Dear Mr Turlov and Mr Anand,
As Chief Arbiter of the Total Chess World Championship Tour Pilot 2026 in Budapest, I consider it my duty to defend the ten highly qualified arbiters whose professional reputations FIDE has publicly called into question.
I categorically reject the following unsubstantiated statement published by FIDE today, 21 November 2026, on its official website and social media channels:
“Furthermore, the officiating during the event fell short of fundamental standards, as the arbiters effectively abdicated their responsibility to uphold the FIDE Laws of Chess and tournament regulations. Consequently, the actions of the arbiters involved will be referred to the FIDE Arbiters’ Commission (ARB) and its Disciplinary Sub-Committee (DSC) for thorough examination and assessment.”
Throughout the tournament, my team and I acted in accordance with the FIDE Laws of Chess and the tournament regulations jointly approved by FIDE and Norway Chess. As Chief Arbiter, I was in direct daily contact with the organisers on all matters arising during the tournament. No participant appealed an arbiter's decision during the event, and I received no formal complaint about the team's conduct.
In the course of the event, no FIDE representative contacted me on any matter, either directly or through the organisers. Nor was I contacted before the statement was published on 21 November 2026. Nevertheless, FIDE publicly accused the arbiters of failing to fulfil their fundamental professional responsibilities without identifying a single specific breach, thereby already causing damage to their professional reputations and violating the fundamental principle of the presumption of innocence.
By making such categorical accusations before any formal proceedings had taken place, FIDE has prejudged their outcome and presented an unproven allegation as established fact. This is contrary to the principles of procedural fairness that FIDE itself is obliged to uphold.
I therefore formally demand that FIDE immediately withdraw its public allegations, publish a retraction through the same official channels used for the original statement, and publicly apologise to the arbiters' team for the damage already caused to their professional reputations.
Sincerely,
Anastasia Sorokina
International Arbiter, Women International Master,
Chief Arbiter, Total Chess
@FIDE_chess
📷 @TotalChess Michal Walusza
@ChrisBirdIA Magnus uses loopholes =bad. Arbiters use loopholes= harsh.. can we blame the actual loopholes? I’ll die on hill that pilots should not be this big of a deal. It’s a pilot.. this is good thing. All the obvious loopholes were discovered and granted exploited. Pilot successful
@HansMokeNiemann Agree with all except 4. Can you address another issue? On that vein. Now perhaps it is already addressed by point allocation.. but if someone won a match do remaining games count.? Not just for this competition but all formats. Also it appeared there was agreed quick draws too
@christi_da54750@HansMokeNiemann Honestly the stream did a bad job regardless of Magnus. The fact that there was still an ongoing match and a winner was decided is laughable.
I stand firmly in defence of Magnus Carlsen following the controversy at the Total Chess pilot tournament in Budapest.
When senior FIDE officials, including Deputy President Anand and Advisor Sutovsky, publicly criticised Magnus for missing scheduled games, they raised legitimate questions about sporting responsibility.
Anand questioned Carlsen’s decision while also acknowledging that the tournament regulations needed improvement. Sutovsky went further, publicly describing his conduct as “pathetic” and “unsportsmanlike.”
Every player who sits down at the board deserves an opponent. Bibisara certainly deserved that respect, and I believe Magnus should have ensured she was informed of his decision.
However, I believe we are overlooking a much bigger problem.
Why did the tournament regulations create a situation in which not playing was more beneficial than playing?
By the time Magnus was scheduled to face Bibisara, he had already won their match. According to the chief arbiter’s explanation, he consulted the arbiters before the game. Forfeiting the remaining game would count as a loss in the match but would not affect his classical rating.
Had he played and drawn, he would still have won the match but would have lost rating points because of the rating difference.
Think about that.
The regulations effectively created an incentive for a player to stay away from the board rather than compete.
Magnus later missed two rapid games against Vladislav and acknowledged that rating considerations influenced his decision.
I am not suggesting that every decision Magnus made was correct. Nor am I ignoring the reported instruction that all scheduled games were expected to be played.
But if tournament regulations create incentives that contradict the fundamental principles of sporting competition, we must examine those regulations rather than focus exclusively on criticising individual players.
And this brings me to another important issue.
I call upon senior FIDE officials, including Mr Anand and Mr Sutovsky, to demonstrate neutrality, professionalism and institutional responsibility.
Of course, officials are entitled to personal opinions. But when someone holds a senior position in an international sports federation, their public statements carry additional weight.
I find it concerning when senior officials publicly criticise athletes over controversies arising from competitions within the international chess system without placing sufficient emphasis on examining the underlying regulations.
Public criticism of individual athletes should never become a substitute for institutional accountability.
Their responsibility should be to identify problems, establish the facts and help improve the system.
Players are expected to respect the rules. Officials must be expected to take responsibility for them.
This principle applies to everyone, regardless of their name, reputation or position.
I have always said:
Chess is not merely a game. Chess is a sport.
And professional sport requires professional governance.
If a game remains mandatory after the match has been decided, the regulations must clearly establish that obligation and meaningful consequences for failing to play.
If the game serves no further competitive purpose, organisers should consider ending the match.
What cannot become normal is a system where avoiding competition offers a better outcome than competing.
Budapest was a pilot tournament. That is precisely why these problems should be identified and corrected before the format develops further.
My position is clear:
Bibisara deserved respect and proper communication.
Magnus deserved clear, consistent regulations.
FIDE and Norway Chess must examine the incentives created by the tournament format.
And senior officials must demonstrate the same accountability they demand from athletes.
I defend Magnus not because he is Magnus Carlsen, but because the principle matters for every chess player.
@4Lukerich@EZTEENSCOM@AraMix_model Don’t bother.. been telling this admin for a year website doesn’t let anyone register..they don’t care. No join us page exists.
@Harryputtar98 Yeah.. Heavy is head wears crown. Magnus recent interview toxic relationship with title.,. Ding left chess for almost two years… Gukesh also interview you can see expectations are overwhelming .
@thelongdiagonal Magnus didn’t cherry picked opponents… just saying all three have drama in their careers.. rating for Magnus.. cherry picking for Kasparov.. Fischer wanted to retain championship if sets ended in a draw.. different topics.. “drama, drama, drama..”
@EmilSutovsky@AlirezaFirouzja Stop bringing it up then… you could have just said look at this wholesome interaction.. also tell me why winner was decided yet two players were still playing match… organizers bad job not having final be last game. The actual coverage was terrible. Nothing to do with drama.