🚨 YOUTUBE IS DEMONETIZING AN ENTIRE COMMUNITY OF ANIMATORS. AND NOBODY IS TALKING ABOUT IT.
This is bigger than one channel. Bigger than one appeal. An alarming number of animation creators are losing their YouTube monetization under the same "Misleading Family Content" policy.
My channel, Pivot Master, has been demonetized for almost 3 MONTHS. And I'm far from the only one.
Here are just some of the affected creators:
Pivot Master - https://t.co/yEGAR99jhi
Ugee - https://t.co/Fx6Njp9IU9
EGM - https://t.co/oyZaVykXHZ
FLORZY - https://t.co/jCwlY13Wm4
ADMYT Animations - https://t.co/V1lLr6hKg0
Kalopi Animators - https://t.co/VlQTaWFqxD
PPANIMAN - https://t.co/wqDShOjQa6
Mega Trex - https://t.co/TbfTtMtyn0
Hardy Maximus - https://t.co/sA3WhgGetA
Raptor Silver - https://t.co/EWfjjHPq1O
PaleoPixels - https://t.co/nCvF4i37Qa
Primitive Domain - https://t.co/YKFoFLmY7T
Tyrex - https://t.co/3aSKfvpvZG
LUNATIK! - https://t.co/Wf4S0uUFKx
Jamez Escaranio - https://t.co/4dVys7HU8L
Zelcurt - https://t.co/imVUSt1RKv
JimboCC - https://t.co/rLW9tN90ld
MAKATOONY - https://t.co/FkS0S0TcAY
VAL Animation - https://t.co/4F2YrDFROt
KAIJUX 3D - https://t.co/EaaDEe93A3
Vrahno - https://t.co/B95C1JfnwI
Basilosaurus Channels - https://t.co/H6lfYNeZtC
Kasch Productions - https://t.co/SqZ557e1W4
Vanimation Films - https://t.co/IDMy2qqSI9
GigaAnimams1 - https://t.co/vPrc9s9Eol
Zaïloth - https://t.co/DVDs4vIa7I
Seal Animation - https://t.co/amKzTbeQ0H
Jack Rex - https://t.co/esCCfbj6nq
Spishi - https://t.co/H1Po1y2VW9
More than 29 creators, probably way more that I am not aware of. Countless hours of animation. Years of hard work. And livelihoods being affected.
Animation does NOT automatically mean children's content.
Many of us create content for general audiences, yet our channels are being classified under a policy that we believe does not accurately reflect our work.
And what happens when we appeal?
Automated responses. Rejections. Copy-paste explanations. And creators left fighting to prove that their own content has been misunderstood.
We're want TRANSPARENCY, ACCOUNTABILITY, AND GENUINE HUMAN REVIEWS.
@TeamYouTube@YouTube, please stop treating these as isolated cases.
LOOK AT THE BIGGER PICTURE.
We want our channels reviewed fairly. We want clear explanations. And if these demonetizations are mistakes, we want our monetization restored.
To every animator affected: PLEASE SPEAK UP.
Repost and Quote this tweet. Tag @TeamYouTube. Share your experience in the replies.
Let's make sure this issue cannot be ignored any longer.
OUR CHANNELS ARE OUR YEARS OF HARD WORK. THEY DESERVE A FAIR CHANCE.
Because of YouTube AI's continuous attacks on my channel, I have not been able to do what I love for the past year.
There were so many animations and projects I wanted to work on. But instead of doing that, half of my day consisted of coming up with new ways to reach YouTube support.
Godzilla minus zero just came out right now. I really want to make an animation about that movie. It is an amazing opportunity for my channel and on top of that, I get to work on a project that I love and am passionate about.
But NO. @TeamYouTube insists that my channel is simply made for kids. Simply because it is animation.
What's worse, is that they don't care enough to acknowledge their mistake. There are SO MANY affected that it is impossible that they are unaware of their situation. Unfortunately it seems like they just don't care.
I miss my life from three weeks ago when I could just focus on making the same videos that people liked, I could have fun chats with my friends over fandom stuff, hobbies, collecting, anticipating movies and sharing thoughtful comments on other matters going on in our lives.
I miss my life from three weeks ago when I could just focus on making the same videos that people liked, I could have fun chats with my friends over fandom stuff, hobbies, collecting, anticipating movies and sharing thoughtful comments on other matters going on in our lives.
@TeamYouTube@YouTubeCreators I'll try this again, there have been many creators and animators that were demonetized or terminated by YOUR faulty moderation.
They have not violated any policies and are being actively ignored and pushed aside. I'll put a list below in the replies, please give them a fair HUMAN review, and reinstate them:
Kalopi is a talented animator who makes animations that are clearly not meant for kids.
@TeamYouTube He has not violated any YouTube Policy. Take a manual look into his channel!!
I'm still waiting for the 90 days of demonetization to end; I'll have to wait until December 13th to get monetization back, but I can't wait! I have bills to pay. @TeamYouTube Me and the other creators need monetization!
