@CharlesHorwood If people find them useful, they should use them. If they know how to use them, use them.
And work towards a more equitable future with these tools that exist now.
@CharlesHorwood Well, our computers, somewhere in their production pipeline have unethically extracted resources and/or labour. And yet, here we are, using them, and hoping and working towards having those elements justly made.
Same thing with AI coding tools...
@anicic_filip@valigo It is models choice, I agree. But I don't agree that the choice is what is considered artistic expression.
The choice is in the implementation, rather than the whole pipline.
In my view code is the way the brush is made
@anicic_filip@valigo You could then expand this example to other DCCs like Photoshot, Substance Suite, Blender, etc.
I think using a mediocrity-derived code via vibe coding and manually coding wouldn't give you any substantive difference, aside from the very design of the toolset.
@anicic_filip@valigo Ill try to give you an example.
I've recently vibe-coded a tool that renders a mesh with a predefined post process effect that renders the mesh in a kindof a line-art style.
Expression there is in a combo of params and what the resulting render is, and how you can control it.
@walter4096@GuiltyDogVR well, game development is not ONLY about making your own engine, its not ONLY about gameplay programming, or design of any kind, or art.
Its holistic. It's about the game itself, and the experience it can provide to players with the combination of all of the above.
@valigo you cooouuuld potentially argue that shader code, or any code that generates art procedurally is in itself art. But I would still argue that it's not.
Not to say that coding isn't creative at times, but creativity =/= art in my eyes
@valigo Im sorry, can't agree on that. Code is not art whatsoever. It does contribute to the overall artistic expression of the game.
But it aint art, nor is it artistic.
@CharlesHorwood I'm comparing them as tools. Asset packs are also, in a way, a tool to get content into the game.
Just like other tools I listed.
You extending the logic that I'm "ripping off" someone by using these tools (which Im not really, except for coding) is silly.