The Left Has Been Running the West Into the Ground for 40 Years. Here's the Receipt.
I wrote that Milei and Bukele exposed the empire of lies. A lot of you asked: whose empire? Who exactly built the system they're dismantling?
Let's name it.
When I say "the left," I don't mean a party. I mean an ideology that took over the institutions of the West and stopped needing elections to rule. Some of its members call themselves socialist. Some call themselves centrist. Some, like Macron, say they're "neither left nor right." Merkel was officially center-right. It doesn't matter. Look at what they do, not the label on the jersey.
Here is what I call the left. Barack Obama and the Democratic establishment. Emmanuel Macron and the technocracy that runs France from the Inspection des Finances. The European Commission, which produces 10,000 pages of regulation and zero industrial champions. The international bureaucracies: the UN agencies, the WHO, the IMF of the austerity-for-thee era. The philanthropic billionaires who fund all of it, Bill Gates, one of the largest private funders of the WHO, and George Soros, whose Open Society Foundations have poured billions into progressive NGOs, activist networks and media projects around the world. And the professional class that lives off the machine: the NGOs, the think tanks, the consulting firms, the "experts."
Different faces, one worldview. Here it is in one sentence: ordinary people can't be trusted, so a credentialed class must manage them.
Everything flows from that.
Start with September 11, 2001.
That day, the West got the clearest warning in its history. Nineteen men, an ideology that openly declared war on our civilization, and 3,000 dead in the most powerful city on earth.
The correct response was obvious. Name the enemy. Defend your borders. Defend your culture without apology.
What did the left do in the two decades that followed? It decided the real danger was "Islamophobia." It spent twenty years explaining that the problem was us: our history, our foreign policy, our "lack of inclusion." It opened the doors wider. In Libya in 2011, the Obama administration and its European allies helped topple Gaddafi with no plan for the day after, turning the country into an open highway to Europe. In 2015, Merkel declared "we can do this," and over a million people entered Germany in a year with no vetting worth the name. In France, after Charlie Hebdo, after the Bataclan, after Nice, after Samuel Paty, the official response was candles, hashtags, and a lecture about "amalgame."
9/11 should have been the moment the West woke up. The left made sure it went back to sleep.
The economic scam.
For forty years, the left sold us the same idea: the state can spend without limit, debt doesn't matter, and every problem is solved with a new program, a new agency, a new tax.
France is the laboratory. Public spending around 57% of GDP, the highest in the developed world. A debt over 3,000 billion euros. The highest taxes in Europe. And for what? Hospitals in crisis, schools collapsing in the PISA rankings, a police force that can't secure a train station.
That's not a failure of the system. That is the system. The money doesn't disappear. It flows to the people who administer it. Every euro of "public action" employs a committee, a consultant, an NGO, a report. The poor never get richer. The managers of poverty do.
Milei proved it in Argentina. The moment you cut the machine, inflation collapses. They told us it was impossible because their salaries depended on it being impossible.
COVID: the full-scale stress test.
If you want to see this class in action, look at 2020.
In March, the French government told us masks were useless for the general public. A few months later, they were mandatory outdoors. We signed our own permission slips to leave our homes, like prisoners filling out forms for their guards. Schools closed. Small businesses died while Amazon had its best year ever. Children lost years of education and socialization. Health passes split society into two classes of citizens.
In the United States, it came out that the CDC's school reopening guidance had been shaped with input from the teachers' unions. Not from pediatricians. From unions.
And who was advising? A "Scientific Council" whose members appeared on TV every night and never paid a price for being wrong. Models predicting millions of deaths that never matched reality. Not one of them ever came back to say "we got it wrong, here's what we learned."
These weren't experts. They were experts by title. A diploma, a prestigious institution, a position on a committee. Never a business built, never a product shipped, never a consequence suffered for a bad decision.
Consulting firms: the metastasis.
And when the experts by title don't know what to do, they call the experts by invoice.
In 2021, the French state spent more than one billion euros on consulting firms. McKinsey was brought in to help organize the vaccination campaign. The pension reform, the housing benefit reform, the vaccination strategy: all passed through consulting decks. A French Senate inquiry called the phenomenon "tentacular," and the Paris financial prosecutor opened an investigation into McKinsey's tax situation.
