Hey @Walmart can you start a policy to ban grocery delivery drivers that smoke in their cars please? Just got a delivery and my kitchen smells like I visited a 60 year olds home that smokes two packs of heaters a day. It’s just gross. Thanks.
@altcap@InvestAmerica24@WhiteHouse Are they going to put age and zip code limits like the SpaceX donations? Have two that would qualify with no location and income rules @altcap ?
With an instructor on board it’s even worse imo. I could see a young pilot not having the SA to allow adequate separation from the jet. Having a CFI allow this to unfold is unreal.
A Cessna aircraft flipped over after being struck by a jet blast from a departing airline aircraft at John Wayne Airport on Saturday, according to a statement from Orange County Flight Center.
A flight instructor and student were onboard at the time of the incident. No injuries were reported.
@SportsCardInv Does he keep the three cards AND get that? Or is it additional. I know the three are a prereq. Has this ever happened before? Can’t imagine the cost.
Someone help me out here. We have to do a CBT every year that warns us of the dangers of "The Honeypot." You are going to tell me that no one at Nvidia warned Jensen of the dangers? Come on now, he had to have been current on all his CBTs. Or his agents were...
@Armysmostok18B@BowTiedCrow We all learn for our mistakes as well as those others make. Hoover shouldn’t scare you, should inform your decision making and be a better pilot for watching his stuff. @PilotDebrief
@AdamClampitt No problem. This is the first time I've dedicated hours to writing since I was in professional school a couple of years ago. My goal when I get out is to run multiple businesses so I can fly something similar to you. This definitely sparked my academic side again.
"So what does our club 172 have, anti-ice or de-ice?"
My IP, Hammer, asked me that in a flying club hangar in Alabama while we were doing ground review for my instrument checkride. We'd gotten on the topic of icing, and I was naturally thinking of active systems like boots or a weeping wing. Hot props, FIKI, the big-airplane stuff.
I said de-ice, because in my mind I was thinking carb ice: turn carb heat on, clear it up.
Then Hammer went down the rabbit hole.
How I got to that hangar
Quick background, because it's part of why that conversation stuck with me.
I've wanted to fly since I was a kid. Top Gun had something to do with it (lol). I had my PPL before my driver's license. I earned a pilot slot out of ROTC, then got DQ'd on depth perception. I eventually learned how to take the darn test and pass it, and reapplied, but the waiver process denied me because of the earlier depth perception failure. So I went another way, and my goofy career path continued.
I started my Air Force career as an Air Battle Manager. Later I cross-trained to fly the MQ-9. Back then, takeoffs and landings were still flown by hand over a C-band line-of-sight link, before SATCOM launch and recovery and Automated Takeoff and Landing. I went on to become an instructor and evaluator.
None of that counts with the FAA: not the RPA hours (a push for 3:1 credit toward a restricted ATP went nowhere), and not the TPE-331 systems and EP knowledge. So I bought into a flying club as a fractional owner to start earning civil ratings and keep the door open for the airlines or a similar flying path after the Air Force. I'm still undecided. So my official hours are low compared to the flying I've actually done, and explaining that gap mostly comes down to networking and conversations like this one.
A lot carried over from RPA undergraduate training in the T-6 simulator. My instrument rating took seven actual flights and then the checkride. Much of that was thanks to Hammer, a former Herc driver, experienced IP, and leader in Civil Air Patrol. He taught military style: heavy briefs and debriefs before and after every flight, plus separate ground sessions. Weather came up in all of it, because you can't separate it from instrument flying, and that's how we ended up on icing.
The rabbit hole
He covered how carb heat can actually serve as both, and how commonly that gets overlooked.
Anti-ice: Use it before ice forms, when conditions and power setting make carb ice likely.
De-ice: Use it after you see the signs (an RPM drop in a fixed-pitch airplane, often with roughness) to melt ice that's already there.
The difference is when you pull it and why. I think people miss that because "anti-ice vs. de-ice" usually gets taught as an equipment list: hot props, weeping wings, and being "certified" for it.
He also made the point that you don't need a cold day for carb ice. You can ice up on a spring or summer day in Alabama given the right conditions. Fuel vaporizing and air speeding up through the venturi can drop the temperature in the carburetor dramatically. The FAA's Pilot's Handbook of Aeronautical Knowledge says carb ice can form at outside air temperatures as high as about 100°F, with humidity as low as 50%, and the risk is highest between about 20°F and 70°F with high humidity or visible moisture. FAA bulletin SAIB CE-09-35 includes a chart of carb icing probability by temperature and dew point, and notes 212 carb-ice accidents from 1998 to 2007. Low power makes it worse: a mostly closed throttle means more cooling and less engine heat.
He didn't leave it at textbook numbers. Throughout the lesson he kept tying it back to real-world temperatures and dew points, the kind of warm, humid Alabama spring and summer days we were actually flying in.
