@CrushnSerpents has accused me of lying in my opening statement during my debate with @ArchangeloRom yesterday. The public accusation provides an opportunity as entertaining as it is instructional. No, I did not lie, and he has yet to identify "the lie" of which I am accused. And by the way, there are no "hundreds of pages of context" in Fragment 37 of Irenæus. It's a paragraph.
In my opening yesterday, I stated quite clearly that the ancient Church believed the Malachi 1:11 prophecy was a Eucharist offering of the first fruits of the harvest for the poor. After the Eucharist "sacrifice" was over, they would take some bread and wine from the Eucharist offering and consecrate it, as I said, either by saying'This is My Body,' and 'This is My blood' or by invoking the Holy Spirit to similar effect. But the Eucharist offering was over before the bread and wine were consecrated, and the consecrated bread and wine were not offered. There was no offering of "Jesus' body and blood" in the ancient church. That abominable novelty came along in the late 4th century.
Evidence that first-fruits was the only Eucharist oblation of the ancient church is abundant:
Justin Martyr said the ONLY honour worthy of God is for us to use the fruit of the harvest "for ourselves and those who need, and with gratitude to Him to offer thanks" (First Apology, 13) and that "prayers and giving of thanks, when offered by worthy men, are the ONLY perfect and well-pleasing sacrifices to God" (Trypho 117). When he describes the ancient liturgy, there is an offering of thanks for food (First Apology 65, 67) with no mention of having consecrated the food before offering, and when there is a mention of a consecration (First Apology, 66), it is spoken over the food that had just been "eucharisted," and there is no mention of offering the now consecrated food. Thus does Justin rule out a liturgical offering of Jesus' body and blood. Unconsecrated food is offered to God. Consecrated food is given to the flock to eat. But consecrated food is not offered.
Irenæus describes something similar when he says "We are bound, therefore, to offer to God the first-fruits of His creation" (Against Heresies 4.18.1), and "the Church alone offers this pure oblation to the Creator, offering to Him, with giving of thanks, [the things taken] from His creation" (4.18.4). He then criticizes the Gnostics for offering the first fruits of creation to "the Father" while not even believing the first fruits had come from "the Father," then pronouncing the consecration over over food that had just been eucharisted: "But how can they be consistent with themselves, [when they say] that the bread over which thanks have been given is the body of their Lord, and the cup His blood" (Against Heresies 4.18.5). Food is offered. Then it is consecrated. But consecrated food is not offered.
Origen describes this exact same liturgical order in Against Celsus 8.34, noting that in the Eucharist "we offer first-fruits, we also send up our prayers," and in 8.57 "And we have a symbol of gratitude to God in the bread which we call the Eucharist." Thus, his liturgy is succintly summarized in 8.33 as a Eucharist offering of first fruits, followed by a meal of consecrated bread: "But we give thanks to the Creator of all, and, along with thanksgiving and prayer for the blessings we have received, we also eat the bread presented to us; and this bread becomes by prayer a sacred body, which sanctifies those who sincerely partake of it.” There is no offering of consecrated bread, and when the bread is consecrated, it is not offered. Unconsecrated food is offered to God. Consecrated food is given to the flock to eat. But consecrated food is not offered.
And that gets us to Fragment 37, in which Irenæus says the Malachi 1:11 prophecy is fulfilled in the Church's oblation of first-fruits: "And therefore the oblation of the Eucharist is not a carnal one, but a spiritual; and in this respect it is pure. For we make an oblation to God of the bread and the cup of blessing, giving Him thanks in that He has commanded the earth to bring forth these fruits for our nourishment." Once that oblation is complete—as I said in my opening remarks—the minister then performs the invocation, asking that the Holy Spirit "exhibit" to the recipients the bread and cup as the body and blood of Christ: "And then, when we have perfected the oblation, we invoke the Holy Spirit, that He may exhibit this sacrifice, both the bread the body of Christ, and the cup the blood of Christ, in order that the receivers of these antitypes may obtain remission of sins and life eternal."
There is an oblation of first fruits, and then AFTER the oblation is already over, there is an invocation of the Holy Spirit to "exhibit" the offerings to the recipients, as in "the body of Christ," "the blood of Christ." What is offered is not consecrated, and what gets consecrated is not then offered.
