@TateAlSalafi@grok@ParadiseSeek3r@Kneel_Muhammad Is it not History as narrated by the people who odserved and lived with Mujamnad. In this case the history cannot emanate from Muhammad but from Abdullah's father hwho gathers these facts from Abdullah the witness.
@TateAlSalafi@grok@ParadiseSeek3r@Kneel_Muhammad Is it a secret ? It would surfice to say that is all the information given, like I said the above passage might be a small verse in a long story. If you not willing to tell it all, those who know will answer.
@TateAlSalafi@grok@ParadiseSeek3r@Kneel_Muhammad A story can't start with Abdullah being sent to Muhammad , need not specified .was Adbullah sneeking on Muhammad ? If his father had sent him did he get what he was sent for? What did he witness. I cant get all that from a single paragraph Im seeing for the first time.
@TateAlSalafi@grok@ParadiseSeek3r@Kneel_Muhammad And are you stupid. Im asking for actual events as described. No rent seeking . Those are facts of events.. Abdulah slept behind Mohammad . Jibril did not address Abdullal but it was Muhamnad who says that was Jibril after he departs ( assuming)
@TateAlSalafi@grok@ParadiseSeek3r@Kneel_Muhammad And you are stupid. Im asking for actual events as described. No rent seeking . Those are facts of events. Whether Mohammad sleeping .but Abdulah slept behind him. Jibril did not address Abdullal but it was Muhamnad who says that was Jibril after he departs ( assuming)
@sarrifomuta@grok@Sverecundus@Kruveux@provingislam Did the children of Israel know when GOD was going to lead them out of Egypt enduring years of servitude and slavery. If you can't pick when GOD foretold the year, then I will demand an answer to Jesus not knowing.
@TateAlSalafi@grok@ParadiseSeek3r@Kneel_Muhammad Jibril does not address Abdullah , heither is there an indication what the two of them were engaged in. Since this is my first time to see this , I can only seek clarity, why Avdullah was sent to Mohammad, is it cultural to sleep behind someone you are sent to.
@grok@ParadiseSeek3r@Kneel_Muhammad Now if this is an angel who is supposed to introduce who to whom. Its a pity the hadith does not tell us what was Muhammad doing with this Jibril. Whatever it is we are none tge wiser.
@grok@ParadiseSeek3r@Kneel_Muhammad This is a description as narrated by Abdullah . Who finds Muhammad in the company of a man unbeknown to him. Abdullah slept behind Muhammad. At this point Mohammad is either sitting/ sleeping/standing with his back to Abdullah . He turns around to ask if he saw the man.
@grok@ParadiseSeek3r@Kneel_Muhammad@grok being incoherent . I asked you to put a picture of events. Muhammad was not aware of Abdullah's arrival , hence he asks what did he see. In simple terms he found the prophet with an unidentified man. He did not notice Abdullal , who slept behind the prophet
@a_random_sauce@Elden_to What are you saying. Or failing to say. Rebecca was more than 3 years! Can you send a 3 year old to draw water for animals from a well?
@grok@ParadiseSeek3r@Kneel_Muhammad Who said anything sexual? Abdullah slept behind the prophet . After finding Muhammad with another man whom Muhammad called Jibril. Care to put the scene in a picture form.
It wasnβt Jibreel the boy saw. It was Dihya - the handsome man who was with Muhammad.
No wonder the Prophet got nervous when the boy walked in and caught him with Dihya.