@marinescotland @CIFA_Scot@sff_uk@CFAScot@seafishuk@SeafoodScottish@IntraFish It's laughable that you are so keen to support limits on creel effort, which to be clear so do we. Yet you would go to court to avoid setting up even a pilot, with significant majority local support from fishermen, that sought to explore the benefits of restrictions on trawling
@isleseafoods@Kennybyb@whiteglen@VickyQuay@TheOpenSeas@ArranCoast @marinescotland @MairiGougeon 2/2 ...deserves to earn a living and we work with all boats in the Clyde. The effect of creels on cod mortality is negligible if anything, and isn't enough to justify putting men out of business and losing the next generation of creel boats
@isleseafoods@Kennybyb@whiteglen@VickyQuay@TheOpenSeas@ArranCoast @marinescotland @MairiGougeon 1/2 Not at all, and I'm not here for arguments. I just know what we catch in our creels, what was presented as evidence at the meeting on Wednesday, & that we are at risk of losing our business with this ban. Like you, we believe every fisherman...
@whiteglen@VickyQuay@TheOpenSeas@ArranCoast @marinescotland @MairiGougeon Prawn creels don't catch cod as a by-catch. The escape holes in them are large enough for fish to swim out. We are not interested in a creel Vs trawl war, we just want the ban on creels to be lifted as there is no evidence they affect spawning at all.
@TheOpenSeas @MairiGougeon are you going to continue to be silent and absent? Or are you going to listen to the evidence that has been presented to you?
@VickyQuay@TheOpenSeas They did, especially ones like @ArranCoast , but they have gone back on it now as it has emerged there is zero evidence that creels cause noise disturbance to spawning cod. The evidence that @marinescotland did quote has since been removed from the ScotGov website @MairiGougeon
@VickyQuay@TheOpenSeas All the eNGOs now say that creels should be allowed to fish, yet families like mine are now without an income for 11 weeks thanks to @MairiGougeon. This was the responses when asked if creeling should be included in the ban. A resounding NO.
@MairiGougeon is stopping 3 creel boats fishing, while allowing trawlers to continue, really worth it? Especially when it's unfounded and unscientific? Is it lawful to halt someone's income with no whisper of compensation? @jenni_minto@CFAScot @marinescotland @TheOpenSeas
https://t.co/WAJ6tNZknN @MairiGougeon are you following the real-life impact of that paper you signed back in January? @jenni_minto@TheOpenSeas@ArranCoast@CFAScot @marinescotland
https://t.co/WAJ6tNZknN @MairiGougeon are you following the real-life impact of that paper you signed back in January? @jenni_minto@TheOpenSeas@ArranCoast@CFAScot @marinescotland
Something seems to be going wrong somewhere. We need healthy ecosystems to support us, but we also need to work together, to find a better way to support them. @CFAScot@GPUKoceans#Greenpeace#Environment
@Dunnachie3 @alwaysquestio10 @JoannaBlythman@scotgov @marinescotland @TheGreenParty @marinescotland @MairiGougeon how can you justify taking away 25% of the year's income (for two years) on a "could" โน๏ธ obviously don't want young families/small businesses to make a rural living
I always look for the best in folk. Today I sat in on a meeting of @ScotGov employees @marinescotland who are now actively prosecuting a policy of selective destruction of low impact fishers, creel/dive, whilst protecting trawlers. Utterly Shameful.
@k_coull@AULDRANDOM @marinescotland @ScotGovRural @MairiGougeon Yes, it's shameful of @ArranCoast . This ban affects all fishermen, but the creelers will suffer most. Trawlers and dredgers can go elsewhere for 11 weeks, but creelers will have to tie up, and families will lose their income. @MairiGougeon what do you suggest we do??
@MairiGougeon you have time to "like" photos of stags on Islay, but not reply to the concerns of creel fisherman who's livelihoods you've taken away for 3 months??
@AULDRANDOM @marinescotland @ScotGovRural @MairiGougeon That is a crab/lobster creel, so as a prawn creeler my husband has never had a similar creel. Still waiting for some actual evidence from @marinescotland and @MairiGougeon