I'm still waiting for the 90 days of demonetization to end; I'll have to wait until December 13th to get monetization back, but I can't wait! I have bills to pay. @TeamYouTube Me and the other creators need monetization!
- My theory behind this massive wave of innocent creators getting TERMINATED and DEMONETIZED is that YouTube is cleaning house and making room ahead of the major update expected in February 2027. I honestly have no other explanation for why so many creators are being wiped off the platform, including my friend, whose termination dragged me down with him because of YouTube's ridiculous "Circumvention" policy.
- Here are a few things that make me question what's really going on:
- YouTube has said it wants to PAY CREATORS MORE in 2027, yet at the same time, the requirements to enter the YPP have reportedly been raised to 8,000 watch hours for long-form content and 20 MILLION engaged Shorts views.
- It seems like they want to keep only the strongest creators on the platform, but I genuinely believe MANY of us are producing quality content and deserve to be here just as much as anyone else.
- Their enforcement policies make absolutely no sense when you look at what's happening. Spam, scams, impersonation, circumvention, sex and nudity... I'm seeing countless channels terminated under these categories, even though, from what I can see, they haven't violated any of them.
- I have no idea how or why so many channels are being flagged, but one thing is clear: AN AI-DRIVEN SYSTEM THAT MAKES THESE KINDS OF MISTAKES NEEDS SERIOUS CHANGES.
- I genuinely don't know what else to say. Over 800 posts on X, countless emails, nothing but generic bot responses, and absolutely ZERO empathy for the people affected.
- I believe far too many of these cases are the result of mistakes in YouTube's own system. The way they're treating the very people who have worked so hard to build something on their platform is incredibly disrespectful and ungrateful.
- YOUTUBE'S SYSTEM NEEDS AN URGENT OVERHAUL. CREATORS DESERVE REAL HUMAN REVIEWS, FAIR DECISIONS, AND ACTUAL SUPPORT.
@TeamYouTube@YouTube@YouTubeCreators@nealmohan
On 11/1, YouTube terminated all 7 of my channels, wiping out 4 years of work. I've created a voluntary list of affected creators to organize, share evidence, and explore collective legal action. I'm fighting for more than just my channels. We deserve accountability.
@YouTube@YouTubeCreators@TeamYouTube I joined group chats with other unfairly demonetized creators who report the same mistreatment I have experienced. You ignore their messages no matter how many times they contact you. Meanwhile you profit off our work, withhold our revenue.
@YouTube@YouTubeCreators@TeamYouTube This is ridiculous and just straight up evil at this point. Ain’t even a single one of y’all give a damn about these folks. We’ve been fine for years on YouTube. No problems. This Ai moderation bullshit is screwin us. Cmon damn it.
Imagine making this kind of money thanks to creators, only to treat those same creators like absolute garbage. You terminate and demonetize innocent people who are simply trying to make a living through their creativity. And after taking away their channels and income, you don't even make the slightest effort to restore them or give each case a fair, thorough review. Instead, you leave it all to bots that handle these cases in exactly the WRONG way. @TeamYouTube@YouTube@YouTubeCreators@nealmohan
This is the last time I try reaching out to YouTube support!!!
I made an extremely detailed and thorough email explaining everything, included screenshots, proof of work and literally everything.
Once again I get some automated BS.
What's worse is that it took them a week to respond.
A whole week, and they are telling me "if this is your first YPP application rejection."
WHAT DO YOU MEAN "IF"
Bro they don't even bother checking my demonetization status.
This support system is disgusting. It is ruining so many lives.
I have been on the fence about proceeding with this in a legal manner. I have been talking to a lawyer, but wanted to settle this without them. Now I know there is literally nothing I can do and will be proceeding legally from this point onward.
Thank you to @AwestruckVox for making a video covering YouTube's unfair treatment of their animators!
He also covers other AI vs Animation stuff. Check out his video:
https://t.co/5gKoY3D6xA
@TeamYouTube@YouTubeCreators
Please take a look at this video’s comment section.
https://t.co/TOeH6brqcs
It shows that I’m not the only one who believes this decision was wrong, and that my content is NOT REPETITIVE.
I need an actual human reviewer to check my channel again.
🚨 YOUTUBE, Stop treating Creators like they don't matter !
@nealmohan@YouTube@TeamYouTube
Creators, was your channel terminated or demonetized without any prior warning, and you disagree with the decision? Like & repost so YouTube sees this. We want our channels back !!
@_m3galophobia_ If you want to target and bully anyone, use that energy and emotion to demand help for me and other creators from @YouTube, @YouTubeCreators and @TeamYouTube instead. They have unjustly demonetized our channels, withheld our paychecks and are continuing to profit off our videos.
You let an AI mass ban a bunch of channels the didn’t do anything wrong.
The AI instantly rejects appeals and creators have to shout on Twitter or make videos documenting how the current system has screwed them over to get help.
YouTube does not truly care for their creators.
24 days trying to get her channel back, she says..
She says a friend once logged in on her device. His account was later terminated, then hers got hit for circumvention.
Sharing a device isn't proof of sharing ownership. YouTube needs to show the CONNECTION.