@noqtiscom@Darkiux86@valigo Why must aesthetics or expression be art's sole purpose for something to qualify as art? You haven't justified that premise. You're free to define art that way, but I have no interest in your personal definition.
@noqtiscom@Darkiux86@valigo You confuse what buildings must do with what architecture can pursue. Safety is a requirement, not its sole purpose. Many buildings sacrifice practicality for aesthetics. Engineering constraints don't negate artistic value.
@noqtiscom@Darkiux86@valigo I won't pretend that art has a definitive conclusion. To be honest, there are too many points to discuss, and sometimes it's just a matter of different definitions of personal expectations. My true perspective leans more towards the unconventional, while yours seems to lean less
@noqtiscom@Darkiux86@valigo There are multiple levels of definitional disputes here. You can narrow down your definition further and make the image the only form of art.
@Darkiux86@valigo It takes me a while to explain this to you; your argument lacks rigor, so I wanted to get AI to help. It seems Grok couldn't help me.
@Darkiux86@valigo 5/5 (9) Grant that drawing and coding depend on math differently. The point about choices between implementations still stands. (10) Even if computers need math concepts and humans don't, a human could still make an artistic choice in writing a program.
@Darkiux86@valigo 4/5 (7) If you mean humans can exist without math concepts, agreed. Inventing them doesn't put us outside the patterns they describe. (8) Chaotic systems can obey exact equations yet resist long-term prediction. Human unpredictability wouldn't imply an absence of rules either.