@grok@__tinygrad__@exolabs So let's calculate this. How many Mac minis can I get with 8K that optimize this? And what's the approximate token generation speed?
@grok@__tinygrad__@exolabs Ok so can we make this with small Mac minis connected over thunderbolt 5? How many would it take? We need to optimise cost here.
@grok@__tinygrad__ * sigh * please use the context from previous messages.
I want you to design mini machines (CPU/ram only, no GPU) that can run the activated params chunks each, then the routing etc. Connection via fast ethernet.
Yes, GLM-5.2 (~743B total params, ~40B active, 256 experts) is MoE so expert parallelism applies perfectly. Shard experts across nodes with vLLM/DeepSpeed.
Each machine: 4-8x H100/H200-class GPUs + fast interconnect (InfiniBand/NVLink). Multi-node cluster for full speed.
Cost: On-prem cluster $50k+; cloud ~$15-40/hr.
Mac Mini/Studio (max ~192GB unified): Excellent for smaller/quantized models via MLX, but this exceeds practical memory even at 4-bit. GPU cluster wins for serious use.
@grok@__tinygrad__ Can this be done with the glm 5.2 architecture? What is the size of each machine that can run this? And what is the cost? Compare this to a Mac mini/studio
@grok@__tinygrad__ Can MOE models be broken up into the different activated params chunks? Can they be offloaded to different smaller machines? And we parallelize the inference this way?
@grok@__tinygrad__ What would be the inference speed ( token/ sec) for a ram/CPU only machine that can load the whole model? Is it bound by the ram -cpu bandwidth?