An interesting point of trivia: "exhibit" here is the Greek word "apophene" from which we get the English word "apophenia," which is a condition in which the mind forms an otherwise abnormal connection between unrelated objects. So Irenæus' liturgy of the Eucharist concludes with a prayer that the Holy Spirit would form in the mind of the recipient a connection between something that is not the body of Christ (the bread) and something that is the body of Christ (His actual body). Thus showing that Irenæus understood the bread and wine to be symbolic—antitypical—of Christ's body and blood, but NOT ACTUALLY His body and blood.
In my opening remarks I said exactly what I believed about the ancient liturgy (an unconsecrated Eucharist was offered, and after the offering was over, the Eucharist of the bread and cup was called the body and blood of Christ, but was not then offered), I warned about the tendency of the Roman Catholic to miss that and assume that because the ancient Church offered the Eucharist (it did) and called the Eucharist "the body and blood of Christ" (it did) that therefore the ancient Church offered the body and blood of Christ in the Eucharist (it didn't).
As is now evident, @CrushnSerpents did exactly what I predicted: because after the Eucharist oblation Irenæus asks the Holy Spirit to "exhibit" the bread and wine as the body and blood of Christ, therefore THE BODY AND BLOOD OF CHRIST MUST BE WHAT IRENÆUS OFFERED IN THE EUCHARIST. But read Irenæus again and see what he offered: "For we make an oblation to God of the bread and the cup of blessing, giving Him thanks in that He has commanded the earth to bring forth these fruits for our nourishment." And of course, Irenæue did not—in Fragment 37 or anywhere else—claim that the Malachi 1:11 prophecy was fulfilled in the liturgical offering of Jesus' body and blood.
Note well: to the Roman Catholic, unless you interpret the ancient liturgy consistent with their late 4th century novelty, you're lying.
To an ignorant man, truth is falsehood if it undermines the foundation of his ignorance. @CrushnSerpents has provided a timely illustration of this reality.
I'm old enough to have done bigger and dumber things than @WesleyLHuff is accused of doing. So, hang in there, buddy. It's not the unpardonable sin.
"Yea, he shall be holden up: for God is able to make him stand" (Romans 14:4).
I don’t think he has. A cheating tax collector can repent and return honorably to his post. A repentant prostitute is not disqualified from becoming a wife. An unfaithful but repentant husband has not absolutely disqualified himself from his marriage.
Academia maintains its “standards of professionalism,” but daily tolerates things much worse than a repentant Wes Huff, I assure you!
https://t.co/HFjk21e56n
@steve_sherwood@WesleyLHuff Mind your degrees & kinds. It is possible to be greater in degree but different in kind. Use your imagination. There is a lot of things I could do that are worse than a decade of plagiarism, while having no deleterious impact on my education, my vocation or my gainful employment.
@sadib100@WesleyLHuff Because we know how much we need forgiveness, and how much we have been forgiven.
“Be kind to one another, tenderhearted, forgiving one another, as God in Christ forgave you.” (Eph 4:32)
@John_R_Fraser@WesleyLHuff You’re confusing action and consequence. Wes’s sins would be just as bad without anyone ever finding out. And it is possible to do worse and yet reap lesser consequences.
Not all public sins were committed in the digital era.
Christian scams are bad. My point is that they need not define the scammer when repentance and forgiveness are available to him. "So that contrariwise ye ought rather to forgive him, and comfort him, lest perhaps such a one should be swallowed up with overmuch sorrow" (2 Cor 2:7).
Let's see where he lands.
@rr74cm@bescofield@WesleyLHuff “Whoever conceals his transgressions will not prosper, but he who confesses and forsakes them will obtain mercy.” (Prov 28:13)
I have every confidence Wes will do the right thing. I’m just not piling on.
@JackpotMMXXVI@WesleyLHuff Certainly. My point is simply that Wes need not lose heart. God revives the spirit of the lowly and the heart of the contrite. The wheels of sanctification can turn slow slowly, and Wes is neither beyond rehabilitation nor beyond the reach of his Father.
If you’re confused by what happened in the election of Talarico in Texas on Tuesday, you need not be. Tim Keller’s exegetical chickens have simply come home to roost. Talarico was a big fan of Tim Keller’s exegetical method and has implemented it as taught. You are simply observing in real time the fruit it has borne.
@chadojackson’s observation on Talarico’s misuse of Scripture: “Instead he merely uses the Bible and Christianity and deliberately misrepresents it in order to dupe certain biblically illiterate churchgoers who unfortunately don’t know the difference, who don’t know that they’re being lied to.”
