Top Tweets for #SWPBritain
#TonyCliff #SWPBritain
Everyone should watch this for a clear summation of the rejection of Lenin and Trotsky by Tony Cliff and SWP (Britain) in favour of pseudo-spontaneism.
At 27:43 ["TCR 16:27:52:00"] Cliff says:
"... We never said the revolutionary party is the teacher of the class. I always laugh at this bloody statement because I always ask a question 'who teaches the teacher?'.
All right we are the leadership. We are the teacher. Who teaches us? Now the only people can teach us are the workers themselves and therefore the idea of the Soviet is not the invention of Lenin, exactly the opposite, when the workers in Petrograd in 1905 created the Soviet Lenin wrote a letter says 'what there are the workers is doing about it? What for?"
--
The simple answer to Cliff's question of "Who teaches the teacher?" is ... Marx, Engels, Lenin, Trotsky!
Notice in the early part of the video he never says they founded the SWP on the perspective developed by Trotsky. They dreamt it up themselves.
--
If Cliff wanted to be really clear, he would have said
"Lenin, following Kautsky, following Marx and Engels, said socialist class consciousness needs to be brought into the working class by a political party. I completely disagree with this, with Lenin's struggle against opportunism in the Second International and thus with the basis on which he fought for the October Revolution. I disagree with Trotsky joining the Bolsheviks in July 1917 and his struggle for Leninism from then until his death. In October 1917 the Bolsheviks should have sat back and waited for the Soviets to take power. How dare Lenin say in the April Theses the task is to patiently, persistently and systematically explain the objective roots of the crisis to workers. He should have just been learning from workers."
FWIW:
Tony Cliff and the origins of the International Socialists
https://t.co/0K3R21Wu7u
Tony Cliff rejected Trotskyism and permanent revolution." the revolutionary character of the young working class is neither absolute nor inevitable…" He went onto positions as to defend the Labour Party as the party of the working class https://t.co/L7d52VTyOd
Last Seen Hashtags on Sotwe
türkifşa
Seen from Turkey
รังสิตนัด
Seen from Thailand
hija #faketoks
Seen from Colombia
fartfetish
Seen from Korea
男同短剧
Seen from Thailand
sakso türbanlı
Seen from Turkey
青春グラフィティ
Seen from Netherlands
AldisVsScurll
Seen from United States
azerbaijangay
Seen from Netherlands
سكس_يمني
Seen from Oman
Trends for you
Most Popular Users

Elon Musk 
@elonmusk
240.5M followers

Barack Obama 
@barackobama
118.7M followers

Cristiano Ronaldo 
@cristiano
114.4M followers

Donald J. Trump 
@realdonaldtrump
111.8M followers

Narendra Modi 
@narendramodi
107M followers

Rihanna 
@rihanna
98.7M followers

NASA 
@nasa
92.2M followers

Justin Bieber 
@justinbieber
91.8M followers

KATY PERRY 
@katyperry
90M followers

Taylor Swift 
@taylorswift13
84M followers

Lady Gaga 
@ladygaga
75.5M followers

Virat Kohli 
@imvkohli
73.4M followers

Kim Kardashian 
@kimkardashian
70.8M followers

YouTube 
@youtube
68.7M followers

Neymar Jr 
@neymarjr
66.4M followers

Bill Gates 
@billgates
65.2M followers

Selena Gomez 
@selenagomez
63M followers

The Ellen Show
@theellenshow
62.1M followers

CNN 
@cnn
61.7M followers

X 
@x
60.6M followers

