@TherealZinney@RETURNOFGD But it also glorifies guns, personal liberties and capitalism. And in itself, it is an exercise of free speech (which liberals tend to frown upon).
@TMJM114@AndrewWillLaw@JLM4CivilRights My only point is that, we’ve gone beyond the realm of “right-vs-wrong” black-letter rules of English construction, and into the realm of “there are valid takes on both sides.” Thats where the Heller debate belongs
@TMJM114@AndrewWillLaw@JLM4CivilRights I could make a case that Wade’s “term of art” is less honest than Heller’s. I could say, for instance, that Brennan’s omission of “understanding” (which is distinct from intelligence) alters the meaning of the waiver in question.
@TMJM114@AndrewWillLaw@JLM4CivilRights Ok so:
“Intelligently and understandingly waive” supports “intelligent waiver”, but
“dangerous or unusual weapons” does not support “dangerous and unusual weapons”…
You do realize the latter case is arguably closer, given that it’s literally *one* word off?
@TMJM114@AndrewWillLaw@JLM4CivilRights The sentence is deliberately impervious to attack based on form (he must have known his test would infuriate gun-control zealots who would be eager to poke holes). I promise you, you are not as pedantic as Justice Scalia.
@TMJM114@AndrewWillLaw@JLM4CivilRights As for your backup argument:
Trying to go after “See” in the Heller quote as improper b/c insufficient support (due to and/or discrepancy), is a dead end: sentence starts with “We think”, and calls the term “fairly supported.” By weakening his own claim he makes it bulletproof.
@TMJM114@AndrewWillLaw@JLM4CivilRights A “term of interpretive art”—that’s exactly how I would describe “strict scrutiny,” and it’s exactly how I’d describe “dangerous and unusual weapons.”
By the way, the vast majority of lawyers on this app disagree with you (see: SLS prof. Orin Kerr, for example).
@atlblog Aha! The backup argument!
Trying to go after “See” in the Heller quote as improper b/c insufficient support (due to and/or discrepancy), is a dead end: sentence starts with “We think”, and calls the term “fairly supported.” By weakening his own claim he makes it bulletproof.
@NYTimesPR@dealbook@nytimes Wade (1967) (“intelligent waiver”), Casey (1992) (“strict scrutiny”): both feature a sentence ending in a phrase in quotes, followed by a See signal, where the source does not contain the verbiage in the quoted phrase. Hope NYT demonstrates journalistic integrity here.
@TMJM114@AndrewWillLaw@JLM4CivilRights Its a free country 🤷♂️
My only request is that you also apply your “unique” understanding of quotes to:
Wade (1967): (“intelligent waiver”)
Casey (1992): (“strict scrutiny”)
Both opinions feature the exact same construction as Heller. So I guess all three are “misquotes.”
@DDi90@EWess92 Casey (1992) (O’Connor, J.)
with its concomitant requirement that any state regulation of abortion survive "strict scrutiny." See Payne v. Tennessee
“Strict scrutiny” does not show up in Payne.
@USSpaceLawyer@wrdcsc Even if you try to go after “See” in the Heller quote as improper b/c not enough support (due to and/or discrepancy), its a dead end: he starts the sentence with “We think”, and calls the term “fairly supported”, weakening his own claim just to ensure it’s bulletproof. Genius.
@earlymodjustice@AnthonyMKreis@legalstyleblog@jadler1969 Haha, setting quotes around terms of art is common practice in English
https://t.co/azAf3lG7xk
https://t.co/xHe9eqOkUH
https://t.co/ify9JdmZCB
Lawyers who aren’t judges and don’t make doctrine are likely not spending much time using this construction, though
@OrinKerr Hit ctrl-F for [” See ] and scrolled through Justia opinions for 5 minutes, found the exact same constructions as Scalia’s all over. 3/4 turned out to be direct quotes, 1/4 were not…
Wade (1967) (“intelligent waiver”) and Casey (1992) (“strict scrutiny”), for example.
@AnthonyMKreis@legalstyleblog@earlymodjustice@jadler1969 Heller (2008) (“dangerous and unusual weapons”); Wade (1967) (“intelligent waiver”); Casey (1992) (“strict scrutiny”). 3 different justices, over 40 years, all commit the exact same “drafting error.”
The good news is that you’ve learned a new use for quotations.
@earlymodjustice O’Connor makes the same “error” in Casey (1992). Do you really want to take the route of accusing every Supreme Court justice of being a sloppy drafter?