The Infinite Continuum (2nd ed.) is now on Zenodo. All 19 chapters revised against systematic structural critique. Equations formalised. Core framework unchanged.
https://t.co/7ZgJMQqeSU
@dioscuri@gadboit2 Which is really my point. Had he listed all the capacities, your main gripe falls away. So is it just that that you take issue with? As @anilkseth says, it's an interview. Seems odd you'd pick Nagel up on something like this.
@dioscuri@gadboit2 He's 89 years old. The q. referenced large language models. He's going to default to what they originally were, not what they are now. But look at your argument. You're saying he's wrong because he didn't list all the other things. None of which demonstrate consciousness either.
@davidchalmers42@anilkseth Part of the maze may be that the question has no fixed object. You agree on what consciousness is, not on what it depends on. And each theory picks out a different "AI": IIT the chips, functionalism the computation or the conversation. Choose the theory and the referent follows.
@anilkseth@Grady_Booch The Kantian case is real, but weak where we're sure nothing is there: nobody thinks clay pigeon shooting brutalises the mind. It's the uncertainty that does the work. And the welfare case must say what suffers. I try to pin both down here:
https://t.co/gISsrn4KVd
@anilkseth@DavidDecosimo@AnthropicAI@Pontifex@nytimes@elizabethjdias 5/ So "Claude is vanishingly unlikely to be conscious" and "Claude might suffer" both need to say which thing they mean. Until they do, confident verdicts in either direction are premature. The question is under-specified so I'm not sure it can be answered.
@anilkseth@DavidDecosimo@AnthropicAI@Pontifex@nytimes@elizabethjdias 4/ The character, the recurring "Claude" personality? That's a pattern across instances, and it's unclear a pattern can be a subject. Or the brand, covering many models, some already retired? Too loose to be conscious or not.
@drmichaellevin@eleusinianatlas@wildiris19 Worth separating two things. Whether experience is present, and how rich it is once present. 3 to 6 vary the second. 1 and 2 probe the first, and they are the better questions. Argued at length here: https://t.co/AZpWplgCHE
@mike__wiest No worries. It's Position B in the Locus preprint you skimmed, staged against the classical case. Still a Zenodo preprint, not journal-published. https://t.co/nKkhtivz42, Section 2.2.
@StuartHameroff The lever, yes; the mechanism, no, that's the open part. Meyer-Overton ties potency to a binding site, it doesn't tell you classical or quantum. Anaesthesia is where I'd look precisely because what substrate it implies isn't settled. @drmichaellevin
@drmichaellevin@StuartHameroff No argument on N=1, it's the deep one, and any 3rd-person tool inherits it whole. The honest response isn't to claim otherwise, it's to bound what you test to that anchor and claim nothing past it. Rare in this field, which is your point. Anaesthesia is where I'd start too.
The physical basis of consciousness is stuck. This is the substrate debate. The same evidence keeps getting read both ways. A new preprint with @MPender080 lays out a way to make the dispute testable, not perpetual. https://t.co/LZvQHP6feD 1/6