In all seriousness though, Matt is right
You know you're doing something right when you're getting replies like these
These are my favourite types of replies. When somebody admits "I never reply to cold emails but..."
If your copy, offer and targeting is on point and is easy to say yes to... THEY WILL RESPOND TO YOUR COLD EMAILS
Friendly reminder that this is how prospects should be responding to your cold emails
best way to tell your offer is ripping is if people just respond with their cell numbers telling you to call them immediately
We were booking 20 to 30 calls a day for our own offer last week, we actually had to pause sending because our calendar was completely full
With that came some unqualified people, mostly objections around price or the pricing model
So we tested putting a ballpark price in our reply to anyone who said they were interested, just to set expectations
Bookings fell off a cliff, down to 2 or 3 a day
Someone replying interested is still a cold lead. they're not a warm lead ready to talk price off a cold email they got an hour ago
The same people who wouldn't book after seeing a number in an email find it totally realistic after a discovery call
trust β price
.com domains are the goat for cold email
I trust EmailBison warmup score more than I trust gravity
As long as you're not sending super spammy or fingerprinted copy, warmup score is a pretty great indication of whether you're going to inbox
If you're getting less than 97% on inoffensive warmup emails, you've got no chance of inboxing in the real world
Since moving to setting up our own Microsoft infra in house, we've bought a load of domains and are paying even more attention to metrics than ever
.com's are consistently achieving better warmup scores, and are a lot more resilient to getting listed on Validity Heatwave and SURBL
We've tested .co's, .net's and .org's. .com's remain the goat
Some things aren't worth cutting corners on
we're probably the best case study for this
we had some rented aged tenants that used to have 99 mailboxes on them - 100% of them were shut down. even though we had them set up properly
our own in house tenants that have always been properly set up - 100% still cooking
Normally would keep this to myself
BUT
If you are doing outlook tenants with 100 inboxes/domain - expect to get smoked by MS going forward
Have this on good authority from team that oversees 3m+ active tenants
@longlivealfred there is no one size fits all answer, depends which infra you're running
some people do over complicate it though
just look at what the reputable resellers are doing and then adjust for your risk tolerance
The domain buying crackdown has actually led to a better process for us
You used to be able to grab 100 lookalikes in one go, ofc you can't do that anymore
Our own tests put domains on blacklists even when we only bought a couple from the same registrar at a time, so we automated the whole thing
- Claude generates generic domain names
- Checks whether they're on any blacklists
- Buys one domain per registrar at a time
- Runs at random points through the working day
As long as the registrars have balance it just runs
We end up with a pool of domains that just naturally age over days and weeks that we can pull from when needed