Bl actors running to their mommies to act like victims when the options are shutting up or taking accountability is growing so fucking old. And it always works 🙄
"we love you 🥺"
"take care of yourself ❤️❤️"
"you did nothing wrong 🫂"
It gets to a point
@GMMTV@ScarletHeartTH We demand to give credit and disclaimers at the beginning of each episode of the series once it's start airing. Otherwise, we decide to voice our frustrations and concerns till we get the proper acknowledgement from production team.
I want to explain why we are speaking up about the cultural representation in #ScarletHeartTH.
Scarlet Heart is already a globally recognized story, and its Thai adaptation has been highly anticipated, especially because GMMTV has cast some of its most popular and well-known actors. As fans, we have waited for this project for over two years, and we understand how much excitement surrounds it. We want this series to succeed, and we want to see the actors we love shine on an international stage.
But supporting a series and protecting our cultural heritage are two different things. One does not cancel out the other.
This is not just an ordinary fictional story that will be watched and forgotten. It is a major production with the potential to reach audiences around the world. A project of this scale can introduce people to a country's history, traditions, clothing, and cultural identity. That is precisely why cultural research and accurate representation matter so much.
When audiences around the world see a costume presented on screen, many may naturally assume that it belongs to the culture of the country producing the series. If a historically significant Myanmar traditional costume is used without proper research, context, or acknowledgment, there is a real concern that international audiences may mistakenly identify it as Thai traditional attire.
The costume in question is associated with Myanmar's historical heritage, particularly the Yadanabon era. Myanmar's traditional clothing did not simply appear without a history. Its development can be studied through historical records, paintings, photographs, and other cultural documentation from different periods. These are matters that can be researched and examined through evidence, rather than dismissed as mere opinions on social media.
Thai productions can portray other cultures, but cultural exchange requires proper research, respect, and historical accuracy. Concerns about a costume’s origins should be taken seriously, not dismissed as unnecessary criticism.
Myanmar is a country whose people continue to struggle for freedom and a better future. At the same time, preserving our history and cultural identity remains an important responsibility. Our circumstances do not make our heritage less valuable, and the challenges our country faces do not mean we should remain silent when we believe our culture is being misrepresented.
To those asking why we are making an issue out of clothing in a television series, please understand this: we can love the actors without agreeing with every decision made by the production team. We can support the artists while questioning the production's cultural representation. And we can look forward to a series while asking its creators to be responsible.
Our criticism is not an attack on Thai people, Thai culture, or the actors involved. It is a request for accountability from a major production company whose work will be seen by an international audience.
GMMTV has had more than two years to prepare a project of this scale. We believe that researching the historical origins of culturally significant costumes should be part of that preparation. We are asking the production team to review the concerns, consult reliable historical sources and relevant cultural experts, and provide clarification where necessary.
We are not asking anyone to blindly accept our claims. We are asking for the same standard we expect from any major historical production: research the facts, respect the cultures being represented, and take legitimate concerns seriously.
Loving our artists does not require us to stay silent about cultural misrepresentation. Supporting entertainment does not mean abandoning our responsibility to protect our heritage. We can do both.
Our history matters. Our cultural heritage matters. And asking for it to be represented accurately is not causing trouble. It is asking for respect.
@GMMTV
#ScarletHeartTH #MyanmarCulture
I have one question for Thai people. If you truly believe your side is right, then you don’t need to gang up on people, insult them, or use ethnic prejudice to attack them. Debate with historical evidence and prove your claims with facts.
When you believe Cambodia is claiming Thai traditional attire, you speak up and defend your culture based on history and cultural identity, don’t you? So why can’t you apply the same standard when Myanmar people raise concerns about their own traditional clothing?
You have every right to protect your culture, but so do we. You cannot expect your concerns to be taken seriously while dismissing other people’s concerns simply because they come from another country.
If you disagree, then present historical records, paintings, and credible evidence showing which era and region these costumes actually belong to. Attacking people instead of addressing the evidence does not prove that your side is right.
If you’re so confident that you’re right, then prove it with historical evidence. Stop resorting to ethnic prejudice just because someone questions your claims. History is not about winning an argument; it’s about acknowledging the facts, even when they challenge your own assumptions.
