curand/Philox parallelises random number generation across the GPU’s Streaming Multiprocessors (SMs).
Because Hopper has 132 SMs and Blackwell has 148 or 152 SMs, the exact same seed lays out initial weights in a different spatial pattern depending on the GPU’s SM count. In huge MoE models, certain low-gradient null-spaces or unrouted slices preserve faint directional traces of those step-0 weights even after training.
So yes, brute-forcing the seed and SM grid can show that a model’s step_0 weight initialisation script ran on a 148/152-SM Blackwell GPU. Now read what the summary explicitly admits in the fine print:
1. Initialisation is not full training: The report literally states that these signatures show how the weights were created, and "support (but do not prove) the inference that Blackwell also participated in model training". Initialising a model checkpoint takes seconds on a single rented dev node before loading the safetensors onto a standard Hopper cluster. The "2,000 to 3,000 Blackwell GPUs" and "$500 million" cluster numbers do not come from the weight fingerprint and Depue admits in his own thread that he simply "estimated" cluster sizes from release schedules and model details.
2. Zero geolocation and zero proof of smuggling: The final sentence of the executive summary explicitly admits that the findings "do not establish the physical location of the chips, how they were acquired, or whether export control regulations were violated". Depue himself rented a cloud GB200 instance just to run his verification test. Commercial labs that are not on the Entity List renting bare-metal Blackwell nodes in offshore clouds (Singapore, Japan, or the Middle East) is completely legal under BIS rules and leaves the exact same SM fingerprint.
Now ask yourself why a former OpenAI researcher dropped this on November 12, the exact day Jensen Huang was pushed out, with OpenAI and Anthropic immediately stepping in to "independently verify" it.
US closed-source labs are watching their paid API moats get eaten alive by free Chinese open-weights models.
Conflating a step-0 PRNG initialisation seed with a "$500M smuggled Blackwell cluster" hands DC hawks the exact pretext OpenAI and Anthropic want to regulate global cloud compute and kneecap open-source AI.
@davidgbiggs@cptn_canada@OG_Sunshine@Austen So if he tips small he's a stingy assh&le..if he tips big but publicly still an assh&le. And if he tips big but secretly we need to consider the likelihood he's still likely an assh&le....
This really illustrates the incredible degree to which public opinions have been manipulated over Taiwan.
So this French MP 👇, @Aurelientache, simply wrote "Taiwan is Chinese".
Which, on the face of it, shouldn't be controversial since it is the official position of A) his own country France, B) every single country in the world without exception, C) Taiwan themselves (well, the ROC) as per their constitution.
When you speak about the prospect of Taiwan maybe "declaring independence": independence from what? From China, of course. What the "Taiwan independence" movement concretely wants is to amend their constitution precisely because it currently defines them as part of China. Support this movement or not, if you have a modicum of intellectual honesty you have to acknowledge that it is secessionist: they're trying to secede away from China, which they're currently part of.
Their country is officially called the Republic of China for crying out loud. Their flag carrier airline is called "China Airlines". Their oil company is called "China Petroleum Corporation (CPC)". Their navy is the ROCN: Republic of China Navy. Their postal service is Chunghwa Post (中华邮政, literally "Chinese Post"). Their official language is Mandarin Chinese. Their national day - Double Ten Day - celebrates the Wuchang Uprising in Wuhan which marked the beginning of the Xinhai Revolution (which ended China's last dynasty). One of their largest universities is literally called Chinese Culture University. Etc. Etc.
So it's beyond insane that the statement "Taiwan is Chinese" be treated as somehow disinformation and scandalous, worthy of a community note that - as I'm writing these lines - says "Taiwan is an independent nation since 1949". Which is itself disinformation: not a single country or governmental organization on earth recognizes the existence of a nation called "Taiwan". Eleven countries recognize the existence of a nation called the "Republic of China" but that nation, as per its name and its constitution, is China.
This British Chinese @MsMelChen says the "CCP" is why China was poor in the first place.
This chart of China's share of global GDP tell the truth: the Brits caused the collapse through conquest and plunder; the CPC arrested it & eventually (fairly quickly actually) reversed it.
How much tech have Chinese experts contributed to the US?
Atom bomb: Chien-Shiung Wu 吳健雄 enabled uranium enrichment for the Manhattan Project
Boeing: Wong Tsu 王助 created Boeing's first military, airmail, and passenger planes
NASA JPL: Qian Xuesen 錢學森 co-founded JPL
"We gave categorical assurances to Gorbachev that if a United Germany could remain in NATO, NATO would not be moved Eastward"
Jack Matlock, US Ambassador to the Soviets 1987-1991 speaking 30 years ago
NATO did, however, move Eastwards towards Russia, and the rest is history
China accounts for 17% of the world's population. But China accounts for only 13% of global goods exports.
