Sar

we never know

[NCT 127 @NCTsmtown_127]

The energy of THE REDLINE

Check out the latest updates through the link below
https://t.co/llCi0Rz7a7

EVERYTHING, ALL AT ONCE, NEO
https://t.co/vkFUnwHeM8

#NCT127 #THE_REDLINE
#NCT127_5TH_NEOCITY_THE_REDLINE
#NCT_10TH_ANNIVERSARY

[🐋วาฬ_whale @hanis_li]

It’s gonna be my last post about this. I just feel that some people really couldn’t get a hold of what was going on and what really matters.

Background:
- Dating rumors about E and 🏸 in June. 🐢said he would support them if they were together.

- E then said publicly that she was single, they were only friends / senior–junior, and that if she ever had a partner, she would tell fans herself.

- C confirmed not renew. Her contract runs to about late April 2027. Both have said they still want joint schedules. Fans were waiting for those remaining ~7 months.

1. How it started | 12 Sep
🏸 posted an IG Story that day tagging E asking how much do you love me

⚠️That day was a CP / 4E-related event. Tickets were expensive. Some fans traveled from other cities or countries, expecting the focus to stay on the pair.

At that point, most fans were hurt and worried, not looking for a fight:

1) Doing this on event day disrespected the partner and people who came specifically for the duo

2) E had just clarified months earlier that there was “nothing going on,” so this no longer matched and harms her image

3) This was not 🏸’s first tag / public-signal controversy, so fans worried about who was around E and if that person have good intentions

4) C’s contract is not over and more duo work was still expected. Why push this into public view now?

What fans asked for was still limited:
- An apology for disrupting the event
- Acknowledgment of other artists affected, especially C
- A clear explanation of the relationship. Dating is acceptable. Guesswork is not.

2. It escalated | 14 Sep
After a few days of silence, and amid talk about 🏸 and her manager, 🏸 posted a long statement.

The point was not to close the issue. It was:
1) She admitted the 12 Sep tag was careless and made some people uncomfortable

2) She said they have known each other for almost two years through a sports / workout circle

3) After seeing reports that E was single, she wanted more contact and to take the relationship further

4) She also said they are still like older/younger sisters in a friend group

5) She denied being in another serious relationship

Thai media and bystanders read this as “at least she was honest.” People who missed the full timeline then turned on CP fans and called them toxic for trying to control an artist’s life.

This is where hurt turned into anger, for specific reasons:

1) It did not read like an apology. It read like a one-sided confession, and made E’s earlier clarification look insincere

2) E still said nothing. Only 🏸 was defining the relationship

3) There was no acknowledgment of C or other artists pulled in

4) A few fans did go too far, but that does not make every hurt fan “toxic”

5) EL couple work got cancelled (not confirmed but it was acknowledged widely)

The real damage became this: the sincere image E spent years building — “I will tell you myself” — was overwritten by a third party. Fans then got blamed on top of that. And C who was innocent got dragged into this and even affected her job.

3. It spread further | 15 Sep
Assistant S posted. E still has not spoken.

Defending an artist’s private life is fair. The problem is:

1) There was no official statement. A close staffer lecturing fans with emotion gets read as the artist’s stance

2) Saying “there are no victims” dismisses a disrupted event, disappointed fans, and a partner who got dragged in

3) It lumped fans who just wanted honesty together with the small group that went too far

4) Saying talent matters more than fan support sounded like talking down to the people who stayed

5) The ending — “some accounts have already been dug up / quiet people are scary / take this as a warning” — reads like a threat

6) E herself is still silent

So the feeling shifted from anger to disappointment: not “she is not allowed a personal life,” but “nobody will face the hurt, and nobody will tell the truth.”

[someproblemhere @someproblemhere]

