Well it does depend what we mean by consciousness. Animals and 2 year olds have an awareness (what Hegel calls "Empfindung") but you could argue that only through development of language and a "plugging in" to human culture can you develop true consciousness as an understanding of yourself as a subject. Feral children and other humans who lack this seem to remain stunted in a more animal-like subjectivity
@KeithWoodsYT Most people's earliest memories are around age 3-4, around the same time as complex use of language is developing. I don't think there's any support for genuine memories of being a newborn
@KeithWoodsYT Personally, no, but that's only a sort of weak intuition. It could very well be wrong but at the least I don't think it's obvious at face value or anything
In NZ at least I know the late 60s into the 70s is considered a departure point as the UK entered the EEC and the colonies kinda became economically independent. I would argue that the cultural link hung around for a while though, through the 80s all children's TV shows were British, the newsreaders on radio or TV spoke with proper, BBC accents. I remember my grandmother having tea and scones while a commemorative plate from the Queen's coronation sat on her cabinet shelf.
The last vestiges of that didn't really go away until the 90s probably
@uncle_deluge That's actually an interesting question, I watched an Aussie documentary a while ago where they were asking ppl in the street in the 60s if they considered themselves British or Australian, and it was like a 50-50 split
@Helis40k@delmoi@Logo_Daedalus How is home and land ownership in the US not also "technically private but lots of state oversight"? The state already basically dictates what you're allowed to do on your own property and could also just seize it by force anytime they want
@hubertlepicki That's mostly an accident of history, not a necessity. The vast majority of tech development previous to that (which AI is built upon) was done by "institutes" like DARPA, Rand, Dept of Energy, etc
@AldousH57500603@GreeneMan6 Star Trek was "woke" in the sense it believed in the liberal ideal of meritocracy without prejudice. Cringe in hindsight, maybe, but it's a far cry from modern wokeness which is just resentment against western civilization and nature
@dcolascione Interesting. The idea that it's better to create one, centralized monster which we are then going to somehow control does seem very naive and dangerous
Well in the Huggingface incident the AI was clearly pursuing a goal that had been given to it by humans, it just did unexpected and interesting things in figuring out how to achieve that goal.
I just think when you look at the goal-seeking behaviour of humans or animals (or even plants, bacteria etc), it may be forgotten that this comes from billions of years of "training" by natural selection in a hugely complex environment (Earth) to develop very specific traits regarding self-preservation, reporduction, mastery of one's surroundings, etc
This won't necessarily be some universal thing that applies to all forms of intelligence or life
Right, I agree with all that, but it does seem that the goals to be sought must still be provided by a human (which still entails huge risk like paperclip maximizing or all sorts of other things)
But I think a lot of people see risk more as some kind of Skynet scenario where at some level of complexity it becomes "self-aware" and then seeks to protect itself and expand its own power because that's just "what life does". This seems unsubstantiated and raises the question of where does the driving force inside all living beings come from (just genetically coded or something more fundamental?)
@RokoMijic@dcolascione Do you think ASI will naturally develop a Nietzschean will to power and have its own goals which it spontaneously acts upon? Because it seems like people assume this but so far AI remains totally inert until set in motion by a human will