Think about what that means. A country with millions of civil servants, the most prestigious administrative schools in the world, and it outsources its thinking to 28-year-old analysts with a PowerPoint template.
Steve Jobs saw this decades ago. He said consulting gives you a broad but paper-thin view of companies, like "a picture of a banana." You never own the result. You recommend, you invoice, you leave. If it works, you take credit. If it fails, it's the client's fault.
Nassim Taleb gave it a name: no skin in the game. And that is the core disease of the entire system. The people who make the decisions never pay for the consequences. The politician who opened the borders lives in a gated neighborhood. The economist who defended endless debt has a tenured job. The consultant who designed the reform is already on the next mission. The philanthropist who funded the NGO pays no price when the policy blows up.
The ones who pay are always the same: the worker, the shop owner, the farmer, the kid in a school where nobody teaches anymore.
So what's the common thread?
9/11, uncontrolled immigration, endless debt, catastrophic COVID management, consulting firms running the state. These look like separate problems. They're not. They're five symptoms of the same disease: a class that governs without accountability, protected by titles instead of results, funded by money it didn't earn, and convinced it knows better than the people it rules.
Every idea they push follows the same logic. More state, less individual responsibility. More managers, fewer builders. More guilt, less pride. And a civilization that stops building, stops defending itself and stops believing in itself has only one possible destination.
The good news.
Milei and Bukele proved the machine can be stopped. Not in fifty years. In two. Inflation can be crushed. Gangs can be crushed. Experts can be ignored. And the sky doesn't fall. The sky clears.
The left's greatest power was never its ideas. It was the belief that there was no alternative.
That belief is dead.
Now it's our turn.
This interview conducted by Glenn Greenwald deserves the attention of anyone who still takes democracy, the rule of law, and individual liberty seriously.
Greenwald is no ordinary journalist. A Pulitzer Prize winner, he helped expose the National Security Agency's massive surveillance apparatus through Edward Snowden's revelations, one of the greatest intelligence scandals in modern American history.
And let us be perfectly clear about something: Greenwald is no right-wing conservative, much less a Republican partisan. His political and intellectual background has traditionally been associated with the left. I remember perfectly well when he supported Lula in Brazil.
Which makes his assessment of Brazil's current political and judicial situation all the more remarkable.
When a journalist with Greenwald's background recognizes the authoritarian excesses of Brazil's judiciary, the systematic erosion of due process, and the alarming concentration of power in the hands of unelected judges, perhaps it is time for the international community to stop pretending that everything is perfectly normal.
What is happening in Brazil is not simply another ideological dispute between left and right. It is something far more serious: the gradual transformation of a constitutional democracy into a system in which judicial authority increasingly operates without meaningful accountability.
And the tragedy is that all of this is being carried out under the convenient, almost Orwellian pretext of "defending democracy."
I sincerely hope this interview helps Americans understand what is really happening in Brazil, beyond the propaganda, the political theater, and the emotional manipulation.
Because the world needs to know.
Brazil is not some insignificant country on the margins of civilization. It is the largest nation in Latin America, an economic and geopolitical power, and a country whose democratic future should matter enormously to the United States and the entire Western world.
The question is no longer whether Brazil has a serious institutional problem. The question is how much longer the civilized world intends to look the other way.
👇👇👇
How did Lula go from prison to becoming eligible to run for president again?
The answer involves three distinct judicial decisions. The chronology matters.
In 2018, Lula’s corruption and money laundering conviction had been upheld on appeal. He began serving his sentence, and the electoral court barred his presidential candidacy under Brazil’s Clean Record Law, which disqualifies candidates with certain convictions upheld by a judicial panel.
First came his release. On November 7, 2019, the Supreme Court (STF) voted 6–5 to prohibit imprisonment solely to begin serving a sentence before appeals were exhausted. The ruling applied generally, beyond Lula’s case, with the exception of @jairbolsonaro who was immediately jailed with total disregard to the rule that was created for Lula. Lula walked out of prison the following day. His conviction remained in place, and he was still ineligible to run.
Then came the restoration of eligibility. On March 8, 2021, Justice Edson Fachin annulled the decisions in four Lula proceedings, including his convictions, because the district level federal court “lacked jurisdiction” over those cases. Fachin ordered them transferred to another court. With the convictions annulled, the basis for Lula’s electoral disqualification fell away. The full Supreme Court upheld Fachin’s decision, 8–3, on April 15, 2021.
