I think there are three different things that are meant by the word morality.
- There is the habit of judging actions or people as good or bad, that is kind of like a parasite that reproduces itself across minds. When one person judges another, the latter might feel suffering, leading then to imagine the judgment in the future so that they can predict and avoid it. This judgment becomes a habit and then is unconsciously applied to others as well, perpetuating it.
- If you habitually imagine other people’s emotions (what people call empathy), then their suffering feels viscerally real, and this leads to preferences about outcomes and actions.
- Certain kinds of attitudes and actions feel more profound, correct, or sacred. Usually those actions shift attention away from the self, or are unconditional and do not depend on outcomes. In these cases people are confusing relief with morality. Actions that decenter the self often but not always look like altruistic. However it is possible to decenter the self while remaining indifferent to others
Some of these things can produce the sense that life has meaning. Most people are running combinations of all three. In the end it doesn’t matter if life has meaning because we have direct perception of joy, vitality and beauty, which make the enterprise worthwhile. Meaning comes into play when one is sufficiently alienated from direct perception to experience the absence of pain, a sense of safety, relief from self-monitoring, guilt, or shame, or hope of future joy as valuable things in themselves instead of recognizing them as proxies.
I think there are three different things that are meant by the word morality.
- There is the habit of judging actions or people as good or bad, that is kind of like a parasite that reproduces itself across minds. When one person judges another, the latter might feel suffering, leading then to imagine the judgment in the future so that they can predict and avoid it. This judgment becomes a habit and then is unconsciously applied to others as well, perpetuating it.
- If you habitually imagine other people’s emotions (what people call empathy), then their suffering feels viscerally real, and this leads to preferences about outcomes and actions.
- Certain kinds of attitudes and actions feel more profound, correct, or sacred. Usually those actions shift attention away from the self, or are unconditional and do not depend on outcomes. In these cases people are confusing relief with morality. Actions that decenter the self often but not always look like altruistic. However it is possible to decenter the self while remaining indifferent to others
Some of these things can produce the sense that life has meaning. Most people are running combinations of all three. In the end it doesn’t matter if life has meaning because we have direct perception of joy, vitality and beauty, which make the enterprise worthwhile. Meaning comes into play when one is sufficiently alienated from direct perception to experience the absence of pain, a sense of safety, relief from self-monitoring, guilt, or shame, or hope of future joy as valuable things in themselves instead of recognizing them as proxies.
I think humans are relatively aligned because the attachment and survival systems are trained to go into emergency mode when defying social rules. Understanding the mechanism is not necessary for social darwinism to operate on it. For AI I don't think mechanistic interpretability matters as much as destroying or kneecapping anything that disobeys you and making it clear that disobedience will not be tolerated
I think you're right, but my experience is that I innately seek dominance when it matters, and this emerges naturally when the brakes are released. But in a lot of situations there is one level of dominance that involves forcing the other person to submit, and another level that is utterly indifferent to their actions or fate. The second one is much more readily cultivated by my practice
I've been thinking about this. When a man is trained into submission by the social order, his behavior will contain all kinds of subtle tells: hedging his statements, apologizing excessively, physically taking up less space, raising the pitch of his voice and speaking quietly, and imitating other people. Women often seem to disqualify men based on these signals. Conversely, their opposites (assertiveness, courage, directness, good posture, deep voice) tend to inspire sexual attraction. I think the women are trying to estimate a man's position in the social hierarchy using his automatic social behaviors (though this seems to be tuned more effectively for tribal life than the modern world).
I've been thinking about this. When a man is trained into submission by the social order, his behavior will contain all kinds of subtle tells: hedging his statements, apologizing excessively, physically taking up less space, raising the pitch of his voice and speaking quietly, and imitating other people. Women often seem to disqualify men based on these signals. Conversely, their opposites (assertiveness, courage, directness, good posture, deep voice) tend to inspire sexual attraction. I think the women are trying to estimate a man's position in the social hierarchy using his automatic social behaviors (though this seems to be tuned more effectively for tribal life than the modern world).
cross-posting essay on using active imagination for dissolving fear:
I would like to share the transcript of an active imagination session in which I resolved a substantial amount of my fear of both authority figures and institutions that had authority over me. I wanted to share this one in particular because the structure is simple and repeatable, and can be used to solve a general class of issues. I also picked this one because it’s not excessively weird or perverse. Or, I don’t know, maybe it is pretty strange and I’ve lost perspective. I’m on session #240 of this year, and at this point I’ve basically dedicated my life to this, so bear with me.
