@AEMFrazier@j3nnyb00m NO ONE! I get terrible migraines. You take Tylenol, excedrin or sumatriptan if it gets really bad. Aspirin? lol. Get the fuck out of here.
DR. BARRY KERR LOGAN, Ph.D.
FORENSIC TOXICOLOGIST WITH A CONTROVERSIAL PAST
O'KEEFE FAMILY EXPERT IN WRONGFUL DEATH SUIT
As we follow the Karen Read civil lawsuit and the motions involving expert witnesses, let's take a closer look at forensic toxicologist Dr. Barry Kerr Logan.
Logan has an impressive résumé, but his history also includes a Washington State toxicology laboratory scandal, judicial criticism of his credibility, and his eventual resignation.
🔶 2007 - WASHINGTON STATE TOXICOLOGY LAB SCANDAL
Logan previously served as Director of Forensic Laboratory Services for the Washington State Patrol.
In 2007, judges examining problems within the state's toxicology laboratory identified governmental misconduct and serious concerns about laboratory procedures.
🔸 A laboratory manager had improperly certified certain testing procedures.
🔸 Judges raised questions about Logan's credibility after he testified that he was unaware of the improper certifications.
🔸 The controversy involved concerns about laboratory oversight, testing practices, and the reliability of official certifications.
🔸 Despite identifying misconduct, judges declined to dismiss 51 DUI cases because they found insufficient evidence that the defendants' rights or breath-test results had been compromised.
🔶 MARCH 2008 LOGAN RESIGNS
Following the controversy, Logan resigned from the Washington State Patrol.
An academic examination of the scandal reported that Washington State Patrol Chief John Batiste considered Logan's departure necessary to restore public and judicial confidence.
Logan disputed the severity of the findings and maintained that defense attorneys had exaggerated the laboratory's problems.
🔶 ADDITIONAL LABORATORY CONCERNS
Published academic research examining the scandal discussed:
🔸 Improper certification procedures.
🔸 Equipment and software problems.
🔸 Inadequate training and laboratory protocols.
🔸 Failures to disclose certain testing problems.
🔸 Questions surrounding Logan's laboratory oversight and testimony.
The research referenced the 2008 judicial decision in Washington v. Amach.
🔶 2022 — THE CONTROVERSY RESURFACES
Years later, Logan's history surfaced again in litigation.
In State of New Hampshire v. Volodymyr Zhukovskyy, a July 15, 2022 court order discussed attempts to raise previous investigations involving NMS Labs and Logan.
The order referenced findings concerning his earlier laboratory practices.
🔶 WHY DOES THIS MATTER IN THE KAREN READ CIVIL CASE?
Expert witnesses are supposed to provide reliable scientific analysis, supported by sound methodology and accurate testimony.
When an expert has previously faced judicial criticism concerning credibility or laboratory oversight, shouldn't that history receive scrutiny?
To be clear, these controversies do not establish that Logan personally falsified test results, committed a crime, or that his current opinions are scientifically invalid.
But they DO raise legitimate questions worth examining.
The issue isn't simply whether someone has impressive credentials. It's whether their methods, conclusions, and testimony can withstand scrutiny.
And when an expert's opinions may influence the outcome of litigation, credibility matters.
Lindsay Clancy’s retrial is March 29th 2027. Karen Read’s civil trial is April 5th 2027 in the same building. Top it off with Alex Murdaugh’s new trial also April 5th 2027. LOTS of court watching this spring!