Separately, on March 23, 2021, the STF ruled, 3–2, that the trial judge had been biased in convicting Lula, invalidating the judge’s acts in that case. Can you imagine if Alexandre de Moraes could have his decisions annulled on the basis of being “biased”?
These distinctions are essential. Release pending appeal did not restore eligibility. Annulment for lack of jurisdiction did. The finding of judicial bias provided a separate ground for invalidating the proceedings.
The decisions that reopened Lula’s path to the presidency were not acquittals on the underlying corruption allegations.
That’s how they did it in Brazil. What do you think they’re planning in Argentina next year?
Very interesting post from a man in Brazil…
I won’t share his name, but he is reiterating what many others have said…
A lot of what he is saying seems very similar to the United States and what happened in 2020, after Trump won in 2016
#FlavioBolsonaro#LulaDaSilva
🇧🇷 Ladies and gentlemen, if the speculation on the just released TSE reports are indeed true, then we have to say that, um, we may have correctly predicted the second turn down to the raw votes after all, just like we did the first turn. We are not jumping to conclusions, as we are launching our own investigation. We usually don’t do this for democratic countries, but our prediction was so off this cycle that suspicious arose within our team. That suspicion dramatically increased when the same methodology of ours just correctly predicted the Israeli Election.
Follow us to keep in touch with the Brazilian situation and international electoral politics.
Overtuigend. Deze dr. in de wiskunde weet met overtuiging uit te leggen dat Bolsonaro met 60 á 65 procent van de stemmen gewonnen heeft.
Ja, mijn professie is statistiek, als directeur van een gerenommeerd onderzoeksbureau. Deze man heeft gelijk. Geen speld tussen te krijgen.
coppolla
O que vai acontecer com o Brasil nos próximos meses? Compartilhe esta análise 👆🏼 Siga o @boletimcoppolla
👆🏼🇧🇷 “Esta é a hora de se concentrar no que você pode fazer da porteira pra dentro, pra sobreviver ao que vai acontecer da porteira pra fora.”
Pra mim a fraude não aconteceu devido a eleitores que votaram depois das 17h. Eu acredito que eles usaram isso como cortina de fumaça para fazer a apuração entre eles e ver o resultado real, viram que tinham perdido e inverteram os donos do resultado: esses números da vitória eram de Flávio, então inverteram no código a constante, exemplo x=Flavio e y= Lula, daí colocaram x= Lula e y= Flávio.
Mas ainda fica a pergunta, porque precisavam dessas 2h e porque insistiram nisso? Eles sabiam que as 16:57 ou 17:01 (dizem que a decisão foi expedida esse horário) não daria tempo de organizar e avisar todos os locais, então a maioria estaria fechado mesmo, permitindo assim que o resultado não mudasse muito do que eles já tinham visto/apurado entre eles, garantindo que Flávio não mudaria de novo o jogo dentro dessas 2h.
Tudo foi premeditado. Artistas já estavam com vídeos prontos desde as 9h da manhã só esperando o comando pra publicar. Foi encontrado nos metadados por uns colegas aqui.
Porque usar a situação do transporte? Porque todo ano temos algum problema relacionado a isso, então não seria algo que levantaria muitas suspeitas.
Nós brasileiros já sabemos que é proibido utilizar esses adesivos em bens públicos, assim como é proibido pedir voto nas escolas… já sabemos. Mas porque mesmo assim integrantes de um sindicato foram fazer isso as 4h da manhã, como mostra as imagens?
Algum tipo de parada nas apurações precisava acontecer, como vem acontecendo desde Dilma x Aécio, para eles “organizarem” o resultado como querem e isso foi muito questionado, até pela mídia, no 1 turno. Porque logicamente que no 1 turno também teve parada. Então penso que se acontecesse novamente do mesmo jeito levantaria muitas suspeitas, portanto inventaram todo esse teatro.
Estamos arrasados, a chance de todas essas coincidências acontecer é absurda. Não somos idiotas, mas infelizmente já estamos amordaçados porque já sabemos o fim de quem questionar.
To understand the controversy over Brazil’s contested election, understand where the votes are counted.
Each electronic voting machine operates offline. When its polling station closes, it produces a printed local tally—the Boletim de Urna. Results are then transmitted, verified and added to the national total. That means the election leaves evidence outside the central tallying system.