That's why Cessna training leans so heavily on carb heat for descents and landings. The carbureted 172 manuals put it right in the Before Landing checklist: "Carburetor Heat — ON (apply full heat before closing throttle)." That's anti-ice built right into the checklist, protecting the engine before you pull the power back. SAIB CE-09-35 gives the same general guidance: check carb heat on the ground, use it on approach and descent at low power or when icing is probable, and apply full heat immediately at the first sign of ice.
Then I moved to Pipers
Now I'm flying a Warrior and an Arrow at my current flying club, and it's been an interesting and fun transition.
The Piper PA-28-161 Warrior POH takes a different approach. Its approach and landing section says carb heat should not be applied unless there is an indication of carburetor icing, because it reduces power, which may be critical in a go-around. The descent checklists say "ON if required," and for a prolonged power-off descent the POH says to apply full heat before reducing power if icing conditions are suspected. So with the Warrior, we don't pull carb heat as part of the normal landing flow like it's ingrained in Cessna flying, but the anti-ice option is still in the book when conditions call for it. The POH also warns that partial carb heat can be worse than none: use full heat, then return to full cold once the ice is gone.
The Arrow (PA-28R-201) is a different case. Its Lycoming IO-360-C1C6 is fuel-injected, so there's no carburetor and no carb heat. It has an alternate air control instead, which the POH uses for engine roughness or power loss that could come from induction icing.
Neither manufacturer is wrong. They're different airplanes with different procedures, and your airplane's POH governs. The 172R and 172S (built since the mid-1990s and today's G1000 trainers) run a fuel-injected Lycoming IO-360-L2A with no carb heat knob at all, so even "a 172" doesn't settle it. This lesson applies to the carbureted N and P models that still fill a lot of rental lines.
Opening the aperture
For me, the bigger takeaway was opening up your aperture on systems and what they can do. And it's all about the proactive versus reactive mindset. Carb heat as anti-ice is proactive: you pull it before you close the throttle on a humid day. Carb heat as de-ice is reactive: the RPM is already dropping, and now you're fixing it. Same knob, different mindset.
Pilots need to be on the front side, "ahead of the jet." We've all been there: behind the jet, SA drained, and you get quiet. That's the perfect time to use CRM. Call it out, and come up with a plan to get back on the front side of the curve.
And to be clear, we aren't talking wing and control surface icing here. That's a separate topic altogether, but related. Airframe ice needs visible moisture at or below freezing. Having pitot heat or boots doesn't make an airplane approved for known icing.
I walked into that hangar thinking I had the obvious answer. Used correctly, that single lever in a 172 can be both de-ice and anti-ice, in the right context of course. And the mindset behind it is the same one that keeps you ahead of the jet.
References: FAA Pilot's Handbook of Aeronautical Knowledge, Ch. 7 (Carburetor Icing); FAA SAIB CE-09-35, Carburetor Icing Prevention.
A reply to my post on X from @AdamClampitt and @BowTiedCFI is why I spent a couple hours on a Saturday writing for the first time in years. Watching @MCCCANM, a retired KC-10 instructor and evaluator who's now an airline captain, teach on X reminded me of something: when you're away from instructing and evaluating, actually teaching, you realize how much you miss it.
CFIs: is that how you teach it? I'd like to hear how others make this connection.
The views expressed are my own and do not reflect the official policy or position of the U.S. Air Force, Department of Defense, or U.S. Government.
"So what does our club 172 have, anti-ice or de-ice?"
My IP, Hammer, asked me that in a flying club hangar in Alabama while we were doing ground review for my instrument checkride. We'd gotten on the topic of icing, and I was naturally thinking of active systems like boots or a weeping wing. Hot props, FIKI, the big-airplane stuff.
I said de-ice, because in my mind I was thinking carb ice: turn carb heat on, clear it up.
Then Hammer went down the rabbit hole.
How I got to that hangar
Quick background, because it's part of why that conversation stuck with me.
I've wanted to fly since I was a kid. Top Gun had something to do with it (lol). I had my PPL before my driver's license. I earned a pilot slot out of ROTC, then got DQ'd on depth perception. I eventually learned how to take the darn test and pass it, and reapplied, but the waiver process denied me because of the earlier depth perception failure. So I went another way, and my goofy career path continued.
I started my Air Force career as an Air Battle Manager. Later I cross-trained to fly the MQ-9. Back then, takeoffs and landings were still flown by hand over a C-band line-of-sight link, before SATCOM launch and recovery and Automated Takeoff and Landing. I went on to become an instructor and evaluator.
None of that counts with the FAA: not the RPA hours (a push for 3:1 credit toward a restricted ATP went nowhere), and not the TPE-331 systems and EP knowledge. So I bought into a flying club as a fractional owner to start earning civil ratings and keep the door open for the airlines or a similar flying path after the Air Force. I'm still undecided. So my official hours are low compared to the flying I've actually done, and explaining that gap mostly comes down to networking and conversations like this one.
