Why has a country of India’s size, intellectual inheritance, and scientific workforce produced so few Nobel laureates working within its own institutions?
✍️ @jmanjaly
https://t.co/DS80R6pAvd
Why has a country as large as India, with its rich intellectual heritage and robust scientific workforce, produced so few Nobel laureates? In my article for The Hindu, "Why India Can’t Win Nobel Prizes Without Questioning the ‘Competent Authority’," I argue that transformative discovery and innovation require more than just skilled workers and financial investment. I also explore how institutional hierarchies and the tendency to equate disagreement with disrespect can stifle curiosity.
[Read the full article here.] https://t.co/ktnPQgExFp
[Download the PDF here.] https://t.co/nSn8XmtHDK
We often attribute India’s limited recognition in the Nobel Prize arena to factors such as funding gaps, brain drain, or our colonial history. While these factors are significant, talent and investment alone cannot lead to transformative discoveries. Researchers also need to be part of institutions that allow them to question established truths, challenge authority, report failures, and express dissent without fear of humiliation.
This article builds upon my previous work on institutional culture. I maintain that original thinking flourishes in environments where disagreement is encouraged, authority is open to scrutiny, and students and faculty can express their thoughts without fear.
@ArtIitgn@iitgn@alumni_iitgn@NobelPrize@NobelPeaceOslo@paniitindia
#InstitutionalCulture #AcademicFreedom #CriticalThinking #ScientificTemper #HigherEducation #ResearchCulture #Curiosity #OriginalThinking #Innovation #IntellectualFreedom #QuestioningAuthority #EducationReform #IndianUniversities #NobelPrize #ScienceAndSociety #TheHindu #IIT
How psychoanalysis ruined conversations
'THE self-improvement of other people has ruined conversations for me. Increasingly, when they speak of human nature and the mind, they speak in borrowed labels and concepts. More than ever, people are attributing reasons for a person’s behaviour to something not very obvious, like the distant past or the subconscious. I have been inside the minds of these savants, and it is always a short journey.
'There was a time when I had to suffer only friends who had newly learnt of “yin and yang” and some affluent underworked people who were somehow “burnt out.”'
Read the piece free on my Substack
https://t.co/sHxNznMKPT
Teaching philosophy at IIT Gandhinagar has convinced me that a university must help students examine the assumptions behind the problems they solve. In my article "Why the humanities belong in the IITs" for The Indian Express, I argue that the humanities belong at the core of the IITs. Their place cannot depend solely on their usefulness to engineering. Questions about knowledge, justice, and society deserve space for inquiry in their own right.
Engineers inherit more than technical knowledge. They inherit ways of thinking about evidence, causation, explanation, probability, and truth that have developed over centuries of inquiry across philosophy, mathematics, and the sciences. An education should help students examine these tools, understand their limits, and contribute to their development. Merely applying inherited knowledge while dismissing the inquiry that helped produce it is a poor way to honor that inheritance"
https://t.co/Pmfj39vgjT
@iitgn@alumni_iitgn@ArtIitgn
#Humanities #Philosophy #EngineeringEducation #HigherEducation #IITGandhinagar #CriticalThinking #IndianExpress #IIT
Students are treated as adults when fees, performance, and responsibility are demanded from them, but as children when autonomy, voice, or due process become inconvenient. Harshness is then defended as character-building, and obedience is conflated with 'respect'
Written by: Jaison Manjaly
Read: https://t.co/Upv6Cwcqwg
My opinion piece in today’s Indian Express argues that student well-being primarily requires a change in institutional culture. Student well-being cannot be outsourced to counsellors alone. It is shaped every day in classrooms, hostels, laboratories, offices, and in the ways institutions respond to disagreement and distress. A humane university must be founded on freedom, equity, trust, and empathy. Students must be heard, treated with dignity, and recognised as integral participants in institutional life. Recent deaths of students at @iitdelhi and @iitbombay have reopened the discussion on well-being and what we owe to students beyond teaching and evaluation
When I began my career at IITGN, I served as a hostel warden and lived alongside students in the hostel. Later, as Dean of Student Affairs, I encouraged students to question us, disagree with us, and express dissent.