The US accounts for 4% of the world's population. Yet, the US accounts for a whopping 14% of global service exports.
Tell me, who's producing something at 'overcapacity'?
@thecyrusjanssen All the naysayers know more than Apollo Global Management, who manage $550B...recent report they released US S&P500 earn $1.2trilliom in revenue from China...
I'm shocked at how blatantly accepted it's become to hold anti-China views in the West.
I'm especially shocked at this seeing how much China has done for global prosperity in the last 50 years, and how little the West has done.
Here's China's track record: they've provided the world with affordable goods, they've been leading poverty reduction efforts, and now they are the world's largest investor and producer of renewable energy.
What's been the track record of the West in this time period? Primarily leading the world towards climate disaster and reviving its old brand of imperialism.
In the first post of my new newsletter, Global Currents, I explain why China's rise in the world economy — while not without challenges — should be welcomed.
The big irony here is that China is actually orders of magnitude more open to US *branded* products than vice versa.
This is an angle of trade that somehow never gets mentioned but it's absolutely critical.
Take General Motors for instance, the US car giant: between 2009 and 2022, a 13 year stretch, it sold more cars in China than even in the United States themselves (https://t.co/b3w5wqm6If)!
Outside of the US, the Chinese were probably the only people to drive a Buick in any significant number. And in fact, in even far more significant numbers than even in the U.S. themselves since Buick's China sales were five times higher than its U.S. sales (https://t.co/JdCx5GfrCx)
The opposite is obviously not true. Chinese car brands have been de-facto banned in the US with the Biden administration developing rules that "effectively bar nearly all Chinese cars and trucks from the U.S. market" (https://t.co/9bh5UUjyj9) and imposing 100% tariff on Chinese EVs that "virtually guarantees that Chinese EVs will not penetrate the US market" (https://t.co/Quik4PtV0g.)
The key reason for the trade deficit isn't that the US is more open to Chinese products than vice versa. It's because so many US brands selling American products are producing them in China.
If you were to look at sales in both countries on the basis of brands - which country's brands sell more in the other's country - you'd undoubtedly find that it is China that actually buys order of magnitude more US-branded products than vice versa.
And this is where the most value resides. An iPhone might be produced in China but there's no denying that it is an American product and that even though it registers - in Trump's lingo - as a trade "loss" when it gets imported from China in the US, it is still a US company - Apple - that makes the most money when they're sold.
Same thing when they're sold in China. Even though it doesn't register in China-US trade calculation since they're produced in China and sold in China, it is again Apple - a US company - that makes the most money here. Same thing for Starbucks, KFC or McDonalds which are on every street corner in China: they earn untold amounts of money from China, but that doesn't register in trade deficit calculations.
This is why looking at things only through the length of trade deficits is so reductive and masks the reality of where value is actually created in global trade. The majority of profits from products - wherever they are manufactured - belongs to companies that own the intellectual property, design, and marketing.
The profound contradiction in Trump's approach is that it simultaneously overvalues manufacturing (where margins are thin and automation is reducing jobs regardless of location) while endangering America's true crown jewels - its lead at the top of the value chain.
He's making the U.S. ironically take the opposite journey as China, which has explicitly recognized the limitations of being merely the world's factory. While China implements initiatives to climb the value ladder toward higher-margin activities like R&D, design, and brand development, Trump's policies are forcing American companies to refocus on the lower-value manufacturing they had strategically outsourced decades ago, and diverting their resources away from the top of the value chain.
Trump's policies are paradoxically pushing the U.S. backward while simultaneously creating additional pressure for Chinese companies to move upmarket faster.
And he's doing all this by gaslighting everyone about China being "closed" to U.S. products when the reality is precisely the opposite: China has continuously opened up over the past few decades - very much including to US products - and the true closed market is the one Trump himself is creating - where US consumers are 'protected' from choice and US companies are increasingly handicapped in global competition.
Columbia Prof. Sachs on the US trade deficit:
"The trade deficit DOESN'T represent trade policies. It represents spending relative to production."
US CONSUMPTION + INVESTMENT + GOV'T SPENDING EXCEEDS GDP. This results in a TRADE DEFICIT.
US TRADE DEFICIT=MADE IN THE USA.
#Covid emerged in Italy earlier than thought.
Italian study shows #coronavirus has been circulating in Italy since Sept 2019.
How do you explain this?
There are a lot of US garrisons in Italy. And China's Wuhan had the outbreak after a visit by a US military team.