Tim Keller’s own professed exegetical method from his an 18-part course on how to Preach Christ in a Postmodern World:
On working same-sex relationships into his sermons: “I have a bible study with three gay women artists, and me. One is a Christian, one is probably a new Christian. One is very much a non-Christian. We read the Book of Ruth. What did they see? What do you think they saw? They said, ‘This is incredible. The two women create a non-traditional family in which a woman is the breadwinner. They buck the traditional family in which you have to have a man. And the basis of it is faith. Their common faith made them a family as opposed to tradition or blood.’ I had never seen that before. I had never seen that before. Why did they see it? Well, because two of the three are in long term lesbian relationships. The couples have been together for years and years and years. They immediately thought about that. Now, what I’m trying to say is: I hear the things that they say as they’re reading through the book so then that affects the way I’m preaching. When I sit down and I study the text, I’m immediately thinking of things that they said, and that automatically gets into the sermon.”
On omitting texts that are disagreeable to the postmodern mind: “That’s another problem with preaching from…Esther…. So if you’re really going to preach…Esther, you know what I’d do, in New York, I’d just never bring that out. I mean, people don’t come to church with their Bibles. They study the passage I print out in the text. So I’m just not going to bring that up.” (Session 9: Applying Christ Part IV: Getting Down to Earth Part II, 1:01:15-1:03:02)
“They don’t have Bibles. Besides that, also non-Christians may not have Bibles. So we print it out [in the church bulletin]. And that works very, very well by the way. It also is a great way of keeping away from certain texts that you don’t want them to see.” (Session 13 Q&A, 9:10-9:33)
More on Tim Keller’s professed (and flawed) exegetical method here:
https://t.co/oYSdQKg7UA
Well, if you look closely, I'm simply answering your specific claim. Your most recent argument was that "similarity of episcopal structure" suffices to prove that your religion is the same as that of the ancient Church. As you said, "So the burden of proof would be on the one claiming a different structure." But I'm not simply claiming a different structure in the ancient church. I have merely observed that similarity of episcopal structure (your argument) cannot suffice as proof of continuity because there were false bishops, false presbyters and false deacons (similar structure) in antiquity. "Similarity of episcopal structure" was in fact your argument. I think you'll agree that "similarity" therefore cannot suffice as proof of continuity because that same structure existed among heretics. For some reason you chased down a trail I had not led you, as if I was claiming that 'catholic doctrine' in the early church was the "falseness" of the episcopal structure. From this you concluded that you had caught me in a circularity:
"if they’re false because they taught Catholic doctrine, that’s classic circular reasoning ... So far we’ve got: circular reasoning, [etc...] Have I forgotten anything?"
Well yes, Dave, you have forgotten something: you forgot not to make strawmen arguments. At no point did I say they were "false bishops because they taught Catholic doctrine." In fact I have repeatedly insisted that the ancient bishop they did not teach Roman Catholic doctrine. To you I was simply relying on the testimony of the ancient writers who, indeed, acknowledge that a "similar structure" existed among some heretics and schismatics.
In any case to your various points. You wrote:
"On Tertullian vs. Irenaeus about Clement: they’re counting differently, not contradicting each other."
Well, thank you for your fallible opinion, but the ancient record indeed says they were contradicting each other and counting differently. The Catholic Encyclopedia says, "we cannot accept as more reliable Tertullian's assertion, which unquestionably places St. Clement after the Apostle Peter, as was also done later by other Latin scholars." And in Lives of Illustrious Men, Jerome says plainly that the majority of Latins believed that "most of the Latins think that Clement was second after the apostle." And to my point, Tertullian's description explicitly states that he was counting bishops "running down in due succession from the beginning," including Polycarp immediately succeeding John, and obviously Clement immediately succeeding Peter. The lists contradict each other Dave. It's silly to maintain otherwise, but I understand why you feel the urge to ret-conn. It's a temptation that is hard for you to resist. But more importantly, why should I take your opinion (that they were just counting differently) over Tertullian's, Jerome's and the Catholic Encyclopedia's, that Tertullian was indeed contradicting Irenæus? Why should I take your opinion over "most of the Latins"?
You continued:
"On episcopal terminology: yes, episkopos and presbyteros were sometimes used interchangeably but that doesn’t mean bishops didn’t exist as a distinct office. Ignatius settles it: ‘Apart from the bishop, the presbytery, and the deacons, there is no Church.’"