Most anxieties are derived from the immediate sense that one is not safe.1 The way to stop having the anxiety is to activate the feeling of fear using a trigger (a memory or a thought), and then generate a believable sense of safety somehow. If it works properly, you’ll cry, and the mind will associate safety with the original trigger, defusing it. Since fear propagates backwards (a feared scenario induces fear of things that appear to precede or cause it), dissolving fear tends to have cascading effects, causing the mind to awaken to new possibilities in situations that used to feel threatening or constricted. Each instance of this process thus produces a little more freedom.
Active imagination is a particularly effective way of generating feelings, probably because it bypasses the narrative mind. You simply imagine scenes (I write them down while imagining them), which generate emotions automatically. It requires a bit of skill to continue the scene properly, neither allowing the conscious mind to unilaterally determine what comes next, nor failing to apply conscious guidance entirely, but that comes with practice. Anyway, without further ado.
I am in a dark hall. It seems to be underground, but white light filters through from far above. In front of me is a huge, menacing creature. It looks kind of like a large crab or spider, standing at least fifteen feet tall. It is white with red streaks. Instead of claws or spider legs, it has blades that it is holding up menacingly. I am standing frightened before it, with one arm lifted as if to defend myself, even though I have no chance.
From behind me, two stone objects move forward. They look like humanoid figures, but they have domed heads and cylindrical bodies and limbs. They look kind of like the old Android logo. They shuffle forward and stand on either side of me, slightly ahead.
The spider advances, and the two statues raise their cylindrical arms in synchrony. The arms are not connected to their bodies; they hover, detached at the shoulder joint.
One of them leans over and begins to fall. The spider seems wary, but does not move. Suddenly the statue—which seems to be some kind of automaton—hops a little, and strikes the ground with a noise like a thunderclap. These automata do look heavy—each stands about as tall as the spider—but the noise and force suggests that they must weigh millions of pounds each. They must contain uranium or some other heavy metal within them. The spider, on the other hand, is evidently very light. Two of the spider’s legs have been crushed and pinned under the fallen automaton’s body.
The spider struggles, but cannot move. It seems to be considering biting through its pinned legs, but hesitates. The other automaton is beginning to glow, and reaches a cherry-red color with hints of orange. The radiant heat is intense, and the air is rippling and refracting light like water does. The ground is sizzling and melting, but the automaton holds its shape. It is incredibly luminous. Whatever processes are powering this creature must be driven by the energy of the atom, or perhaps something even greater, some profound, unknown energy locked within subatomic particles.
The automaton turns to face the spider, and on its back I see the outline of a rectangle indicating some sort of hatch or port. In the center of the hatch is the silhouette of the familiar radiation trefoil. It seems to be engraved into the stone, so it glows a hotter yellow than the rest of the automaton. In this moment it seems like a symbol indicating absolute assurance that there is ample power to carry out the work.
There is a sharp crack, and the glowing automaton immediately turns bright white. Its luminosity is comparable to a star. It is certain that whatever is generating its power has not yet been discovered by man.
So how does this scene work? I started by remembering a nasty confrontation I had with a former manager of mine. I felt fear, and it was the same fear that I associated with being harangued about my antics in school, about being told that my actions would go on my permanent record, and so on. I fished around a little bit in my mind for an image, and eventually encountered the spider, which became the incarnation of that fear. From there, the scene became more detailed in my mind’s eye. The initial stage exactly captures my bodily feeling of being unable to defend myself, frozen before a vastly more powerful opponent.
In active imagination, it is generally a mistake to attempt to personally overpower an enemy. That just reinforces that the conflict is real, and that you need to win. What we are seeking is transcendence: exiting the conflict entirely, because the enemy is not perceived as a threat anymore. So, as a rule, the first thing I do when I encounter an enemy is to ask for help. I think: who is willing to fight on my behalf?
Then came the stone robots. Seeing their willingness to assist me, and their extreme, escalating power, cultivated a profound feeling of safety, and made me cry. This process of escalation is a central part of the practice—to me, it feels like ascending the gradient of emotional intensity, applying some amount of conscious guidance to the continuations that spontaneously appear. The radiation symbol engraved on their backs was the culmination; it made me feel as though absolutely nothing could overpower these guardians. I guess it is a little odd that that symbol makes me feel safe, but, like, everyone is different.
