@Ot15Mr@bruce_straughan The rule is stupid doesn't matter. It's the rule. Therefore you have to have a master level of cognitive dissonance to say it's still a catch.
@SoullessSaint@bruce_straughan What? ๐๐๐ In that case no defender can ever knock the ball out. As long as it touches the revivers hands might as well award a catch.
@tjkcards@bruce_straughan If this exact thing happened in the middle of the field and they ruled fumble they would absolutely be crying that it's actually incomplete.
@LifetimeIP@bruce_straughan You very clearly didn't understand what he is saying. 75% is his personal preference. You can slow something down 100x and nitpick every fine detail and spend hours reviewing a play to try and decipher it. That's not how real time works. That's his point.
@QuiteFrankly133@BotsForEveryone@TaylorTwellman I'm a Notre Dame football fan, which you'd clearly see in my timeline over the years. So, if Notre Dame is irrelevant than what is Miami?
Get out of your feels buddy.
That's the question. Historically, it's been multiple steps with the intent to keep progressing. On the sidelines like this, you have to survive the entire play. On his third step the ball gets knocked out and on top of that he didn't have 100% control to begin with. If he hangs on it's a catch but there is a reason the immediate reaction by everyone was incomplete
@QuiteFrankly133@BotsForEveryone@TaylorTwellman Clearly said OR in that sentence. Then again, based off of what I see on your timeline, understanding things is difficult for you.
How salty are you bud?
@ZachSaraceni@passfirstmafia@LockyLockerson You literally can only point to one game he didn't perform well, and then say you can't point to one game regarding the heisman.
Idiotic take. Quite literally everyone who is paid to understand football sees and talks about how Carr has phenomenal football IQ, reads and diagnoses plays ore snap, makes adjustments, and goes through his progressions on an elite level.
Guys like you are just so used to trying to "scout" a player based on new age college characteristics that almost never translates to the NFL
@BotsForEveryone@TaylorTwellman I mean it's pretty clearly defined in this instance that a player must complete the catch and survive the ground or a football move.
It was a clear incomplete and immediately called so correctly.