Fifteen outlets published 249 articles about Professor Jason Arday, but there appears to be a partial media blackout surrounding Dr Lola Salem, Michael Gove’s ex-girlfriend, who has been suspended from the University of Oxford after being charged with possessing indecent images of children.
Ghana is going through a fascist cleansing.
Similar to the US. Where “undesirables” are being kidnapped and displaced by the state for the crime of existing while poor
No African is illegal in Africa. That is fascist ideology!!!
May all police and military FALL down forever
Triggered by a far-right, anti-black race science network, the entire British media whipped up a state of national psychosis in which an extraordinarily talented, generous black academic - who excelled against many odds and challenges - was endlessly labelled a fraud, despite plausible reasons (documented in detail below and which ought to have been recognised by journalists doing their jobs responsibly) to believe he was just flawed.
The network that drove this campaign has for decades sought to mainstream its pseudoscientific fantasy that black people are inherently stupider than white people, due to genetics and heredity. Premised on that religious-level conviction, dressed-up in the language of science but actually at garbage levels of empirical rigour, this group has worked to mainstream the idea that higher education is structurally disadvantaged against white people by systematically recruiting underqualified ethnic minorities (who are believed to innately lack capacity) into university roles and jobs.
Like a mind-virus, this specious bullshit has beguiled the greatest minds of many of the most influential figures in politics and media - despite lacking empirical evidence, which consistently points in the opposite direction. (See, for instance, this study based on national data led by experts at Imperial College London and published by Wellcome Open Research: https://t.co/50hZq5xi81)
Jason Arday became the lightning rod of this campaign. It is clear that his autism and learning difficulties did lead to errors in his work. But a university inquiry had cleared him of plagiarism and identified that the citation errors found had been compounded by his disabilities at the time.
Notwithstanding this, his entire life story became fodder. Every apparent inflection in wording, every inconsistency in source testimony from decades back, every claim which journalists 'could not verify' became evidence of "fraud", "fabrication" "fabulism". It turns out that the efforts to verify were themselves weak and nonsensical, such as the headline claim that Arday lied about writing an academic book (detailed below in my article).
Fraud is hard to prove. Courts put the litmus test very high. Yet the press had made up its collective mind. And worst of all, the thing that really gets me, is that it is widely known in the literature that some autistic people can experience issues with how they recollect autobiographical details. It didn't occur to these responsible journalists bravely seeking the "truth" to consider that Arday's diagnosis might plausibly explain errors and inconsistencies (much of which are catalogued and investigated below). Instead, a working class man who had fought tooth and nail from the estate against challenges most of us would be floored by, was systematically defamed.
Yes, you cannot defame the dead by law. But there was a time when Arday was alive. And during that time, the vast bulk of the "journalism" published about Arday promulgated speculative falsehoods and failed to prove dishonesty. I'll repeat: they failed to prove dishonesty.
Yet in the minds of millions on this hell site, fraud and dishonesty is the only way they will remember Arday. They, and the trolls and bots below, lack the functional literacy to even bother reading through the thread carefully, let alone reading the whole article itself.
Something strange and alarming happened this summer at the tail end of the climate-induced heatwaves that set alight our forests and homes. We've seen before how societies can descend into bouts of madness. We follow the crowd, we take the meme as Word. The masthead has tremendous power. It sets the frame and tells us where the wind is blowing, and so we blow there.
These past weeks, the British media chased its own tail into a hyperreality of its own construction. At the heart of it was a concocted, baseless moral panic about a disabled black man in one of the country's most elite institutions. The black man was portrayed in fundamentally parasitical terms, against the backdrop of the unquestioned assumption that there are two many underqualified black people plaguing Britain's precious universities. His disabilities, and their symptoms which he had struggled against for his entire life and career, were weaponised against him.
I do not blame individual journalists as such for this. And I utterly condemn those hurling abuse at any journalists. I do not offer ready-made simple solutions. I do not believe in censorship or top-down press control.
But what just happened is bigger than that. This was an institutional failure, and a systematic collapse in basic journalistic standards - whipped up by a movement of anti-black racists who are operating in mainstream British institutions which regularly receive airtime and respectability. It was a cultural hurricane that resulted in death.
Retreating into self-defensive justifications is a natural psychological response. I understand. But simply saying - we were just doing our jobs - is quite a pathetic cop-out. It illustrates that our media institutions are unwilling and incapable of holding themselves to account in even the most mildest of ways.
A national public inquiry is urgently needed.
I watched the Jason Arday lecture Aaron Bastani repeatedly circulated to 1.4 million people as supposed proof that Arday was a “conman” – someone who, he said, could speak for more than 40 minutes while saying “nothing”.
That is an extraordinary characterisation of what is actually in the video, playing well to the racist gallery.
Arday’s delivery is undeniably repetitive. It is discursive, jargon-heavy and often far less concise than it could be. Some empirical claims are asserted rather than demonstrated.
One would be free to take issue with that.
But Bastani did not merely say: “I think this is a weak lecture.”
He said Arday was a “conman” and “literally a con artist”. And the lecture simply does not substantiate that allegation.
Arday quite obviously does say things.
His central argument is that racial inequalities in universities are reproduced not only through overt discrimination, but through what gets taught, who determines what counts as legitimate knowledge, who teaches it, and whether students from different backgrounds can meaningfully participate in academic life.
He argues that an “inclusive curriculum” cannot merely mean letting everyone through the door while leaving the substance and culture of the institution untouched.
He argues that overwhelmingly Eurocentric academic canons marginalise histories and intellectual traditions outside Europe.
He links curriculum, belonging and participation to racial awarding gaps.
He calls for students to participate in constructing curricula rather than simply completing module feedback forms.
