Take an uncensored look at the world of free expression through personal stories and candid conversations. Created by @TheFIREorg. Hosted by @nicoperrino.
Ep. 286: Trump vs. the Smithsonian: Who controls America’s history? w/ Jessica Dickinson Goodman
The @smithsonian Institution in Washington, D.C., is the world’s largest museum, education, and research complex. Over the past year, hundreds of ordinary Americans have been photographing its exhibits — not because they’re enthusiastic tourists, but because they’re afraid parts of American history could be altered or even disappear because of political pressure.
Nearly 180 years after Congress created the Smithsonian, the White House is trying to change how the nation’s museums tell the American story. It has demanded reviews of exhibits, threatened federal funding, targeted museum leaders, and ordered government signs posted outside the National Museum of American History warning visitors that the museum is ideologically biased.
In response, a grassroots organization called Citizen Historians for the Smithsonian has mobilized hundreds of volunteers to document every Smithsonian exhibit in Washington, D.C., and New York City. So far, they’ve compiled an archive of more than 73,000 photos and videos.
Joining @TheFIREorg's @NicoPerrino to discuss the administration’s attacks on—or reforms of—the Smithsonian, is Jessica Dickinson Goodman, co-founder of Citizen Historians for the Smithsonian.
Timestamps:
00:00 Preorder Nico’s book Free Speech Generation
01:04 Intro
03:05 The origins of Citizen Historians for the Smithsonian
04:48 The chilling effect on museum staff
06:58 Changes to Smithsonian exhibits and national parks
11:50 Who should decide how history is told?
20:30 The White House’s objections to Smithsonian exhibits
32:26 Impact on America’s 250th anniversary celebrations
37:28 Could political pressure strengthen public resistance?
44:35 Editorial independence in public institutions
51:50 The future of the Smithsonian’s independence
55:46 Outro
When “harm” becomes the argument, does it become a blank check to shut down speech?
@RobbySoave on the “emotional blackmail” that shaped campus speech battles:
Two things can be true at once: You can oppose Trump’s actions in Venezuela and still believe removing Maduro benefited people who lived under his rule.
In a recent episode of @thefireorg's So to Speak podcast, Stephen D. Solomon, founding editor of First Amendment Watch, gave his opinion on the original intent of the First Amendment.
Hear more of this discussion at the link in our bio.
Imagine visiting a national park and finding two mangled posts where an informational sign used to stand.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman describes what happened to a sign about climate change and why groups like Save Our Signs and Citizen Historians for the Smithsonian are documenting changes to America's public institutions.
The Founders made a compromise over slavery. But did they have to?
It's a difficult question. And one that forces us to consider not just the choices the Founders made, but the choices they could have made.
In a recent podcast episode with @thefireorg, Stephen D. Solomon, founding editor of First Amendment Watch, discussed the original meaning of the First Amendment alongside Stanford law professor Jud Campbell.
Watch the full episode at the link in our bio.
In 1902, the Free Speech League was formed. It was America's first national organization dedicated solely to defending free speech as an end in itself.
Earlier groups had advocated for free speech, too. But they typically did so because their advocacy for other causes — labor, women's rights, or opposition to war — was being censored.
The Free Speech League had no other cause. Just free speech.
Its first event was a fundraiser for sex educator Ida Craddock, who had been jailed for distributing information about sexual intimacy. Reports noted that hardly anyone in attendance agreed with her views.
But as League President Edwin Walker explained, “Her opinions do not concern us. We simply stand for liberty. Whatever views we may hold, at bottom there is only one issue — the right to express our thoughts.”
Unfortunately, the League lost most of its free speech battles during its existence. But its work helped lay the groundwork for what we at @TheFIREorg do today.
There's a straight line from that first gathering of free speech advocates in 1902 to FIRE's Soapbox conference last week. Both brought together advocates from across the political and ideological spectrum to defend one core American value that will forever be challenged.
Thank you to everyone who attended and to those who support the cause from afar. We are all the inheritors of a long and proud tradition of freedom — one that must be defended in every generation!
The White House has a problem with butterflies.
In a report criticizing the Smithsonian, they cited butterfly images as evidence of immigration reform support.
The issue: some of the objects it cited are from decades before butterflies became a DACA symbol.
What could go wrong with politicians deciding how much criticism is too much?
Stephen Solomon says lawmakers tend to protect themselves from the speech that makes them uncomfortable.
It’s easy to be mean to a username.
That's a lot harder when there’s a voice on the other end.
New research in @NatureComms found that spoken disagreements tend to produce more understanding and less conflict than written ones — suggesting some arguments are better talked through than typed out.
In Venezuela, criticizing Maduro in a text message could land you in jail.
You didn’t have to be a journalist. You didn’t have to be a politician. Just a citizen with an opinion.
Could a flat-earther be better at defending their beliefs than you are?
Maybe.
If you’ve never had to defend something you take for granted, those argumentative muscles can get pretty weak.
That’s one reason hearing bad arguments can actually be useful.
Ep. 285: Why you should talk to strangers w/ Fin Colleton and Kratima Divakar
Growing up, most of us learned one simple rule: don’t talk to strangers.
But American Dialogues is betting on the opposite.
In New York City parks, the group’s organizers set out folding chairs and invite anybody passing by to sit down and talk about politics, culture, and everyday life. The goal is to get strangers to speak honestly and keep listening when the conversation becomes difficult.
Joining @TheFIREorg's @NicoPerrino to discuss how American Dialogues began, what happens when strangers disagree, and whether these conversations can help bridge America’s divides are Fin Colleton, @Columbia Trust Collaboratory student fellow and the creator of the public conversation tables that grew into American Dialogues; and Kratima Divakar, @ColumbiaSIPA graduate student and Trust Collaboratory student fellow who leads American Dialogues’ outreach.
Check out more about American Dialogues’ work at https://t.co/mYUuFYxZHL or @americandialogues on Instagram.
Preorder Nico’s book and fill out the form for a free tshirt at https://t.co/0Ht9JbBASA.
Timestamps:
00:00 Preorder Nico's book and get a free tshirt!
01:55 Intro
03:36 Fin’s first experiment with talking to strangers
05:54 Kratima’s introduction to Listening Tables
07:32 Bringing American Dialogues to New York City
10:43 Conversations across political divides
14:32 How do they handle disruptive participants?
19:52 The purpose of American Dialogues
28:16 Why New York City is the perfect venue
32:07 Online versus face-to-face conversations
33:56 Expanding American Dialogues
37:34 Outro
What does social media look like when the government controls the airwaves?
In Venezuela, it became a lifeline to reliable information.
@jimepstein explains how Venezuelans used social platforms, VPNs, and other online tools to keep information moving as traditional media was censored.
Hugo Chávez didn’t initially campaign as a socialist.
In fact, when asked about it, he reportedly mocked the idea: “I’m a capitalist.”
So how did he go from that to holding up Lenin and openly embracing socialism?
Hugo Chávez understood something about Twitter very early: You could use it to attack journalists and speak directly to your supporters while doing it.
@iamgermania says that playbook should look familiar to Americans.
In Venezuela, criticizing Maduro in a text message could land you in jail. And pushing for political change can become “terrorism.”
@iamgermania and @nicoperrino explain how vague speech laws can turn ordinary dissent into a crime.
Hugo Chavez didn’t just call Venezuela’s most popular media company biased.
He labeled it a dangerous propaganda machine that was destabilizing the country.
@jimepstein explains why that angle made taking RCTV off the air seem justified.