@MiriamFein @Eduventuring04 @MrWheelerTeach@DavisTeaching Miriam, You continue to do a great job of asking questions to help move a conversation from generalities that can't easily be discussed with nuance... to specifics that help individuals pinpoint areas of agreement and areas where we can dig deeper.
@karenvaites@right2readproj@ehanford@ehanford manages to do the impossible, which so many have tried to do for years w/ little traction, but somehow she hasn't done enough? Why not simply suggest a topic for her next series, rather than expect her to create a 12-part blockbuster instead of a 6-part blockbuster?
@natwexler @Say_Dyslexia @ehanford I love your work, @natwexler , but I admit that when I read The Knowledge Gap, I was disappointed that you barely commented on the huge gaps in teaching students how to decode/encode. But I didn't think you owed it to anyone to cover it.
@kato_NV True! Been there. Used to be a high school history teacher. Then I found out that kids were being failed by a "multi-cueing" approach to teaching reading. That changed my professional trajectory 17 years ago.
@MiriamFein @DrMPaff @cpatrickproctor @mgpotente @ReadOrPrison @Say_Dyslexia @missypurcell1 @Veggievangelist@tenati0us_tina@dyslexiamama@dyslexiasomd@athorsen16@ReadWellAlaska 2x a week in tutoring setting and ask parents to do this at home.
Daily, if possible, in school setting, but not easy to find 1-on-1 time. If parents ask for ideas I suggest this or that they alternate reading every other word, modeling slow-blending more challenging words.
@DrMPaff @cpatrickproctor @mgpotente @ReadOrPrison @Say_Dyslexia @missypurcell1 @Veggievangelist@tenati0us_tina@dyslexiamama@dyslexiasomd@athorsen16@ReadWellAlaska Notched card, 1-on-1, for 5-10 minutes/day. Sit on the student's right hand side, so you can see the words that are coming. PM with ORF probes re: https://t.co/nZle28aLE6 to educators on the https://t.co/xdFkhRhlSu message board years ago. Can take several months, but works well.
@DrMPaff @rrcna_org I quoted Clay in a long thread a few years' back, and people jumped on me for taking her quotes "out of context" and they attacked me/my motives. Not one defended her actual words. Keep on quoting her. It's eye-opening to parents and teachers alike.
@ruebeckerman@chitterbugg99@ehanford Many teachers have had the same concerns about multi-cueing in reading instruction that Emily Hanford has now highlighted for the general public. Teachers are now feeling more empowered to speak up themselves. We know we are part of the solution.
@live4literacy @HelenProulx2@tomtakeflight @NarelleLyn @DoctorSam7 School teacher for over 20 years. I love learning from fellow educators and from primary sources. I read Marie Clay's words and tweeted them out. Which of her quotes in my thread do you find compelling and likely to help teachers teach a child to read?
Found my notes from years ago, when I decided to see what Marie Clay, founder of Reading Recovery, had to say about reading instruction. It was worse that I had imagined. [A thread]
@theOGlibrarian@TheAaveMaria Do you mean for segmentation? Or while blending? or both? Tapping fingers on the thumb (so only 4-phoneme words)? Or "finger phonemes" (flicking up a finger for each, so could do 5-phoneme words)?