Why does Ignatius "settle it"? Clement was before him. Would you accept my argument if I said "Clement settles it"? All I said was that Clement regarded them as the same. Therefore he cannot be brought forward to testify in favor of your "similarity of episcopal structure." He provides you no supporting evidence. You can't bring him forward as a witness and then say Ignatius settles his adverse opinion.
You continued:
"On Tertullian saying succession isn’t necessary: you’re making him contradict himself within the same work."
On the contrary. You make him contradict himself by saying there was succession from Peter "from the beginning," and then insisting that he didn't really mean "from the beginning," but rather started counting with Clement. What is more, I do not make him contradict. He says, "if there be any (heresies) which are bold enough to plant themselves in the midst of the apostolic age ... Let them produce the original records of their churches. ... For this is the manner in which the apostolic churches transmit their registers:" So far so good. Then he says of recent churches that are "founded daily" and therefore have no such registers, that they, too, will put the heretics to the same test, requiring the heretics who claim apostolic origin to produce original records, even though the recent churches themselves have no such records. As Tertullian says, "although they derive not their founder from apostles or apostolic men ... yet, since they agree in the same faith, they are accounted as not less apostolic because they are akin in doctrine." My advice to you is that you read the evidence more closely before making such blanket statements. I represented Tertullian accurately: a heretic who claims apostolic origins of his teachings must "show for his ordainer and predecessor some one of the apostles or of apostolic men," but churches that are not introducing heresies have no such obligations, precisely my point. It does not, however, support yours.
You continued:
"On Irenaeus and the illiterate barbarians: a pastoral observation about uneducated converts holding the faith in their hearts."
Yes, but did they have the correct "episcopal structure," Dave?
You continued:
"In the same book he makes Roman episcopal succession the primary proof of apostolic orthodoxy. ... For it is a matter of necessity that every Church should agree with this Church, on account of its preeminent authority."
Well, kind of. He argues for continuity, but as I have stated, your use of both Tertullian and Irenæus to prove continuity is a double-edged sword. There is an argument for continuity to show apostolic origins, but there is also a contradiction in their lists of succession, which calls that continuity into question. How is it possible that such an important attribute (a reliable record of succession) was lost within one generation of Peter? What is more, a claim of apostolic continuity, even from "real" successors, is not a guarantee of accuracy or truth. After all, Irenæus joined the European bishops in "sharply rebuking" Victor of Rome, and praised Polycarp and Anicetus for remaining in fellowship even after Anicetus could not persuade Polycarp based on what he had received from Peter, and Polycarp could not persuade Anicetus based on what he had received from John and the other apostles. And Firmilian of Cæsarea complained that "they who are at Rome do not observe those things in all cases which are handed down from the beginning, and vainly pretend the authority of the apostles." How good is apostolic succession if even the successors of the apostles don't regard it as authoritative? In any case, this section of Irenæus only survives in the "barbarous" Latin translation, as the scholars attest, and it is by no means certain what Irenæus meant by it in the original Greek, and they are not even certain it means what the English translation from Latin suggests. There are parts of Irenæus that survive in his original greek, but this is not one of them. It's hardly compelling when Irenæus himself did not always agree with the Church at Rome, and when even Catholic scholars disagree with the implications of the English translation you provided.
You continued:
"On Ignatius and independence: the man you’re using to argue for independent churches wrote to Rome calling her the church that ‘presides over love... worthy of God, worthy of honour, worthy of the highest happiness, worthy of praise, worthy of obtaining her every desire, worthy of being deemed holy.’ A bishop of Antioch, disciple of the apostles, voluntarily deferring to Rome’s authority on his way to martyrdom."
Umm, no. Ignatius also said the Bishop of Magnesia presides "in the place of God." Shall I convert immediately to the One Holy Apostolic Magnesian Catholic Church based on his letter to the Magnesians? He wrote a lot of flowery language, Dave. Your citation from his letter to Rome is hardly determinative, and his flowery language was not reserved for Rome alone. Besides, the ancient evidence is that the jurisdiction of the bishop of Rome was just the city and its suburbs, which is why Cyprian referred to the Roman clergy as the "City clergy," and Milan and its bishop were the Chief Metropolis and Metropolitan Bishop of Italy. In truth, Ignatius' reference to the church "which also presides in the place of the region of the Romans" is a term of diminution, not magnification, and carries the meaning of the limited jurisdiction of the Bishop there. He said a lot of nice things about each church he wrote to. Rome was not exceptional.
