Top Tweets for #FreedomForEver

The most honest thing ever said about the American War was said by a Vietnamese colonel to an American colonel after the war ended. The American colonel, Harry Summers, told his Vietnamese counterpart: "You know, you never defeated us on the battlefield." The Vietnamese colonel, Nguyễn Đôn Tự, thought about it and replied: "That may be so. But it is also irrelevant." That exchange contains the entire war. The Americans won battles. They won firefights. They had superior firepower in almost every conventional engagement. By their own metrics, body counts, kill ratios, territory controlled, they were often "winning." And they lost the war. Because wars are not won by body counts. Wars are not won by kill ratios. Wars are not won by the number of bombs dropped or the cost of the weapons deployed or the technological sophistication of the killing machinery. Wars, especially wars of occupation, wars of colonial imposition, wars fought against people defending their own land, are won by will. And on the question of will, there was never a contest. The Vietnamese people had been resisting foreign occupation for two thousand years before America arrived. Fighting was not a policy position. It was a cultural inheritance. A collective understanding of who they were and what they would do when someone came to tell them how to live. America arrived with the most powerful military in human history and a firm belief that sufficient firepower could substitute for legitimacy. It cannot. It never could. It never will. Irrelevant. That one word, from a Vietnamese colonel to his American counterpart, is the entire lesson.