@DillerMug@DivinelyDesined "Profound misunderstanding" is funny. My whole life I've only experienced the natural realm. I live in New York City. Is there anything you can recommend that I should do or watch out for so I can experience directly this alleged super-natural realm? Sounds exciting and fun!
@DillerMug@DivinelyDesined You can easily answer your own question. Similarly, evidence for Superman and his home planet of Krypton can't be submitted for discussion because there's no evidence that Superman or Krypton exists. That's enough silliness for today. Go read Coyne's Preface and get back to me.
@DillerMug@DivinelyDesined Naturalism is the only viable paradigm, as there is zero evidence for the existence of a "creator" or a "designer" or of a super-natural realm (my hyphen for emphasis). ID challenges nothing. Go read the short Preface to Jerry Coyne's "Why Evolution is True" to understand more.
@DillerMug@DivinelyDesined Re "exclusion," scientists in whatever field—cosmology, biology, whatever—are always open to understanding how some idea or hypothesis is wrong. Any scientist would be eager to embrace new evidence that shows a certain disease has a different cause—or that life doesn't evolve.
@DillerMug@DivinelyDesined Consensus can easily be used within science. However, a scientific consensus doesn't always mean that a matter is settled (though some matters *are* settled). New info can come along, but there is a consensus that, for example, certain microbes can cause certain diseases.
@DillerMug@DivinelyDesined I don't understand your issue w/ the word "consensus." There's a consensus among geologists that the planet isn't flat (b/c there's evidence to support that it's a sphere). There's a consensus among microbiologists that certain germs cause disease b/c facts support the consensus.
@DillerMug@DivinelyDesined I've no idea what Nagel is trying to say here. Feel free to treat me like a five-year-old and explain what he's saying. Nagel, by the way, accepts the general scientific facts that underpin evolution. It looks like he has some questions, but he's not a creationist nor an ID guy.
@DillerMug@DivinelyDesined There was a time in Earth's history when rabbits didn't exist. Now they do. Are you maintaining or suggesting that rabbits just...popped into existence one day? If you insist that life doesn't evolve, then you're implicitly supporting the "popped into existence" view. Yes?
@DillerMug@DivinelyDesined I remain fascinated by believers who persist in their belief that life doesn't evolve when all the life sciences exist precisely b/c life does evolve. To be clear, THAT u think life doesn't evolve is a given. But why do u WANT evolution to not be true? What's driving that "want"?
@DillerMug@DivinelyDesined What "logical inconsistency"? Be as specific as you can with your answer. Better yet, why not cite something said by an evolutionary biologist and then explain in detail the supposed inherent logical inconsistency? If you don't want to use the example below, use something else.
@DillerMug@DivinelyDesined Yes(about the scientific method). Re evolution, observations, hypotheses, and experiments have led to the irrefutable conclusion that life evolves. Funny, it's one thing for religious people to say evolution isn't true, but I'm amused by their desire for evolution to not be true.