Kansas already ran this exact experiment, and the record is not close. The state's proof of citizenship law blocked 31,089 eligible registrations, a tenth circuit appellate court's own precise number, 12 percent of everyone trying to register for the first time. In exchange for that, the state's own evidence in court identified 39 noncitizens who managed to register over nineteen years, an average of about two a year, which the appeals court itself called incredibly slight evidence. A federal judge eventually struck the law down entirely and ordered Kris Kobach back to legal education classes before renewing his own law license.
The SAVE America Act's polling numbers tell a similar story once you ask the actual question instead of the easy one. Voter ID alone polls at 74 percent. Ask about the documentary proof of citizenship requirement specifically, and support drops to somewhere between 51 and 65 percent depending on the poll. Ask whether people support the SAVE Act as a whole, the actual bill with its mail voting ban and its federal takeover of state election administration, and it falls to 37 percent, with 63 percent either opposed or unsure. That gap between how a slogan polls and how the actual legislation polls is not an accident. It is the entire strategy.
Worth sitting with the passport numbers too. A hundred forty million Americans do not have one. Twenty-one million voting age citizens have no citizenship document handy at all. Only five states even issue the enhanced REAL ID that shows citizenship status, and more than a third of Americans mistakenly believe their standard REAL ID already does. The gap between what people think they can produce and what they can actually produce is exactly where Kansas lost thirty-one thousand real, eligible, documented citizens the first time this idea got tried at scale.
@chucktodd The fact that Pixies have yet to be nominated, let alone inducted, says all that needs to be said about the legitimacy of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.
@AmericaPapaBear This, combined with my DOGE rebate, should allow me to pay the premium for trump’s healthcare plan, and because it’s so much cheaper than the ACA, I should still have a bazillion dollars left to invest in trump crypto.
Lied to much.
A few notes on the Comey indictment:
1) Yes, Trump and lots of allies were indicted, too. They were overwhelmingly convicted by juries when the cases actually went to trial. We’ll see whether Comey is, too.
2) There is no comparison between Biden’s role in those prosecutions and Trump’s role in this one. Trump’s charges were brought by a special counsel, not a Biden-appointed US attorney or even AG Garland. These ones were brought by a Trump loyalist who was installed shortly after Trump forced out a US attorney who declined to charge, and shortly after Trump publicly called for the prosecution. There is no evidence that Biden applied such pressure on DOJ, though he on a number of occasions violated DOJ norms by commenting on investigations (https://t.co/cFvcSsJyLS). Biden repeatedly said he wasn’t getting involved and emphasized DOJ independence in such matters – a major contrast to Trump publicly calling for prosecutions of Comey, James, Schiff, Soros, etc., and criticizing those who didn’t bring charges (including his own AG).
3) The Comey situation is also unlike these other federal cases in that not only did the US attorney decline to bring charges, but the DOJ inspector general investigated the matter and reached similar conclusions. He cited “considerable circumstantial evidence” and “concluded that the overwhelming weight of that evidence supported Comey’s version of the conversation.” Maybe there is better evidence now, but two investigators who looked at this didn't seem to think it rose to the level. Now it's being charged on the eve of a deadline after an extraordinary series of events.
4) Whatever you think of how advised it was to indict a former president, these were things even Republicans said were very bad. Seven GOP senators voted to convict Trump at his Jan. 6 impeachment trial – a historically bipartisan vote. And on Trump's classified documents indictment, Trump’s own former AG, Bill Barr, said the evidence looked damning and that Trump’s defenses didn’t hold water.
@BlueBoxDave Because nothing says “I don’t care anymore” like spending time on social media saying “I don’t care anymore”. Maybe write a book and a podcast about it, as well. Snowflake much?
This wasn’t about honoring a young man’s life of political service.
It was a rally.
It was mass conditioning through weaponized faith, with death repackaged as a “turning point.”
A 10 hour stadium revival stitched together from nationalism, the glorification of military enlistment and biblical martyrdom.
This is the machine.
It even had pyrotechnics.
For the umpteenth time: Trump is what people get when people no longer care about right and wrong. Trump is what happens when people say “they all suck, the system is broken, it doesn’t matter if Satan is President.” Trump is what happens when people become selfish and quit on democracy.
If this isn’t a call for open, violent, unadulterated fascism and authoritarianism, from a top adviser to the president, then what is it? Seriously, what the hell is it?
"Don't you dare call us fascists just because we first tried to seize power by a violent putsch ... and then after that failed we instead used a spectacular crime as a pretext to consolidate power and suppress opposition."
Thank you to @ChrisCuomo for having me on his @NewsNation show so I could comprehensively debunk the lie from JD Vance & others on the right who claim the statistics show political violence is from the left, not the right.
It's the *exact opposite*, as I laid out, with receipts:
He’s lying. The statistics - including his own government and own FBI’s statistics - say the exact opposite.
Well, for now. I’m sure they’ll doctor them going forward like they plan to do for the jobs numbers.
We can be morally outraged by an assassination and at the same time acknowledge that Charlie Kirk’s racism, bigotry and misogyny were immoral. Whitewashing his behavior and beliefs betrays the collective by masking how we got to this place in America.
The President of the United States threatens to withhold federal funding from an American city if that city elects a mayor he doesn’t like. Utterly wrong. Utterly anti-democratic. An abuse of his powers of office. And not one Republican will say a thing. Do not normalize this.
It is indeed an ‘absolute lie that “both sides” are equally violent’. Every piece of data we have - governmental, non governmental - shows that the right is responsible for most of the political violence and killings in this country in recent years. Even Musk’s @grok agrees.
There is literally no Western politician alive that I can think of that has incited more hate, bigotry, and violence than Donald Trump.
That so many in our public life, in our 'liberal' media, have just memory-holed 10 years of nonstop incitement and abuse from him is shameful.
Remember when the radical left Democrats called for @Liz_Cheney to be shot in the face?
We need to stop the left from promoting political violence against the right.
Me: "Donald Trump ran for president in 2016 and said people with guns should maybe take care of Hillary Clinton to protect the 2nd Amendment. He ran for president in 2020, lost the election, and then incited a violent insurrection at the Capitol where his supporters tried to hang his vice-president. In 2024 he ran for president, he referred to his opponents as 'vermin' and the 'enemy within' and said he would send the military after them... Donald Trump has set the tone here."
BBC host: "That is the right. But what about the left?"
Me: "Which left? I saw Barack Obama, Joe Biden... all the leading Democrats came out and condemned this and said we need to tone this down."
From my appearance on @BBCNewsnight
He had an opportunity last night to heal a broken/divided nation. Instead, he attacks, he pours gas on the fire, & he further divides. For the next 3yrs, the American people are on their own trying to lower the temperature in this country. Bcuz the guy in the White House is humanly incapable of it.