#ScarletHeartTH #MyanmarCulture #MyanmarTraditionalCostume
Then gmmtv should just admit they took references from Yadanabon Era and not just blabbering about how the drama is based on Lanna people and fantasy kingdom.
Remind us where is the Yadanabon era and its monarchy now? If It is history, which means its historical attire is in the public domain and free for artistic fantasy interpretation. Nobody needs your permission or a disclaimer to design costumes for a TV show.
@mellanniin@MayPoeOu246065@GMMTV South African fans should stay in your South African lane. You dont know anything about South east Asian cultures and traditions and still want to insert yourself into our conflict.
I would like to raise a concern regarding the costumes featured in the trailer for Scarlet Heart Thailand.
I understand that the series is set in the Lanna Kingdom, a region with its own rich history, cultural identity, and traditional clothing. I fully respect Lanna culture and its heritage. However, as a Myanmar person, I cannot help noticing the striking similarities between some of the costumes shown in the trailer and traditional Burmese women's clothing.
The most noticeable example is the costume worn by the women in the candle dance scene. Certain details, including the upper garments, chest coverings, waist arrangements, and traditional skirt styles, appear remarkably similar to elements found in historical Burmese attire.
Myanmar has a long history of traditional dress, including the Yinkhan (traditional bodice), Htaingmathein (a traditional women's jacket), and Htamein (traditional women's skirt). These garments are more than just clothing; they represent our history, cultural identity, and heritage passed down through generations.
At the same time, Lanna has its own distinctive traditional clothing, including the Pha Sin, a traditional wraparound skirt, as well as its own weaving traditions and ceremonial attire. The Fon Tian, or Lanna candle dance, is also an important part of Lanna's cultural heritage.
I recognize that Myanmar and Lanna share historical and cultural connections, and similarities in traditional clothing can naturally exist between neighboring regions. However, shared cultural influences should not mean that the origins of traditional designs can be overlooked or left unexplained.
As someone who has been looking forward to this series because of the cast, I genuinely want to enjoy it. I will still watch it when it airs. However, seeing these costumes in the trailer has left me feeling uncomfortable and raises legitimate questions about the research behind the costume design.
When a historical series draws inspiration from a particular kingdom and its culture, the costume department has a responsibility to conduct careful historical research and represent the region's heritage accurately. If certain designs closely resemble traditional Burmese attire, I believe it is reasonable to ask what historical references were used in creating them.
I am not raising this concern to disrespect Lanna culture or deny its unique traditions. I simply believe that Myanmar's cultural heritage deserves the same respect and recognition. Every culture deserves to have its traditional clothing represented accurately, with its historical origins acknowledged rather than blurred or misrepresented.
I would therefore appreciate clarification from the production team regarding the historical references and sources used for these costume designs, particularly those that appear strikingly similar to traditional Burmese clothing.
Cultural inspiration is one thing, but cultural heritage deserves careful research, respect, and proper recognition.
#ScarletHeartTH #MyanmarCulture #MyanmarTraditionalCostume #CulturalHeritage
The more I look the more I realize the Htaingmathein isn’t the only issue.
They’ve disrespectfully mixed Myanmar ethnic cultures into a frog-fish hybrid.
pairing a Myanmar Htaingmathein with a Shan htamain while performing the Rakhine Oil Lamp Dance 💀
@GMMTV
The more I look the more I realize the Htaingmathein isn’t the only issue.
They’ve disrespectfully mixed Myanmar ethnic cultures into a frog-fish hybrid.
pairing a Myanmar Htaingmathein with a Shan htamain while performing the Rakhine Oil Lamp Dance 💀
@GMMTV
Why am I seeing Burmese traditional clothes ????
Most of the characters are wearing Shan culture from Myanmar . But I don’t want to blame because Thai and Shan have similarities.
But these clothes in these pictures are Burmese dresses from Yadanabon Era.
#ScarletHeartTH
🚨 Usage of Burmese Attire in SHTH series
We would like to ask why the team would use the Burmese royal attire ‘htaingmathein’ from Yadanarbon era, 19th century, instead of using Lanna traditional clothing from 15th century?
#ScarletHeartTH@ScarletHeartTH#GMMTV@GMMTV