He argues that unconscious-bias training is inadequate without deeper discussion about racism.
He criticises academic hierarchies which make it difficult for students to challenge lecturers.
And one of his strongest themes is that responsibility for combating institutional racism has disproportionately fallen on women of colour – including while men of colour have sometimes benefited from that labour – when it should instead be a collective responsibility.
You can reject every one of those arguments.
You can say the language is fashionable, the theoretical framework is wrong, the evidence is insufficient, the presentation is meandering, or the whole thing could have been said in a quarter of the time.
But you cannot seriously say he “says nothing”, unless you are deliberately attempting to perpetrator your own con - or are literally, yourself, utterly ignorant of the concepts he is discussing.
More importantly, the actual lecture is considerably more nuanced than the caricature subsequently constructed around Arday.
He explicitly distinguishes “whiteness” as a structure of power and privilege from white people themselves.
He acknowledges his own privilege “as a male or as a black male”.
He says everybody carries biases, including himself, and uses his own possible prejudice towards middle-class people – rooted in his working-class upbringing – as an example.
He argues for putting yourself in uncomfortable intellectual spaces.
He advocates difficult conversations rather than censorship.
He says students should be able to challenge academics.
This, of course, doesn't prove every argument Arday made was correct, or that he was a brilliant lecturer.
But where, precisely, is the "con"?
Calling someone a con artist is not an academic judgement. It is an allegation about their honesty.
A rambling keynote making arguments you disagree with is not evidence of a con, and never was. There is a vast evidential gulf between:
“I think this lecture is bad.”
and
“This man is literally a con artist.”
Repeatedly telling hundreds of thousands of people to “Watch it!” does not bridge that gulf.
Bastani did not make this accusation once in passing. He repeatedly jumped onto the Arday story and returned to the “conman” allegation, helping turn a contested argument about one academic’s work and career into an attack on his basic honesty and legitimacy.
Only after Arday’s death has Bastani now acknowledged that he should not have called him a conman – while accompanying that concession with a lengthy boring self-assuaging justification of why he regarded the wider story as newsworthy.
But saying afterwards that the word should not have been used does not erase what happened .
Bastani had no evidence in this lecture that Arday was a con artist. What he had was his own racist contempt for Arday’s performance. He transformed that subjective judgement into a sweeping allegation of personal fraud, repeatedly broadcast it to a huge audience, and encouraged others to treat watching the video as though it somehow proved the charge.
This was an evidential sleight of hand which helped egg on a much wider public pile-on against a man already being witch-hunted across the media as a fraud.
Who was the "con man", really?
Imagine being able to kill a man - for profit - and then casually report on his killing - also for profit - as if it had nothing whatsoever to do with you.
The line between journalism and white supremacy has been blurred. In some papers that line no longer exists.
You had remarkably little difficulty pronouncing on Jason Arday while he was alive.
Then he dies and suddenly we discover that emotions run high, facts may be unclear, premature judgement is unwise and everybody should spend some time reflecting.
Where was this exquisite epistemic modesty last week?
Were emotions conveniently absent while you were publicly dissecting his intelligence, competence and integrity?
Was everything you wrote then produced in some hermetically sealed chamber of pure reason?
And why exactly is now the moment for silence?
You had plenty to say when there remained a living human being at the other end of it, capable of reading every sneer, every column and every delighted assessment of his humiliation.
Now you know with absolute certainty that he will never read another word you write about him, apparently the fun has gone out of pronouncing.
That is the part I would reflect on.
Because “nothing is clear when emotion runs so high” sounds considerably less like wisdom when it arrives after the target of all that certainty is dead.
The Jason Arday circus has reached the bit where someone turns the lights on and the pigs suddenly realise there are mirrors around the trough.
Two days ago the story was “delicious.” Every allegation was another course. Every humiliation was content. Everyone was licking gravy off their fucking fingers.
Then Arday died.
Now there’s this hideous little pause while half the people who were feasting on him discover that carrying on would make them look exactly as ghoulish as they were behaving.
So suddenly it’s Cambridge’s fault. DEI’s fault. His defenders’ fault. The “race ideologues” used him. Somebody else should have stopped it.
Anything except:
“Fuck. We were enjoying this.”
His death has robbed them of their entertainment and left them standing around the trough with dinner all over their faces, furiously insisting somebody else cooked it.
I was sued by a white french academic who plagiarised me. For 3 years she used racist slander against me. She was protected and promoted by some of the most prominent french medias, political foundations and parties who refused to talk of the affair. She lost. She still teach.
Jools documents how Professor Jason Arday was legitimately cleared of plagiarism with the main issue being poor referencing and The Spectator’s Lara Brown’s biased and anti DEI reporting on this.
#RipJasonArday
As much as I would love to say "forgive them for they know not what they do", they knew exactly what they were doing, for we told them. Repeatedly. In text and audio. On air and off air.
Below was from 03/08.
Looks like Tony Blair is very determined to confirm his status as one of the worst persons alive.
His speech is pure 19th century colonialism: he frames the Gaza issue as one of "ineffective governance" on the part of the Palestinians, without as much as mentioning the 17-year blockade, the occupation, or the small matter of the deadliest assault on a civilian population this century.
I'd love to understand how you build "effective institutions" when:
- Your airport was destroyed by Israel in 2001
- Your seaport is blockaded
- Building materials are banned as "dual use"
- Your university gets bombed every few years
- Your civil servants can't travel for training
- Your economy is strangled by design
- Your people and government officials are routinely killed in devastating attacks
And he uses this, the eminently predictable outcome of this continuous strangling of a people, as evidence that they can't govern themselves and that they require outside management by the architects of their immiseration.
Absolutely repugnant, no other word for it.