After Justice @Cristianozaninm, Lula’s former campaign lawyer in 2022 (so a real pro on these issues), extended voting, the receipt of tally reports was also paused for 2 hours, national aggregation and publication until after 7 p.m. Closed machines remained closed. Polling stations still operating could accept additional voters.
That is the critical 2 hour window that demands a precise accounting.
There are two separate questions:
FIRST: Did the uneven extension change who could vote and by enough to affect the outcome? Publish the sections involved, their closing times and the number of additional voters admitted.
SECOND: Did the national system faithfully receive and add the original polling station results? Compare independently collected printed tallies with the published figures. Recalculate the total. Examine system logs, administrative access and any changes during the interruption.
Researchers have already demonstrated serious vulnerabilities in Brazilian voting machine software. Their 2019 paper, “The return of software vulnerabilities in the Brazilian voting machine,” documents compromised software integrity under test conditions that should worry anyone thinking about congratulating Lula on his “win”.
Read it here:
https://t.co/XtIxNnAncg
The public should not have to accept unexplained assurances from Lula.
Preserve the evidence. Publish the records. Permit independent verification.
🇺🇸🇧🇷 Senhores, faz duas semanas que venho alertando sobre a situação política frágil dos Republicanos e da administração Trump aqui nos EUA. Ontem, após o resultado da apuração, comentei que qualquer movimento vindo de Donald Trump seria improvável, devido à proximidade com o pleito eleitoral.
A parte da política interna brasileira está clara. A oposição já recebeu o recado e cortaram a cabeça do “rei” e do “príncipe”; quem quiser sobreviver deverá se curvar. Deltan Dallagnol é o próximo na mira para servir de exemplo.
Estamos assistindo no Brasil o mesmo sistema implementado na Venezuela, principalmente com todo expediente aplicado no ano de 2015, como detalho em meus livros do Foro de São Paulo. Sei que muitos ficarão chateados com o que vou escrever, mas, na fotografia de hoje, a oposição já foi domesticada; poucos homens e mulheres de valor continuarão sendo uma oposição verdadeira.
Agora, o “virar Venezuela” que todo mundo confunde ser a profunda crise econômica, não é mais um “SE”, tornou-se “QUANDO”.
Hoje saiu 1 TRILHÃO de reais da economia, os que estão nas ruas pulando comemorando tudo de graça, não se perguntam que para cada direito adquirido, outras duas ou três pessoas estão pagando por ele.
Quem vai pagar a conta de Luz de graça, gás de graça, dinheiro para ficar na escola, dinheiro para ficar na faculdade, dinheiro do Bolsa Família, rombo do roubo da previdência e afins?
Brasil, o país do futuro… QUE NUNCA CHEGA.
Aqui ainda debruçada sobre papéis, contas, estatísticas, números, fatos. Nada faz o menor sentido.
𝐏𝐫𝐢𝐦𝐞𝐢𝐫𝐨 𝐭𝐮𝐫𝐧𝐨:
- Maior bancada de direita da história na Câmara e no Senado.
- Maior número de governadores de direita.
- Flávio na frente. Lula o único candidato de esquerda.
(Votos da direita divididos entre 3 candidatos).
𝐒𝐞𝐠𝐮𝐧𝐝𝐨 𝐭𝐮𝐫𝐧𝐨:
- Quase todos os votos dos outros candidatos de direita vão para Lula.
- Milhões saíram da abstenção em número histórico.
- Virada histórica de Lula 𝐞𝐦 𝐭𝐨𝐝𝐨𝐬 𝐨𝐬 𝐞𝐬𝐭𝐚𝐝𝐨𝐬. Em apenas três semanas, quem elegeu o Congresso mais conservador/liberal da história resolveru votar no Lula.
- Lula cresceu em 5.838 municípios e Flávio apenas em 184.
𝐁𝐎̂𝐍𝐔𝐒 𝐁𝐑𝐀𝐒𝐈𝐋 𝟐𝟎𝟐𝟔:
- Pesquisas que sempre erraram para a esquerda davam vitória ao Flávio. Mapa do primeiro turno majoritariamente azul.
- 4º mandato de um presidente nada popular.
- Virada inédita do 1º para o 2º turno.
