The story of computing is the story of humanity: this is a story of ambition, invention, creativity, vision, avarice, power, and serendipity, powered by a refusal to accept the limits of our bodies and our minds.
It is sad to see such profoundly naive predictions from @AnthropicAI’s staff.
The only conclusion I can draw is that they are blinded by the cult in which they work, are insulated from the real world, and have incredibly shallow, emaciated life experience.
Anthropic Researcher Tao Lin: Pretty much all humans on earth will become permanently unemployable because of AI
"It's very likely that pretty much all humans on earth will become permanently unemployable"
"And will need to strictly rely on government welfare to sustain themselves"
"Human employment will go away."
Except that, Mr Nagel is referring to contemporary frontier models. While they indeed only produce language, the domain of possible software-intensive systems is far larger.
My experience and understanding tells me that the mind is computable. We do not yet comprehend the architecture that may lead us to sentient systems - indeed, I contend we are far away from that - and it is certainly true that LLMs are a dead end in that regard.
But, we are a curious and creative species, and I suspect we will in the fullness of time coevolve with our inventions.
Except that, Mr Nagel is referring to contemporary frontier models. While they indeed only produce language, the domain of possible software-intensive systems is far larger.
My experience and understanding tells me that the mind is computable. We do not yet comprehend the architecture that may lead us to sentient systems - indeed, I contend we are far away from that - and it is certainly true that LLMs are a dead end in that regard.
But, we are a curious and creative species, and I suspect we will in the fullness of time coevolve with our inventions.
@IvanOmarOT@eyebrows360@BojanSala I suggest you study some neuroscience before you continue making assertions that are clearly outside your area of expertise and understanding.
Feeling vulnerable so I’ll ask a stupid question I’ve been wondering: are LLM’s really just token predictors at root?
How do tools like Claude produce incredibly accurate results if so? Mountains of constraints and context, carefully packaged around the token predictor?
I spent time with one of @elonmusk@DOGE-ers he assigned to that task shortly after he made that post in 2025.
He was completely void of any understanding of the domain of air traffic control, incompetent, uncaring about the architecture of the current system, inexperienced in hard real time/high risk systems whose failure could result in human death, and blindly arrogant as to his ignorance and ability.
@developfwd@elonmusk@DOGE Involved only to the degree I was witness to a train wreck that was avoidable, despite waving red flags, shouting at the engineers, and shaking my fist at their boss who foolishly put them on those tracks in the first place.
@developfwd@elonmusk@DOGE Involved only to the degree I was witness to a train wreck that was avoidable, despite waving red flags, shouting at the engineers, and shaking my fist at their boss who foolishly put them on those tracks in the first place.
The invention has a moral side, a stirring, optimistic inspiration. “If this can be done,” we ask, “what is there that cannot be?”
-- A Night with Edison, November 1878
https://t.co/v4gE95Hwok
I spent time with one of @elonmusk@DOGE-ers he assigned to that task shortly after he made that post in 2025.
He was completely void of any understanding of the domain of air traffic control, incompetent, uncaring about the architecture of the current system, inexperienced in hard real time/high risk systems whose failure could result in human death, and blindly arrogant as to his ignorance and ability.
Selling Oculus to Facebook in 2014 gave me money for helicopter flight lessons and developing a seastead called SLAB with a 1,000 year design life.
The goal was to be cheaper than land and absent state/local laws that cripple critical American industries like metal processing, medical research/treatment, desalination, oil refining, chemical engineering, and more. Me and a few close friends cashed it up at a $1B valuation back in 2017, and while it still has a long way to go, there has been significant progress towards my goal of reviving manifest destiny and westward expansion. At a time when most of the seasteading community wanted to escape the US and smoke pot, this was the one project explicitly designed to make America stronger, a relief valve for ill considered or outdated rules and regulations.
I am only talking about it now because a few media outlets got wind of me and some friends topping up the coffers and plan on calling SLAB my new floating AI datacenter project. It is way cooler than that, way older than that, and I hate looking like a hype-chasing consensus loser, so now you have to read this tweet.
All architecture is design, but not all design is architecture. Design Patterns - the classic book by the Gang of Four - presents 23 patterns including Abstract Factory, Facade, and Chain of Responsibility. Mary Shaw’s book, Software Architecture, presents 11 architectural styles such as Pipe and Filter and Event-Driven.
In studying the architecture of contemporary frontier models, every one of them seems to follow the same pattern: a symbolic harness on top of a neural large language model. Remember, however, those LLMs are each non-deterministic and unreliable narrators and those harnesses both extend and guard the behavior of the LLM below them.
I have a name for this architectural pattern: the Fallible Chaperone.