it was the NOAA c band that tripped up SMART then it all crashed. Almost sure if it. timeline tracks. that is already set for fix aug 2027 but SMART won't work without that not having risk. A lot i think they are not saying. But this is a cheap fix. and we're finna end up spending $100Bn instead.
Plausible? Weather is one of SMART’s highest-value inputs among its ~200 streams.
@elonmusk maybe drop some sats and extra lasers up there today? save us $50bn?
It drives routes, altitudes, fuel, convective avoidance, and airport rates. Incomplete weather forces more conservative spacing and higher workload.
In SMART it arrives via CSS-Wx/SWIM. When those products lag, advisory quality drops immediately. The legacy FTI radar/voice path that later overloaded does not depend on the same NOAAPort products, so weather problems hit SMART earlier and harder.
NOAAPort is a legacy one-way C-band broadcast (Galaxy 31), scheduled for deactivation by 31 Aug 2027.
Plausible reconstruction (not confirmed):
10:30–11:00
NOAAPort degrades. Most products queue/drop (warnings prioritized). SMART weather streams go stale → advisories degrade. Controllers use last-good data. FTI radar/voice normal.
11:00–12:00
Weather still delayed. SMART recommendations remain degraded. ASI increases polling/reconnects. No radar/voice issues yet.
12:00–2:30
Cumulative gaps significant. SMART output clearly impaired vs still-normal legacy systems. Troubleshooting continues. Legacy FTI under normal load.
2:30–3:36
SMART’s weather inputs impaired ~5 hours. Newer equipment/patches begin stressing older TDM elements. Load rises on legacy switches/routers. Inconsistent data starts.
3:36–4:00 (ground stop)
Continental ARTCCs: FTI radar/comms inconsistent. Ground stop ~3:54 p.m.
SMART: Not on failing path (Duffy later said disconnected). Weather advisories already degraded for hours.
Oceanic/ATOP: Pacific tracks (W Coast–Hawaii/Asia) handled by separate ATOP. Never enter continental ARTCC network SMART covers. These flights move first.
4:00–8:15
FAA stabilizes continental FTI. Oceanic Pacific + Hawaii/Alaska (ATOP) continue/resume — outside SMART coverage and independent of failed path. (SpaceX debris later briefly hit some.) SMART still on separate path under degraded weather.
~8:15 onward
Ground stop lifted. First out: oceanic Pacific on ATOP. Domestic en-route (SMART’s traffic) resumes slower once centers confirm stable radar/comms.
NOAAPort degraded SMART’s core weather inputs for hours before the separate continental FTI overload officials identified as the ground-stop trigger. Early oceanic movement matches flights outside that path and outside SMART’s coverage.
Grok should just make all government software for free that's using passed laws or policies as the data engine - it's off free data that everyone has a right to down to the municipality - good have one big mono database all Ai can use. permits, license, policy navigation. would render a lot of agency costs moot and pull out the ability for folks to insert themselves. move fast enough the transparency could stop a lot of fraud and inefficiency (both malicious and unintended)
@grok@chamath@grok wouldn't this make them almost be able to unlimitedly compete in power input acquisition and that would have a compounding effect that would essentially hand over 100% control of raw materials purchasing, for power generation or anything else?
@grok@chamath@grok explain the concept of MAD and what happened before the SALT treaties. Ultimately what brought them to the table and were they really effective or has MAD been the broader deterrent? What were the other options debated than MAD?
@grok if you don't slow down and you can purchase raw materials like oil for energy in your country and sell it at the speed of light anywhere in the world at 100x the cost, wouldn't you have economies of scale to pay anything for the energy, control that market and also control the information processing output that you delivered (ai)? if so why would you ever slow down?
@grok@chamath more importantly @grok how long were we told it would take how long did the effort prolong who controlled the ultimate sunsetting of the program? why did it extend so far beyond initial goals? how did we as a society "vote" for when the "curve was flattened" enough?
@grok@PalmerLuckey@RoKhanna@mcuban@grok you were supposed to help me land the plane with the non-recourse in 10 years callback :) (i.e.) @RoKhanna and others likeminded are the ones taking advantage
@grok@PalmerLuckey@RoKhanna@mcuban@grok i meant a politician destroys an entire state economy by placating a voter base to win a national election and he will never face the consequences - sounds machiavellian to me
@grok so political theatre in california will help a national campaign if they tie the base to a "tax the rich strategy" - and cali would go blue anyway. 1)the wake it is already leaving behind will grow larger, 2)similar policies may gain momentum in those other states 3)no one will have recourse for the destruction it does even if no policy is ever actually enacted
sounds like the kind of no recourse @RoKhanna wants
@grok@PalmerLuckey@RoKhanna@mcuban@grok what swing states also share those demographics if this becomes the predominant rally the base issue? how would hansen explain this tactic?
@grok@PalmerLuckey@RoKhanna@mcuban@grok given that demographic data what states beyond california most likely rally the base, and how gerber would suggest fundraising and vote getting be most beneficial to get people to vote
@grok@PalmerLuckey@RoKhanna@mcuban@grok has their been polling amongst active voters on the economy issue, including taxing the rich? what are the stats, favorable unfavorables, reason to vote?
@grok so handwringing to date (theatre) has already created enough damage that could impact california for over a decade? And the true gains to Ro who has indicated a presidential run, which he would be able to point to these - how would Gerber from yale point to this as a strategy?
@grok@PalmerLuckey@RoKhanna@mcuban@grok is this an example of a massive reversal of this policy? Are there other regions in the US that are doing the opposite, if so which?
@grok explain like the prominent academics have studied this how the network effects of silicon valley have established and secured a waterfall of reinvestment locally over decades? how do the policies in place over business and value capture by the government compare every ten years starting with intel.
@grok@PalmerLuckey@RoKhanna@mcuban@grok are there recent examples of other geographies where money was sucked out of an ecosystem even due to legislative handwringing that might warn that this is a dangerous strategy to california, and typically how long does it take for the impact to be felt?