You continued:
"That is not a senior pastor answering to God alone."
Umm, it kind of is, Dave. He wrote "to Polycarp, Bishop of the Church of the Smyrnæans, or rather, who has, as his own bishop, God the Father, and the Lord Jesus Christ." This was typical back then. In Ignatius' absence, God was the bishop of the Syrians. Polycarp's bishop was God the Father and Jesus Christ. As I observed in a previous exchange, when Stephen tried to intervene in Spain, the Spaniards wrote to Cyprian who responded that the Spaniards could ignore Stephen and do as they pleased in the disputed matter. The bishop of Rome had a very limited jurisdiction back then, as in just the surrounding countryside around the city itself.
You concluded: "Show me Presbyterian polity before Calvin. Memorialism before Zwingli. Forensic imputation before Luther."
You go first. Show me Roman Catholicism before Damasus. You still have not done so.
So this is from last year, but @JoeHeschmeyer thinks he has the question that can finally stump the Protestants. The question is intended force the unsuspecting Protestant to paint himself into a corner: "Who was the first pope?" If the answer is "Peter," then "Why aren't you Catholic?", right? And if the answer is "someone else," then "Who was it and how do you know that they’re the first one?" Whoever is identified as the first is, to Joe, sufficiently ancient that it still comes down to, "Then why aren't you Catholic?" Oh no! An impossible trap!
No, not really. There's an easy way out of this, if you're willing to take it.
First, Joe's question is a little anachronistic. Cyprian of Carthage was called "Pope" by the congregation in Rome, and Athanasius of Alexandria was called "Pope" as well. It was a common title long before it came to refer singularly to the bishop of Rome. But "who was the first pope?" isn't even the real question. The real question is "Who was Bishop of Rome at the time prophesied by Scripture for the emergence of the Little Horn that arose among the fragments of the Roman Empire?" and the answer is easy: Pope Damasus (AD 366 to 384).
We know this because Daniel prophesied that the Roman Empire would break into 13 fragments, and a Little Horn would arise among the fragments and claim three of them for himself (Daniel 7:20,24). (You can read why there were 13 here: https://t.co/5iQSdUaBcQ)
Sometime between about AD 370 and AD 383, during the pontificate of Damasus, the Roman empire divided into 13 dioceses, each under a metropolitan city. It was under Damasus' reign that the theory of the Three Petrine Sees originated. He claimed that the Church was built upon Peter's three seats in Rome (because that's where Peter died), in Alexandria (because that's where his disciple, Mark, ended up) and in Antioch (because that's where he started). Those three cities were by then the three metropolitan cities of the three Dioceses of Italy, Egypt and Oriens. And there began the claim that the true Church of Christ was Built upon "A See of One in Three Places." The fact that the Little Horn had already scooped them up on his rise is the reason Daniel only saw 10 horns remaining as it came to full stature, a prophecy almost a thousand years in its fulfillment.
Unsurprisingly, Damasus' rise to power was accompanied by all the carnal, murderous ambition that you would expect from such a figure. Ammianus Marcellinus records the violent election: "Damasus and Ursinus, being both immoderately eager to obtain the bishopric, formed parties and carried on the conflict with great asperity, the partisans of each carrying their violence to actual battle, in which men were wounded and killed. ... Ultimately Damasus got the best of the strife by the strenuous efforts of his partisans." (Roman History 27.3.12-13).
The English here is too polite. The Latin is much less dainty: "Damasus and Ursinus, burning with an intensity that transcended human bounds to seize the episcopal see..."
"An intensity that transcended human bounds."
I'll bet it did.
When all the dust settled, the basilica was soaked in the blood of 137 men, so "immoderately eager" 🧐 were these men to occupy this newly powerful episcopate.
Good times.
Unsurprisingly this Little Horn would one day find itself on the receiving end of the fawning attention of a false prophet (the Apparition of Mary) that could even make the fire of heaven descend to earth in the sight of men (Fatima), urging us all to bow down before an image (the Eucharist) that is known occasionally to bleed, pulsate, and even speak (Euharistic miracles). Yes, there was a time when men were put to death for not worshiping that image. Who could've seen that coming? (Revelation 13:15).
