@PHYS878@Domenic_Toronto@RaymondArroyo True. I miss exactly zero Protestant hymns after my conversion (8 years ago). Thankfully I hear Gregorian chant every Sunday.
Odd request seeing that it wasn't an ad hoc list in 382, but discerned as to what was already being used. And then the fact that you already have citations of the book as the word of God prior to 382.
But curious: if we unearthed a list in the year 300 AD that included I Maccabees, would that convince you? Or would you just ask for a list prior to 300 AD?
@mustache_superb@whpub@WesleyLHuff "Scripture is sufficient for faith and practice" - even if I grant this, it wouldn't put to rest the debate. We'd have to discuss exactly what constitutes a valid handling of the Scriptures.
Why would I be tired of evangelization? When I was in the OPC years ago (taking classes at Knox seminary, studying under R.C. Sproul Sr!), I was turned on to Thomas Aquinas, the Reformation, and the theological controversies surrounding the Council of Trent. I read as much of the primary Reformation sources as I could get my hands on (Calvin's Institutes, Luther, Chemnitz, and Melanchthon's works, and on and on). I think a good Protestant would want to discuss the Gospel with Catholics. I take zero offense.
That's a judgment you formulated without any knowledge of what I believe. I didn't say Scripture is meaningless; I was critiquing your assumption about Sacred Scriptures in relationship to the question of justice.
Just because the Bible is silent on what to do in the case of particular public breaches of trust doesn't mean we're hopelessly lost on what we're dealing with and what is owed.
@alexanderw36@IchimokuSatoshi@papism101 If you're going to flex in Latin, at least get "Solus Christus" right.
Also, what makes you think EO Christians don't "turn to Christ alone for the forgiveness" of sins?
I am Catholic but I agree with this rationale. Paul wasn't submitting the Apostolic teaching to their judgment -- as if the Bereans could come back to Paul and say, "Sorry, I don't see your preaching in the Torah."
They were noble for the very fact that they gladly received the Apostolic hermeneutic first, then searched the Scriptures aright.
"So that's not in Scripture" -
Restoring what was stolen is a very obvious Scriptural principle. It doesn't have to exhaustively detail every circumstance for us to know where it applies.
Furthermore, natural law antedates Scripture, and God is the author no less since He gave us reason and we bear His image. Scripture, for example, nowhere says IVF is prohibited either, but we recognize the evil for what it is on natural principles. What's more, Scripture nowhere says an application must be explicated in Scripture for it to be legitimate. You imported that.
Finally, I didn't say justice originates with us, I said sin creates a debt because it robs from God and Man what is their due. So yeah, Mr. Huff owes the public an apology since he deceived them about his credentials, but even more egregious is his milquetoast non-apology video.
@mustache_superb@whpub@WesleyLHuff Itβs a matter of justice. Sin creates a debt with the one it deprives or offends. A man who is caught lying to gain public credentials owes the public an apology since it is a form of robbery (stealing trust).
@ErickYbarra3 PSA was alive and well before the Protestant revolt. The critics need to distinguish between what Catholics extrapolate from that reality and what Protestants extrapolate from it.
@IndianaBrunner Who do I consult on a difficult doctrinal subject when I am not sure whether my reading of the text is faithful to the Scriptures? A Church Father? Or you?