@AhlAlFikr@realAlyasa I'd never reject a verse even if it doesn't sit right with me, cause I fully trust the word of God and its preservation. And alhamdulillah all verses make sense to me cause I repeatedly ask for guidance while reading Qur'an. Alhamdulillah. Allahu Akbar.
@AhlAlFikr@realAlyasa You're upholding hadiths from a place of privilege. Just how men benefit from patriarchy, they benefit from hadith. Imagine being a women and seeing yourself as awrah, urdu derives word for "woman" from the word in Arabic used for intimate parts. 💔 We are HUMANS FGS!
@AhlAlFikr@realAlyasa Arab culture is not universal. Islam is universal. For the whole ummah. Women always covered their heads, it was the cultural norm. It does not make hair sexual. Men sexualized every aspect of women. Hadith calls whole of a women "awrah."
@AhlAlFikr@realAlyasa Calling it "the science of hadith" won't hide the fact that it's literally a case of Chinese Whisper. I read hadiths too to understand the context of the verse but never to add extra rulings to it.
@AhlAlFikr@realAlyasa Hadiths discourage resistance against oppressive rulers, undermine women's political authority, and justify child marriage. These aren't harmless academic disagreements. They have real consequences for people's lives, rights, dignity and freedom.
@AhlAlFikr@realAlyasa Not "ungrateful to Allah, but ungrateful to husbands." Tell me this doesn't seem like it was written by a man just to control wives. Allah constantly tells humans to be grateful to him in Qur’an. Hadiths tell women to be grateful to Husbands. Hadiths constantly favor men.
@AhlAlFikr@realAlyasa You cant interact with prophet in the same way his contemporaries did. Allah is Al-Hayy the Ever-Living. His revelation remains with us. The Quran is preserved, accessible and repeatedly identifies itself as guidance. >
@AhlAlFikr@realAlyasa People who lived alongside him could directly hear him, ask him questions, receive his instructions and follow his decisions in real-life situations. That is fundamentally different from claiming that people today must obey collections of narrations compiled generations after him
“taj mahal this, taj mahal that, shah jahan loved mumtaz xyz” 14 pregnancies in 19 years, dragged across war zones and mountain passes while heavily pregnant, until her body literally gave out at 38. never call it “love” again