@BodiedbyKai@HIEI_FUSSBALL@LrdSeitan@RanMah10@Quality_JWC Again, if you'd like you can simulate winning the argument by leaving the last reply, I'm bad at stopping arguing with someone when I know they're full of shit, I'll fully admit that, but I'm actually done now lol
@BodiedbyKai@HIEI_FUSSBALL@LrdSeitan@RanMah10@Quality_JWC lol the IAGS is an “activist echo chamber” but you know better than the actual scholars of genocide. You have again demonstrated you have no understanding of why the IAGC proceeds with votes in the manner it does.
@BodiedbyKai@HIEI_FUSSBALL@LrdSeitan@RanMah10@Quality_JWC “all who vote more than likely are activated in some way shape or form by the comments made by Israeli officials or the public display of destruction in Gaza.”
Analyzing state rhetoric and physical destruction is literally the foundational methodology of genocide scholarship.
@BodiedbyKai@HIEI_FUSSBALL@LrdSeitan@RanMah10@Quality_JWC No, the IAGS did not change or lower the legal criteria. In fact, the text of their resolution explicitly relies on the standard, literal definition.
https://t.co/ny3xUcEO89…
@BodiedbyKai@HIEI_FUSSBALL@LrdSeitan@RanMah10@Quality_JWC No, the IAGS did not change or lower the legal criteria. In fact, the text of their resolution explicitly relies on the standard, literal definition.
https://t.co/7DKqyfEKtw
@BodiedbyKai@HIEI_FUSSBALL@LrdSeitan@RanMah10@Quality_JWC It’s not just one NGO this has long been a matter of debate in genocide studies. And in fact, the “bigger party” of genocide scholars agree Israel is committing genocide.
https://t.co/7DKqyfEKtw
I’m done arguing because you dismiss all evidence you don’t like.
@BodiedbyKai@HIEI_FUSSBALL@LrdSeitan@RanMah10@Quality_JWC It’s not just one NGO this has long been a matter of debate in genocide studies. And in fact, the “bigger party” of genocide scholars agree Israel is committing genocide.
https://t.co/7DKqyfEKtw
I’m done arguing because you dismiss all evidence you don’t like.
@BodiedbyKai@HIEI_FUSSBALL@LrdSeitan@RanMah10@Quality_JWC Do you really not see how stupid what you just said is? 26% to 28% turnout is completely typical for the organization's voting history, rather than a sign of a broken mechanism. This is how these organizations work, there is nothing special about the turnout in the case of Gaza
@BodiedbyKai@HIEI_FUSSBALL@LrdSeitan@RanMah10@Quality_JWC And besides that point, you claim the genocide scholars are wrong too, there’s no point engaging with you because you simply dismiss the work of actual scholars of genocide
@BodiedbyKai@HIEI_FUSSBALL@LrdSeitan@RanMah10@Quality_JWC kept impossibly high, the Genocide Convention becomes functionally useless during active wars because states will always use "counter-terrorism" or "self-defense" as a legal shield to obscure their intent.