A lot carried over from RPA undergraduate training in the T-6 simulator. My instrument rating took seven actual flights and then the checkride. Much of that was thanks to Hammer, a former Herc driver, experienced IP, and leader in Civil Air Patrol. He taught military style: heavy briefs and debriefs before and after every flight, plus separate ground sessions. Weather came up in all of it, because you can't separate it from instrument flying, and that's how we ended up on icing.
The rabbit hole
He covered how carb heat can actually serve as both, and how commonly that gets overlooked.
Anti-ice: Use it before ice forms, when conditions and power setting make carb ice likely.
De-ice: Use it after you see the signs (an RPM drop in a fixed-pitch airplane, often with roughness) to melt ice that's already there.
The difference is when you pull it and why. I think people miss that because "anti-ice vs. de-ice" usually gets taught as an equipment list: hot props, weeping wings, and being "certified" for it.
He also made the point that you don't need a cold day for carb ice. You can ice up on a spring or summer day in Alabama given the right conditions. Fuel vaporizing and air speeding up through the venturi can drop the temperature in the carburetor dramatically. The FAA's Pilot's Handbook of Aeronautical Knowledge says carb ice can form at outside air temperatures as high as about 100°F, with humidity as low as 50%, and the risk is highest between about 20°F and 70°F with high humidity or visible moisture. FAA bulletin SAIB CE-09-35 includes a chart of carb icing probability by temperature and dew point, and notes 212 carb-ice accidents from 1998 to 2007. Low power makes it worse: a mostly closed throttle means more cooling and less engine heat.
He didn't leave it at textbook numbers. Throughout the lesson he kept tying it back to real-world temperatures and dew points, the kind of warm, humid Alabama spring and summer days we were actually flying in.
That's why Cessna training leans so heavily on carb heat for descents and landings. The carbureted 172 manuals put it right in the Before Landing checklist: "Carburetor Heat — ON (apply full heat before closing throttle)." That's anti-ice built right into the checklist, protecting the engine before you pull the power back. SAIB CE-09-35 gives the same general guidance: check carb heat on the ground, use it on approach and descent at low power or when icing is probable, and apply full heat immediately at the first sign of ice.
Then I moved to Pipers
Now I'm flying a Warrior and an Arrow at my current flying club, and it's been an interesting and fun transition.
The Piper PA-28-161 Warrior POH takes a different approach. Its approach and landing section says carb heat should not be applied unless there is an indication of carburetor icing, because it reduces power, which may be critical in a go-around. The descent checklists say "ON if required," and for a prolonged power-off descent the POH says to apply full heat before reducing power if icing conditions are suspected. So with the Warrior, we don't pull carb heat as part of the normal landing flow like it's ingrained in Cessna flying, but the anti-ice option is still in the book when conditions call for it. The POH also warns that partial carb heat can be worse than none: use full heat, then return to full cold once the ice is gone.
The Arrow (PA-28R-201) is a different case. Its Lycoming IO-360-C1C6 is fuel-injected, so there's no carburetor and no carb heat. It has an alternate air control instead, which the POH uses for engine roughness or power loss that could come from induction icing.
Neither manufacturer is wrong. They're different airplanes with different procedures, and your airplane's POH governs. The 172R and 172S (built since the mid-1990s and today's G1000 trainers) run a fuel-injected Lycoming IO-360-L2A with no carb heat knob at all, so even "a 172" doesn't settle it. This lesson applies to the carbureted N and P models that still fill a lot of rental lines.
Opening the aperture
For me, the bigger takeaway was opening up your aperture on systems and what they can do. And it's all about the proactive versus reactive mindset. Carb heat as anti-ice is proactive: you pull it before you close the throttle on a humid day. Carb heat as de-ice is reactive: the RPM is already dropping, and now you're fixing it. Same knob, different mindset.
Pilots need to be on the front side, "ahead of the jet." We've all been there: behind the jet, SA drained, and you get quiet. That's the perfect time to use CRM. Call it out, and come up with a plan to get back on the front side of the curve.
And to be clear, we aren't talking wing and control surface icing here. That's a separate topic altogether, but related. Airframe ice needs visible moisture at or below freezing. Having pitot heat or boots doesn't make an airplane approved for known icing.
I walked into that hangar thinking I had the obvious answer. Used correctly, that single lever in a 172 can be both de-ice and anti-ice, in the right context of course. And the mindset behind it is the same one that keeps you ahead of the jet.
References: FAA Pilot's Handbook of Aeronautical Knowledge, Ch. 7 (Carburetor Icing); FAA SAIB CE-09-35, Carburetor Icing Prevention.
A reply to my post on X from @AdamClampitt and @BowTiedCFI is why I spent a couple hours on a Saturday writing for the first time in years. Watching @MCCCANM, a retired KC-10 instructor and evaluator who's now an airline captain, teach on X reminded me of something: when you're away from instructing and evaluating, actually teaching, you realize how much you miss it.
CFIs: is that how you teach it? I'd like to hear how others make this connection.
The views expressed are my own and do not reflect the official policy or position of the U.S. Air Force, Department of Defense, or U.S. Government.