@jaykaid17@ProletariatRis1@1kblades It's not ironic at all. I'll take oligopolies over a unitary state any day. I'd love to prevent regulatory capture, but Marxism only makes that problem worse.
At the outset I acknowledged that Marx identified some real problems. He wasn't wrong on everything. But his proposed solutions were silly, and their real world implementations have proven that time and again.
And since you think concentrations of power are a problem, then explain to me why every single socialist society is characterized by far more extreme concentrations of power than any capitalist society?
You're saying "concentrations of power are bad, so let's concentrate all power in the State!"
@ProletariatRis1@1kblades But that class is not unitary, and it isn't well defined at the boundaries.
Thus discussing their class interests as though these interest were unconfirmed and pointed in a single direction is incorrect and fruitless.
@ProletariatRis1@1kblades In America, each person owns their labor, which is a means of production. And, by saving judiciously, they can acquire further means of production for a price.
People cycle in and out of the ownership class every few generations; it isn't a fixed, hereditary structure.
@ProletariatRis1@1kblades Somewhat, yes. This is a point where I thing Marx gets the broad strokes correct.
I just think we can address these issues without abandoning the core concept of private property and free markets.
@theCatSlapper@1kblades That works if you are content to live around a campfire, hunt your food, and likely die by age 30.
If you want to operate society at scale, it's going to take organization, planning and leadership.
The relevant scale for the discussion is millions of people. Yes, you need hierarchies to operate at that scale.
The scale of a family -- and we live in nuclear families, not extended families here in the West -- is about 2-6 people. I agree that no hierarchy is necessary at that scale. Beyond about 10 people, however, there is almost always a leader.
And billionaires do not eat their money. Most of their money is tied up in their businesses. If you were to ask a billionaire to give you $100 million tomorrow, they would have to arrange a loan (easy for them to do), because they don't actually have the money stored away in a Scrooge-MacDuck money bin. What they have is control of resources at scale, which is a natural consequence of sitting atop a hierarchy over millions of people.
I always forget how simultaneously dogmatic and uninformed Marxists are, mea culpa.
I'm happy to talk with you, but the world doesn't work like you think it works, and you need to open your mind a bit if you want to understand.
I dispute the existence of a unitary capitalist class, yes. That was very sloppy on Marx's part, as it is obviously false.
Big Oil, Big Tech, Big Pharma, Big Ag -- these are all distinct centers of power. They contend with each other for access to resources, and meaningfully so.
By contrast, socialism IS a monopoly. Socialism is also strictly hierarchical, with the government at the top.
Capitalism trends towards monopoly, but not inevitably. Various interventions can disrupt this tendency, such as anti-trust action, and we should embrace these interventions periodically.
I'm not sure that is really happening. A lot of the new voters came not from blue states, but from other countries, perhaps 15 years ago so that they are now naturalized citizens.
They are foreigners, they look at American society as having obvious problems, and they want to fix those problems.
We are the idiots for letting business interests bring in so many foreigners that we are now culturally overwhelmed.
And it will only get worse if we continue to follow the laws that are currently on the books.
You would consign your own people to poverty and eventual domination by other nations that will exploit AI to become strong.
Rice's comments are as stupid as saying that we should have banned computers in the 1960s or disconnected the internet in the 1990s.
It is as stupid as banning nuclear power, which we effectively did with the Nuclear Regulatory Commission under the Carter presidency.
Existential risk is a political tool, not a reality, and preaching AI doom is attempt to subjugate and control the people.
If you are going to remove a leader, standard practice is to do it quickly and decisively (cf. Sam Altman).
This case is odd in that sexual misconduct is usually handled more discreetly. Accusations of espionage and violation of export controls would also typically be handled more discreetly.
So the very public nature of Huang's ouster is strange, reminiscent of a cancellation campaign based on outside pressure.
@MarkWarner AI is the best hope we have to keep America relevant for our children.
We need to support our children strongly, but killing AI or turning it into a walled garden for the benefit of a few is not the way.
@itsnwts No, you don't have it right. Paying 25% of your paycheck for universal healthcare would be bad.
Ending collusion between insurers, hospitals, and pharmaceuticals -- now that might bring it down to 10% of your paycheck for healthcare.
@SenSanders Pause Bernie Sanders now!
If socialists escape human control, we could be looking at a disaster. General impoverishment? Mass gulags?Even worse?
We can wait to find out. Pause Bernie now!