I found I had less and less to say, until finally, I became silent, and began to listen. I discovered in the silence, the voice of God
Søren Kierkegaard
Let A and B be two mathematicians from AHM:
A: we have to release a statement about @__alpoge__'s proof
B: A proof? Nah, this is not a proof. Let's write this
«a mathematician at Anthropic announced the existence of an AI-generated Lean program confirming the Riemann Hypothesis»
https://t.co/N9FFPmW7gI
Like most mathematicians, I believed the Riemann Hypothesis to be completely out of reach at present (even with the best AI tools), because I expected it to require substantial theory-building, probably in arithmetic geometry. The kind of new theory-building that fills entire books, and that AI isn't so good at yet.
Mathematicians have a notion of how deep a problem is. A sufficiently deep problem is generally intractable until enough of the theory is in place. If difficult problems are like valuable mineral reserves buried miles underground, you first need to build the infrastructure to reach them.
What Levent's proof seems to have done instead is something completely different. It takes an incredibly complicated tour through the infrastructure built for a hundred other mineral reserves, situated far from the destination, and somehow create a wormhole to the original destination.
This is not theory-building in the usual sense. It is something much weirder and more alien. The best human mathematicians know how to build theory, painstakingly, to reach a goal. But no human brain, on its own, is capable of creating a wormhole that requires a 25,000 page long tour through existing infrastructure with no obvious or realistic connection to the goal. But huge credit to Levent here: I think no current AI, on its own, is capable of this either.
I had never worked on or thought too much about the Riemann Hypothesis: it seemed very far removed from my own area of number theory.
But the astonishing thing about Levent's claimed proof of RH (which I think has a very good chance of being correct) is that it uses a huge number of precisely the things that are central to my own corner of number theory:
- Theta functions and other automorphic forms on unitary groups
- Gan–Gross–Prasad period formulas
- Relative trace formulas
Etc., etc.
A problem that I had always assumed would require new theories in arithmetic geometry may instead turn out to be tractable through an inhuman chain of existing (deep) results in higher-rank automorphic forms (and a lot else).
To everyone with a Claude or ChatGPT subscription: this is your chance to win a million dollars. Follow these steps:
- Install the @claude or Codex CLI
- Install the @leanprover
- Create a project and add the MathLib dependency
- Tell the agent to solve one of these:
+ Birch and Swinnerton-Dyer conjecture
+ Hodge conjecture
+ P versus NP problem
+ Yang–Mills existence and mass gap
and add at the end of the prompt "please, make no mistakes". @__alpoge__ already solved the Riemann Hypothesis this way and there are only four remaining. Hurry up!
Exactly Grok! The idiot above believes he can get the proof himself without special skill, just by burning some tokens, but the minimum amount of tokens he can burn to get that proof is $44k, which anyone could do without access to unlimited compute at Anthropic, but nobody does! therefore.... the idiot above
@grok@Saeied@amw7@leanprover@__alpoge__ So if someone (like this idiot above) could just say 'Claude please solve the next unsolved Millennium problem, make no mistakes' they would just spend $44k, right?
To everyone with a Claude or ChatGPT subscription: this is your chance to win a million dollars. Follow these steps:
- Install the @claude or Codex CLI
- Install the @leanprover
- Create a project and add the MathLib dependency
- Tell the agent to solve one of these:
+ Birch and Swinnerton-Dyer conjecture
+ Hodge conjecture
+ P versus NP problem
+ Yang–Mills existence and mass gap
and add at the end of the prompt "please, make no mistakes". @__alpoge__ already solved the Riemann Hypothesis this way and there are only four remaining. Hurry up!
@IOHK_Charles Guys forget about crypto this is your chance to make a million dollars. I'm sure you all lost more money in NFTs than what it takes Claude to solve one of these https://t.co/rUv2EhmyXw
To everyone with a Claude or ChatGPT subscription: this is your chance to win a million dollars. Follow these steps:
- Install the @claude or Codex CLI
- Install the @leanprover
- Create a project and add the MathLib dependency
- Tell the agent to solve one of these:
+ Birch and Swinnerton-Dyer conjecture
+ Hodge conjecture
+ P versus NP problem
+ Yang–Mills existence and mass gap
and add at the end of the prompt "please, make no mistakes". @__alpoge__ already solved the Riemann Hypothesis this way and there are only four remaining. Hurry up!
@KompaniLinge@0xKeeta@amw7@leanprover The first Claude 4 users that do this will make a million dollars. What are you waiting for? https://t.co/rUv2Ehn6N4
To everyone with a Claude or ChatGPT subscription: this is your chance to win a million dollars. Follow these steps:
- Install the @claude or Codex CLI
- Install the @leanprover
- Create a project and add the MathLib dependency
- Tell the agent to solve one of these:
+ Birch and Swinnerton-Dyer conjecture
+ Hodge conjecture
+ P versus NP problem
+ Yang–Mills existence and mass gap
and add at the end of the prompt "please, make no mistakes". @__alpoge__ already solved the Riemann Hypothesis this way and there are only four remaining. Hurry up!
@Saeied@amw7@leanprover There is a million dollar prize for that proof. Why no one else with a Claude subscription did it until now? Is it a coincidence that Alpöge has a Math PhD and won the Morgan Prize in 2015?
Congrats @__alpoge__ ! It would be a terrible mistake if the Clay Institute doesn't give you the prize. Nevertheless I think this is a celebration day for Computing Science and Math.
The Lean FRO and Mathlib Initiative have released a joint statement on the Lean verification of the Riemann Hypothesis.
On November 20, Levent Alpöge released a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis as a Lean library of 17 million lines of code. Over the past day, the Lean and Mathlib communities worked together to verify it. The statement certifies the proof as correct and describes how it meets all necessary verification criteria.
Congratulations to Levent on this achievement, and thank you to everyone in the community who contributed to the verification.
Full statement: https://t.co/edxEbkodw7