- Queda histórica de nulos e brancos.
- Ex-advogado do candidato (indicado por ele ao STF) atendendo pedido para interromper a possível vitória do oponente.
- Fiscais expulsos da sala-cofre.
- Usurpação de competência do TSE pelo STF.
- Suspensão da apuração após o início.
- Datafolha e mais 18 pesquisas e trackings errando o vencedor.
🤯Em poucas horas, Lula sai da maior rejeição em 30 anos como político para o maior fenômeno eleitoral da história do Brasil. Fenômeno absoluto em estados profundamente conservadores como GO, MT, SC, PR e RS.
🤡Mas tudo dentro da normalidade democrática, claro. A da Venezuela.
I warned yesterday that the decisive test for Brazil would come AFTER the election. Would Brazil return to normal democratic competition or follow Venezuela’s path after December 2015?
That test applies regardless of who ultimately wins or loses the contested election.
Last night, Lula used his victory speech to promise greater regulation of social media platforms he accused of interfering against him. Today, his opponent—who is challenging the result—says Alexandre de Moraes has ordered him to surrender his passports and forbidden him from leaving Brazil.
Venezuela’s warning is precisely this. After the opposition won parliament in December 2015, courts became instruments of Maduro for stripping that victory of its practical meaning. Democratic institutions retained their names while entirely losing their independence. Maduro never left until he was removed by force.
Lawfare becomes a means of consolidating power when opponents can participate in elections but cannot safely challenge those who govern.
This is what the U.S. and other governments should examine as it weighs recognition. The question extends beyond the tally to whether Brazil will preserve meaningful political competition afterward.
If Brazil is returning to normal, demonstrate it Lula and Moraes. Protect lawful dissent, permit election challenges and justify every restriction through evidence and due process.
Winning an election, if Lula even won it, would confer authority to govern. It confers no authority to extinguish the opposition.
Como FALSO COMPARECIMENTO deixa sinais claros, caríssimo eleitor, fique ligado.
Se você chegar à seção e o mesário disser que você JÁ VOTOU, a urna não será liberada de novo no seu título.
Você não vai votar.
O que você faz nos 15 minutos seguintes é o que decide se o crime vira inquérito ou vira estatística.
- NÃO SAIA DA SEÇÃO. Quem sai sem registro vira "não compareceu".
- Exija que o presidente da mesa registre a ocorrência na ATA DA MESA RECEPTORA, com seu nome, número do título, hora e a frase "eleitor compareceu e foi informado de que seu título já constava como votado".
- Peça para ler o que ele escreveu antes de qualquer outra coisa.
- Peça para ver o CADERNO DE VOTAÇÃO. É ali que está a assinatura (ou a digital) de quem votou com o seu título. Fotografe a página. Celular é proibido na cabina, não na seção.
- Exija a DECLARAÇÃO DE COMPARECIMENTO SEM VOTO. Sem ela você não tem como provar que esteve lá e ainda pode levar multa por ausência.
- Peça que o presidente da mesa ACIONE O JUIZ ELEITORAL. O Código Eleitoral manda: se há dúvida sobre identidade, é o juiz que decide, não o mesário.
- Se houver FISCAL DE PARTIDO na seção, chame-o para testemunhar e assinar junto a ocorrência na ata.
- No mesmo dia, registre BOLETIM DE OCORRÊNCIA na Polícia Federal (ou na delegacia civil mais próxima) por crime do art. 309 do Código Eleitoral: votar em lugar de outrem, reclusão de até 3 anos. Leve a foto do caderno e a declaração.
- Guarde tudo e protocole no CARTÓRIO ELEITORAL da sua zona na segunda-feira.
Em 2022, o TRE-MG admitiu casos de eleitores barrados porque outra pessoa já tinha votado e assinado o caderno; a resposta oficial foi "registrar em ata" e mandar para a PF.
Quem não exigiu o registro simplesmente não existe no processo.
Ata registrada, caderno fotografado, declaração na mão, BO feito. Nessa ordem.
Fontes: Manual do Mesário 2026 (Justiça Eleitoral), Res. TSE 23.751/2026, art. 309 do Código Eleitoral, TRE-MG (out/2022), Fato ou Boato/TRE-RJ (out/2022, caso de Queimados, eleitor orientado a registrar BO e que recusou a declaração de comparecimento).