I dedicate this article to the students and alumni of IIT Gandhinagar. Over the years, they have taught me as much as I may have taught them. Their questions, disagreements, anxieties, courage, and trust have shaped my understanding of what education ought to be.
I am not a perfect teacher or administrator. I have made mistakes and may not always have understood what a student was experiencing. This piece is also a reminder to myself. It means asking, again and again, whether our institutions and we as teachers deserve the trust that students place in us.
https://t.co/9aVMgSqMKD
@iitgn@alumni_iitgn@iitbombay@iitdelhi@IITKgp@alumni_iitgn@paniitindia@paniit_usa@paniitalumni@IndianExpress
#StudentWellbeing #InstitutionalCare #AcademicFreedom #CampusCulture #Trust #Freedom #EducationWithEmpathy #HigherEducationInIndia #IITStudents #IITGandhinagar #panIIT #IIT #iitbombay #iitdelhi #iitkharagpur
Delighted to announce the Curiosity Conference 2026, hosted by Curiosity Lab, IIT Gandhinagar, in memory of the Late Kushal Sacheti. This year’s focus is the confluence of Art–Sci-Tech and Curiosity.
If you work at the intersections of education, cognition, art practice, design, technology, or social-behaviour change, please consider submitting your work and joining the conversation. You can submit
- Papers, work-in-progress reports, and posters
- Creative practice (visual, literary, performative, narrative, interactive)
- Research demos and tech-based exhibits
- Workshops and panels
Details, guidelines, and registration are on the Curiosity Lab conference page.
https://t.co/fZa1TKt8cP
#CuriosityConference #Curiosity #ArtSciTech #IITGandhinagar #Education #Cognition #Design #SocialChange #Research #PublicEngagement
@iitgn@HSSiitgn
I am deeply saddened by the passing of Kushal Sacheti. An alumnus of IIT Kanpur, Kushal was the Founder & CEO of Galaxy USA Inc. and the Centre for Curiosity, NY. I first met him at IIT Gandhinagar in 2011 during the IITGN Leadership Conclave; since then, we have stayed closely connected, speaking regularly and meeting whenever possible. He supported the Curiosity Lab in many ways and remained deeply committed to helping it grow and evolve.
Kushal was excited about the unique path IITGN was carving out for itself and was always enthusiastic about supporting its initiatives. He was a visionary entrepreneur, philanthropist, an enthusiast about Liberal Arts education in IITs, and a close friend of IIT Gandhinagar.
Every meeting with him brought new ideas, warmth, and energy. Most recently, during my visit to meet him in New York this July, he was as eager as ever to discuss new ideas and possibilities for The Centre for Curiosity and the Curiosity Lab. His passion and his belief in the importance of nurturing curiosity never wavered.
Kushal was more than a supporter; he was a guide, a friend, and a constant source of encouragement. His vision and generosity will continue to inspire me, even as I will deeply miss his presence and our conversations.
@iitgn@IITKanpur
#Curiosity #hss #Curiositylab #iitgn #IITGandhinagar #Paniit
@Schiphol@Marechaussee@Marechaussee There were just two officers who didn't seem to care and were involved in small talks while hundreds of passengers were standing in the line, worried about missing their flight. It appeared to me that the officers lacked empathy and professionalism.
@Schiphol@Marechaussee@Marechaussee, I had the ordeal of emigrating while flying out of Schipol on October 7. My flight was at 11.40 am, and I had to be in the line for almost 90 minutes to clear the emigration.
@HospitalsApollo in Gandhinagar is getting very sloppy over the years. Public washrooms don’t have tissues or hand sanitiser. When reported, the response is very cold. Appointment system is a sham. Billing takes hours. No one seems to care. @DrPrathapCReddy
This included almost equal participation by the undergraduate and postgraduate alumni of the Institute. This remarkable feat has been made possible through tireless efforts by Prof @jmanjaly and his entire team at @alumni_iitgn.
#IITGN#IITGandhinagar#IITGNAlumni#Alumni
This is monumental participation and a record of a kind nationally and internationally by the alumni of any educational Institute. Out of total 2749 alumni of IITGN, a total of 1375 alumni participated in the “Annual Alumni Giving” activity this year.