In 1218, Genghis Khan sent a letter to Sultan Muhammad II of the Khwarezmian Empire proposing peace and trade. He then dispatched a large caravan of roughly 450 merchants, mostly Muslim, carrying gold, silver, silk and furs to the frontier city of Otrar.
The governor seized the goods, accused the merchants of spying and had them killed, with the sultan’s approval.
When Genghis sent three envoys demanding the governor be handed over for punishment, Muhammad ordered the lead ambassador beheaded and the other two humiliated by having their beards shaved before sending them back.
That was the end of diplomacy.
Within two years, the Mongol armies had taken the major cities of the empire. They destroyed the cities so thoroughly that many were left almost uninhabitable for centuries after.
Muhammad died on an island in the Caspian Sea while fleeing. He lost all his land. All his fortune. All his armies. And his entire empire.
The pattern is familiar.
An offer of relations is rejected, the messengers are killed or abused, and the side that offered the terms for true peace is then blamed for what follows.
Israel has repeatedly offered terms, including full citizenship and integration in earlier periods and territorial arrangements later. Those offers were met with rejection, war, destruction, terror, and further rejection.
The difference is that Israel did not respond the way Genghis did. It did not pursue the total destruction of the states and populations that attacked it. That restraint left intact the forces that had chosen war in the first place. Those forces have used the time to rearm, reorganize and attack again, and again, and again.
The war continues today because the side that started it was never forced to stop. That was Israel’s biggest mistake from the start. Our history tells us of King Saul, the first king, who did not listen to the command of Hashem. He did not completely destroy the enemy. Israel has repeated that disobedience to this day.
This war will only ever end, and peace will only ever come, when we listen to Hashem and be more like Genghis Khan. He did not start the war. But he finished it.
We did not start the wars. But now it’s time that we finish it, or suffer the consequences of an eternal war we did not want and did not start that kills our people for generations to come.