ไม่มีใครสนใจว่าคุณจะคบใคร... ปัญหาคือการหลอกลวงและการลากคนอื่นมาเดือดร้อน
* มีแฟนไม่ใช่ปัญหา แต่การ "หลอกลวง" คือประเด็น: ไม่มีใครห้ามคุณมีความรัก การมีแฟนไม่ใช่เรื่องผิด แต่การสร้างอาณาจักรธุรกิจมูลค่าหลายร้อยล้านจากการขายภาพจำคู่ (CP) ในขณะที่มีความสัมพันธ์ซ้อนหลังฉากมานานถึง 2 ปี มันไม่ใช่เรื่อง "ความเป็นส่วนตัว" แต่มันคือการหลอกลวงผู้บริโภคและไม่จริงใจต่อแฟนคลับที่ทุ่มเงินสนับสนุน
* อย่าลืมว่าดังมาจากอะไร: คุณไม่ได้กลายเป็นปรากฏการณ์ระดับอินเตอร์เพียงเพราะเสียงร้องเพลง แต่ยอดพรีเซนเตอร์ งานพาร์ทเนอร์ และคอนเสิร์ตฮอลล์แตกทั่วโลก มันถูกสร้างขึ้นบนฐานของ "Englot" การพยายามสลัดฐานรากนี้ทิ้ง แล้วทำเหมือนตัวเองประสบความสำเร็จได้ด้วยตัวคนเดียวตั้งแต่แรก คือความหลงตัวเองอย่างแท้จริง
* ลากคู่ทำงานมาซวย และสะท้อนตัวตน 5 ปี: ในขณะที่คุณปล่อยให้เรื่องส่วนตัวทำลายบรรยากาศงานคู่ และคอยใช้คำว่า "น้องมีการพัฒนาขึ้น" คุมเชิงเขามาตลอด 5 ปี แต่ Charlotte กลับรักษาความเป็นมืออาชีพ 100% จนวันสุดท้าย แถมเพิ่งพิสูจน์ศักยภาพด้วยยอดขายเดี่ยว 2.3 ล้านบาท เธอไม่เคยเป็น "เด็กในโอวาท" ของคุณ แต่เธอคือคู่ทำงานที่คุณทิ้งภาระไว้ให้
* จนถึงตอนนี้ก็ยังจับประเด็นไม่ได้: การเบี่ยงประเด็นอ้างเรื่อง "สิทธิส่วนบุคคล" หรือส่งทีมงานมาขู่ฟ้องร้องแฟนคลับ ไม่ได้ช่วยให้คุณดูดีขึ้น มันยิ่งตอกย้ำว่าคุณไม่เคยเข้าใจเรื่องจรรยาบรรณในการทำงาน การเคารพคู่ค้า และความรับผิดชอบต่อสังคมเลยแม้แต่นิดเดียว
Nobody Cares Who You Date—The Problem Is Fraud, Greed, and Dragging Others Down
* Dating Isn't the Issue—Deception Is: Nobody is policing your love life. Having a partner is completely fine. What is NOT fine is building a multi-million-dollar commercial empire by selling a manufactured CP image while secretly maintaining a 2-year romance behind the scenes. That isn't "privacy"—that is commercial fraud and pure disrespect to the fans who bankrolled your lifestyle.
* Remember How You Got to the Top: You didn't become a global phenomenon on solo vocals alone. The sold-out arenas, international tours, and endless brand deals were built on the backs of "Englot." Discarding that origin story now and acting as if you achieved all of this entirely on your own is total delusion.
* Sabotaging Your Partner's Work: While you allowed personal drama to sabotage a major shared milestone and patronized her for 5 years with "she has improved," Charlotte kept her head down, maintained 100% professionalism, and just proved her worth by pulling 2.3M THB solo in a single stream. She was never your student—she was the reliable partner you constantly dragged down.
* Still Completely Missing the Point: Gaslighting fans with "respect my privacy" and threatening legal action only proves one thing: you still don't get it. This was never about jealousy; it was about basic workplace ethics, accountability, and professional integrity.

[About Music @AboutMusicYT]

Milk, Love, Bonnie, Film, Janhae, Kapook, Ciize, Fond, and Mewnich perform Genie by Girls Generation at the Blush Blossom Fan Fest 2026.

"I'm genie for you girl"

[𝐀𝐦𝐢 ✈️🩰 @amisickk_]

GENIE BY MILK LOVE FILM BONNIE JANHAE KAPOOK CIIZE FOND AND MEWNICH 😭😭😭😭 A DREAM CAME TRUE!!!

#BBFanFest2026D1

[Sar @invyouuu]

Mark lee….

[Sar @invyouuu]

@Tyler_grassl hi

[Sar @invyouuu]

@Iunatico_feliz Done

[Sar @invyouuu]

@Iunatico_feliz Dana

[Sar @invyouuu]

@Iunatico_feliz Dana

[Sar @invyouuu]

@MiaPumpIT 28

[Sar @invyouuu]

@MikaelDewabrata Izin tanya, kalo baru mau mulai cen blu mending pake akun lama apa baru ya?

[Sar @invyouuu]

Maap Kpop kita udahan dulu, per Tailan an lagi seru” nya 😁🤭

[Sar @invyouuu]

@keshikiayame Mauu cobain cheese cream, penasaran bgt sama cheese cream

[ningning pics @prodningning]

ningning’s vocal tone is everything

[NCT @NCTsmtown]

UNKNOWN FAX

NCT JNJM 【BOTH SIDES - The 1st Mini Album】
➫ 2026.02.23 6PM (KST)

💿 Pre-order
https://t.co/6meQQFN3yn

#NCTJNJM #BOTHSIDES
#NCTJNJM_BOTHSIDES

[About Music @AboutMusicYT]

Girls Generation at their US TV debut, performing The Boys, 2012.

[Sar @invyouuu]

@vousjeaime @newromantician @preciellent @ilsasfst Kak bukannya dia lagi lgi ngatain cwe fandom mu ya?, kok malah kmu ngatain juga ya…

[Girls' Generation @GirlsGeneration]

‘흥행퀸’ #임윤아, 서울서 #폭군의셰프 드라마 팬미팅 피날레 장식! 12월 개최
전 세계 흥행 이끈 주역! 글로벌 투어로 독보적 존재감 입증
요코하마부터 서울까지 ‘폭군의 셰프’ 감동과 여운 연말까지 잇는다

https://t.co/G8HSoL6J1I

#LIMYOONA #임윤아
#GirlsGeneration #소녀시대
#tvN #폭군의셰프 #Bon_Appetit_Your_Majesty
#YeonJiYoung #연지영

[Sar @invyouuu]

@RacunBelanja Bismillah… gak ada salahnya mencoba 🙌