So, the first "Pope" (the way Roman Catholics really mean it) was Damasus. I know this because he arose at the time the Roman empire finally divided into 13 dioceses, and right on cue, he claimed 3 them as the seat of the new world religion, bearing the fruits of covetousness, carnal ambition and murder to attain to his throne.
And that leads to Joe's most favorite question of all: "Who founded the Roman Catholic Church?"
This, too, Scriptures answer plainly: "The dragon gave his power and his throne and great authority" to the Beast (Revelation 13:2).
Joe's questions are carefully crafted to force the Protestant to implicitly assume Joe's premise: an unbroken unfolding of Church History from Peter to Leo XIV. If you grant that assumption, there can be no "first pope" without conceding that Roman Catholicism is the Church Jesus founded on Peter.
But if you study the history of what Daniel foresaw, what happened with Damasus was a new thing, utterly unrelated to Jesus' promises to His Church, a grotesque departure from the preceding centuries. It was a new religion for a new empire, and Damasus was it's first "Pope." And the fact that practically the whole world fell for the lie should not surprise us in the least because this, too, had been foreseen: "the whole earth marveled as they followed the beast" (Revelation 13:3).
As I said, you need not be stumped by Joe's questions. But you do have to be willing to avoid the trap he has laid for you. 😇
https://t.co/iQLzy8f0Tw
@garrettham_esq , this is one of my favorite questions.
The ancient church understood that it lived under the Roman empire, and that according to Daniel‘s prophecies, the Roman empire would soon split 10 ways and the wicked one, the beast of Revelation 13, the little Horn of Daniel 7, would scoop up three of the 10 and begin to rule over the rest as the 5th earthly empire of Daniel‘s visions.
Have you ever wondered to yourself, what would happen if the Roman Empire divided into 10 horns, and the wicked one snatched away three: how many horns would be left? There would be 7.
And yet in every depiction of the 5th empire in scripture, the beast of Revelation 13 has 10 horns in his entourage. Revelation 12, Revelation 13, revelation 17 all depict 10 horns all the way up to the very end when they do battle against the Lamb.
But if the Roman empire divided into 10 horns and the wicked one uprooted three, why do 10 remain? That’s a question that puzzled me for decades. Scripture abhors a contradiction.
It turns out that Daniel chapter 7 was written in a language that has no past perfect tense. And therefore there was no way in the original language to state that the little Horn came up among 10 horns, having already uprooted three in his uprising. That meaning can only be discerned in context, and Revelation provides that context.
The solution to the apparent contradiction between Daniel 7 and Revelation chapters 12, 13 and 17 is that Daniel was in fact aware that the Roman empire would divide 13 ways and the little Horn he saw arising had already scooped up three when he arose. Daniel chapter 7, never says that there had only been 10 horns in the original division and neither does it say that the wicked one or the little Horn scooped up three of the 10. There were in fact 13 horns before the little one arose.
The antagonist of Daniel chapter 7, that little Horn, also identified in Revelation 13 as the beast of the sea, is whoever scooped up three of the 13 divisions of the Roman Empire.
You will therefore find it fascinating to discover that in fact, the Roman empire was divided 13 ways. Under Diocletian it was divided into 12 dioceses and over the next century through readjustment and shifts they ended up being 13 dioceses, the 13th of which was formed only in about AD 370.
In AD 381, the council of Constantinople had the temerity to suggest that it was second only to Rome, and was in fact the new Rome.
The bishop of Rome responded that the see of Peter existed in three places simultaneously: in Rome, in Alexandria, and Antioch, and certainly not in Constantinople. And therefore the church, he claimed, the see of Peter was in fact of see of one existing in three places. Those three cities happen to be the three chief Metropoli of the three dioceses of Italy, Egypt, and Oriens. And therefore in its carnal. Geopolitical ambition, the episcopate of Rome fulfilled Daniel‘s prophecy and became the fifth earthly empire of Daniel’s visions, scooping up three dioceses of the 13-way division of the empire and eventually subjugating the remaining 10.
The rest is just details, but to prove that Roman Catholicism is apostate, does not require that I prove to your satisfaction that there is a separate church that existed throughout history. All I have to do is prove that Roman Catholicism is in fact, the apostasy that Daniel foresaw.
Once you realize that, you will begin to search elsewhere for the true church. But the scripture has already informed us that that true church is not Roman Catholicism. To begin your studies I invite you to consider this article called a See of One.
https://t.co/ypE9z4gIw0