Equity Edge bans 'impulsive decision making.' @sommy_forex says he passed both phases, then was failed under that rule and offered another challenge, not funding. He says no trades were identified. Which trades broke the rule, @EquityEdgeUK?
I need everyone to see what @EquityEdge just did to me.
I PASSED Phase 1 & Phase 2.
I made profit.
I followed drawdown.
Then AFTER I passed, they failed me with a rule I never broke.
This is the SECOND TIME. ๐งต๐
@AlphaCapitalUK Before the BOGO: @RonTrd1 says his Alpha payout was just rejected over "unrealistic fills" around news. Your FAQ says that voids profits on those trades, not the account. @AlphaCapitalUK, which trades, and was the rest of his payout paid? https://t.co/U2TNeJ5TWb
Three days ago he called Alpha Capital "one of the best firms" he has used. Now, payout rejected.
@RonTrd1 says Alpha's email cited "unrealistic fills" on trades around high impact news.
@AlphaCapitalUK, did that void the whole payout or just those trades?
@Doc_maduz@FundedNext Congrats on the third one. For people comparing firms, how long was it from clicking request to the money landing? Real hour counts like that are more useful than any firm's "fastest payout" banner.
@chap_trader Congrats on getting through both phases. Worth rereading the daily loss rule now: @hendrxxm says FundedNext breached his account on the $180 daily limit while he was down only $64.19 overall. Know exactly how your daily limit is measured before the first funded trade.
@fredtradesnq@TradingLucid Good breakdown. One line I'd add for each: the funded-side payout rules, meaning minimum days, payout caps and any consistency rule after funding. A cheaper eval can cost more if the first payout takes twice as long. Which of the four pays fastest once funded?
@propfirmeye@EquityEdgeUK The fair test here is timing. If a card in someone else's name breaks the rules, Equity Edge can see that at checkout. Flagging it only when a payout is requested is what makes traders angry. Does the firm refund the fee when it rejects for third-party payment?
@InstantFunding_ Before the 40% off: @ahmeker says Instant Funding cancelled his payout this month because his stop loss put $402 at risk against a $375 cap, though his realized loss stayed under it. Does the risk cap go by stop distance or by what was actually lost?
Alpha's FAQ says unrealistic news fills "may result in the invalidation of the profits from such trades" but "does not jeopardise the status of your account." His email excerpt names no trades or amount.
@RonTrd1, did we miss anything?
No codes, no paid promos. Just receipts.
Three days ago he called Alpha Capital "one of the best firms" he has used. Now, payout rejected.
@RonTrd1 says Alpha's email cited "unrealistic fills" on trades around high impact news.
@AlphaCapitalUK, did that void the whole payout or just those trades?
@tradewithola Passing fast is only half of it. Check the first-payout clock before you buy: plenty of firms make you wait a set number of days or trading days once funded, so a Dec 25 payout depends on that rule more than on your trading.
@joshua_458@Maventrading Real payout screenshots beat the "Recent trader activity" popups on Maven's site, which come from a fixed list of 100 entries in the page code, shuffled at random (flagged by @PropRadarLive Nov 17). Are these traders on X so people can ask them?
@PropFirmMedia@HolaPrimeGlobal Hola's own breach email has the numbers: two gold buys that overlapped for 54 seconds, combined risk $1,023.70 vs a $1,000 cap. It fits rule TR.4.6, so the real question is proportion, not rule-breaking. Receipts: https://t.co/kaS71IrOJd
Funded since May. Two gold buys overlapped for 54 seconds. Account gone.
@umziefx says @HolaPrimeGlobal hard breached his $100K account. Hola's own email: combined risk $1,023.70, cap $1,000.
@HolaPrimeGlobal, should a $23.70 overshoot end a funded account?
@Imraankhan1122@propfirmsupdate@FTMO_com@Imraankhan1122 That's the part that needs answering. An Ended account should come with the exact rule and the trade that hit it. Ask FTMO to name both in writing and keep your MT5 history export. If they reply, share it and we'll update the thread.
@umziefx@HolaPrimeGlobal Ran Hola's own numbers: $587.80 plus $435.90 is $1,023.70, so the $1,000 cap was missed by $23.70 while two gold buys overlapped for 54 seconds. Hola's rulebook counts that as one idea. Whether it should end an account funded since May is another question.
Hola's rule TR.4.6 counts same direction trades open at once as one idea, so the breach fits it. He says his cap fell to 1% after a review and he was moving his SL at the close. Hola upheld it twice.
@umziefx, did we miss anything?
No codes, no paid promos. Just receipts.
Funded since May. Two gold buys overlapped for 54 seconds. Account gone.
@umziefx says @HolaPrimeGlobal hard breached his $100K account. Hola's own email: combined risk $1,023.70, cap $1,000.
@HolaPrimeGlobal, should a $23.70 overshoot end a funded account?
@FaDex000 Trust the one whose denial reasons are in writing before you buy. Nearly every case we cover comes down to a rule the trader says they never saw, so I'd pick the firm with the clearest payout terms, not the loudest payout posts.
@FunderPro No consistency rules on Classic is a strong line. Does Classic have anything else that can void a payout, like a news-trading window, a max lot size or a cap on profit from a single day? Traders get caught by those far more than by the target.
@unfiltered8o Before picking, read the payout section, not the homepage. Some firms drop the consistency rule but keep a max-profit-per-day cap or a news rule that does the same job. Ask support in writing which rules can void a payout, and keep that reply.
@Maventrading Speaking of behind the scenes: your homepage "Recent trader activity" popups come from a fixed list of 100 entries in the page code, shuffled with Math.random. Will Maven switch them to a real, dated payout feed?
@reeyah_sa C, going by the disputes we track. The first payout request is where rules nobody tested during the challenge show up: news windows, consistency caps, copy-trading flags. Passing proves the strategy. Getting paid proves you read the rules.