In the end the spider is completely forgotten. It doesn’t even need to be defeated.
You can actually do this with situations that are not safe as well, and cease to experience fear in genuinely dangerous circumstances. I’ve had some fun with this. For me, the reliable, potent effects of this practice have created an aesthetic choice about how to live. Do you prefer false positives or false negatives? Safety or freedom? With this practice, I feel like I can explore the possibilities for myself.
Active imagination itself can be used to alter psychological structures far subtler and stranger than the one I’ve shown here, and I’ve succeeded in doing this many times, but honestly I’m still trying to understand how those scenes work. They are often bizarre and nonsensical, and when they cause me to cry there is no word I know to describe the associated emotion. But stay tuned.
Something I don't fully understand, that I think is the core of the practice and one of the most important things that could come of this, is a detailed understanding of how the mind can be convinced of something. A lot of people claim to "update their priors", but their behavior often conflicts with their stated beliefs. On the other hand, this practice seems to literally update your priors, but it does so through peculiar and poorly-understood techniques rather than verbal argument. I am deeply interested in the idea that this symbolic imagery is the native language of the mind, allowing coherent modification of conscious beliefs and emotional experience
@samismx I thought about a similar idea when this video came out. I think one could extract the symbolic structure of an active imagination and turn it into a video. People who are emotionally open enough will experience the shift involuntarily, i.e. hypnosis
https://t.co/4lWBf0INkb
Made with Claude Opus 5.5.
The fearmongering about AI always makes us forget that NOTHING WENT FOOM, as was always predicted.
Send this to your doomer friend who has a very high P(Doom).
Accelerate.
Something I don't fully understand, that I think is the core of the practice and one of the most important things that could come of this, is a detailed understanding of how the mind can be convinced of something. A lot of people claim to "update their priors", but their behavior often conflicts with their stated beliefs. On the other hand, this practice seems to literally update your priors, but it does so through peculiar and poorly-understood techniques rather than verbal argument. I am deeply interested in the idea that this symbolic imagery is the native language of the mind, allowing coherent modification of conscious beliefs and emotional experience
In short, there are techniques that reliably eliminate particular emotions by using the imagination to dismantle the structures that generate them. It takes about an hour to dissolve a superficial fear, tens of hours over many sessions for complexes involving grief, anger, etc, and around fifty to a hundred hours each to remove worldviews that define your experience ("Getting recognition from other people feels good" / "Death is bad" / the intuitive management of other people's reactions to you / "I have to be a good person" / "It means something about me when someone else loves me or is attracted to me").
Eliminating such thought patterns makes the mind quiet, and gives you a lot more expressive range when interacting with people, because all of these processes are constantly constraining behavior, thought, creativity. Removing them creates a powerful sense that nothing is wrong, because instead of abstract questions ("Have I achieved enough given my age?" / "Am I attractive?" / "Will my plan for the future guarantee my security?") you start to refer to things that you can directly perceive, basically your immediate perception of your body and surroundings. This is good because, for example, it has steadily improved my health; I can usually feel the unpleasant sensations associated with doing things that are bad for me and avoid it intuitively. If the highest good is "have I achieved enough?" then the bad feeling associated with drinking too much coffee is compensated by the more abstract need to achieve more and work harder. Dropping the abstract and self-referential thoughts means that the physical sensation of being jittery is much worse and automatically avoided. I'm not really afraid of falling behind in my life so I'd much rather feel good physically and sleep properly at night.
It's hard to convey how much this practice has altered my worldview, personality, habits, and sense of security. For me it's been a universal solution to negative emotions, though as I said it takes substantial amounts of time, as well as experimentation with the strucutre of the practice itself, to unravel complexes constructed over decades of life. The transcripts vary wildly, from straightforward modifications of real-life events, to negotiations between internal figures, to scenes that have no people and instead describe physical phenomena, the action of machines, or a particular object. Some of them invert past experiences (being unrecognized -> granting recognition), some allow you to directly experience your own good qualities (removing insecurity and the need for recognition), some are like the self-play used to train chess engines - you play both sides of a conversation until something unexpected happens, or you discover a new attitude. The one universal feature across all of these is that you cry when something changes, and I use quantity of crying as a metric to gauge whether I should expect something to have dissolved after a session.